01Facts
The applicant was appointed as Senior Telecom Office Assistant on 01.03.1982 and as Junior Accounts Officer on 14.06.2010.
pp. 1–2He was absorbed in BSNL under Rule 37A of the CCS (Pension) Rules, promoted to Accounts Officer, and voluntarily retired on 31.01.2020 while serving as Accounts Officer (Cash), GMTD Himatnagar.
pp. 1–2Charge memorandum dated 05.10.2020 was issued under Rules 36 and 61 of the BSNL CDA Rules, 2006, concerning irregularities between 01.07.2017 and 31.01.2020.
p. 2 · p. 20The Presenting Officer's written brief stated that the charges were "NOT PROVED".
p. 2The Inquiry Officer nonetheless held the charges proved in his report dated 12.05.2022.
p. 2 · p. 20The Disciplinary Authority's memorandum dated 13.06.2022 recorded its agreement with that report before the applicant's representation was invited.
p. 2 · p. 20The applicant contended that a 2015 departmental order (A/14) transferred cheque collection and deposit to CSC in-charges, that AO (CMTS) was responsible for franchisee monitoring under the Sales and Distribution Policy, 2018, and that the ERP system permitted unlimited top-up balances on single cheques.
pp. 3–5 · pp. 12–13The Disciplinary Authority imposed a 25% cut in monthly pension for five years by order dated 06.02.2023.
p. 2 · p. 20The appeal was rejected on 21.09.2023 and the review petition on 07.10.2024.
p. 2 · p. 20The applicant also contended that the post-retirement proceedings lacked the sanction required under Rule 9(2)(b)(i) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
p. 26The respondents maintained that the applicant, as AO (Cash) and DDO, was responsible for overall monitoring of cash and cheque collections and bank reconciliation.
pp. 16–1702Issues
i.1. Whether the Inquiry Officer acted beyond his quasi-judicial role in holding the charges proved despite the Presenting Officer's conclusion that they were not proved, and whether those findings are sustainable in law.
pp. 21–23ii.2. Whether the findings recorded against the applicant suffer from perversity or are based on no evidence.
pp. 23–25iii.3. Whether disciplinary proceedings initiated after retirement are legally sustainable in the absence of the requisite statutory sanction.
pp. 25–26iv.4. Whether the penalty suffers from arbitrariness, discrimination, or disproportionality.
pp. 27–2803Law Applied
The Tribunal applied the scope-of-review principles in B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India, (1995) 6 SCC 749, under which the disciplinary authority is the sole judge of facts, and courts interfere only where findings are perverse or based on no evidence.
pp. 19–20The Tribunal relied on the principle in State Bank of India v. Ajay Kumar Srivastava that findings in departmental proceedings must rest on evidence that would enable an objective person to reach them, and cannot rest on conjecture.
p. 22 · p. 24The Presenting Officer's conclusion is not binding on the Inquiry Officer, but a contrary finding must be supported by a reasoned evaluation of the material evidence.
p. 22On post-retirement proceedings, the Tribunal required compliance with the statutory sanction requirement under Rule 9(2)(b)(i) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, as a condition precedent.
p. 26On proportionality, the Tribunal relied on P. Gunasekaran and State of Karnataka v. Umesh, under which quantum of punishment may be interfered with where it is disproportionate to the proven misconduct.
p. 27The respondents relied on Union of India v. Parma Nanda, (1989) 2 SCC 177.
p. 17The applicant cited State Bank of India v. Navin Kumar Sinha in support of his retirement argument, but the Tribunal's reasoning on that point rests on the sanction requirement.
p. 15 · p. 26Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138
04Reasoning
The Tribunal held that the Inquiry Officer's disagreement with the Presenting Officer was not by itself impermissible, but that the report had to be supported by a cogent analysis of the material evidence.
pp. 22–23It found that the report and the subsequent orders did not address the 2015 departmental order, the allocation of duties among officers, the testimony of SW-1, SW-4 and SW-6, or the configuration of the ERP system, all of which bore directly on attribution of responsibility.
p. 23 · p. 25The Tribunal noted that the applicant's defence raised a threshold question of whether the misconduct was attributable to him at all, not merely a challenge to the adequacy of evidence, and that his designation as AO (Cash) could not by itself establish that responsibility.
pp. 24–25The Tribunal recorded that the authorities had not explained how the delay in depositing cheques or the irregular franchisee credit was attributable to the applicant.
pp. 25–26On the sanction issue, the Tribunal held that the respondents did not demonstrate compliance with Rule 9(2)(b)(i) for a charge memorandum issued more than eight months after retirement, and that this objection went to the root of jurisdiction.
pp. 26–27On discrimination, the Tribunal noted that officers with operational responsibility received lesser penalties while the retired applicant, who had no physical custody of cheques, received a larger cut, and that the authorities had not examined these comparative roles.
pp. 27–28Having found the underlying findings unsustainable, the Tribunal held that the penalty could not stand independently of them.
p. 2805Holding
The Tribunal answered the issues against the respondents. The Inquiry Officer's findings were not supported by reasoned analysis of material evidence, the findings were not sustained by evidence attributing the misconduct to the applicant, post-retirement proceedings lacked demonstrated statutory sanction, and the penalty could not survive independently of the findings.
p. 23 · pp. 25–28The OA was allowed. The Tribunal quashed the charge memorandum dated 05.10.2020, the Inquiry Officer's report dated 12.05.2022, the penalty order dated 06.02.2023, the appellate order dated 21.09.2023, and the reviewing order dated 07.10.2024. It exonerated the applicant of the charges, directed restoration of full pension and refund of amounts deducted within two months of receipt of a certified copy, and granted consequential benefits in accordance with the applicable rules. There was no order as to costs.
p. 29Original Court PDF
Parimal Bhanuprasad PanditvsBHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Tribunal Quashes 25% Pension Cut On Retired BSNL Officer Over Franchisee Cheques, Finds No Reasonable Link To His Duties. Parimal Bhanuprasad Pandit vs BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/tribunal-quashes-25-pension-cut-on-retired-bsnl-officer-over-franchisee-cheques-finds-no-r-d419fe946bd44c4a8e3caa36e4bcfda1.webp)