CAT - ['Ahmedabad']Employment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

BSNL Engineer Denied Executive Engineer Promotion: Officiating SDE Years Don't Count as Regular Service

praDipsinh B thakorv.BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED

BSNL Engineer Denied Executive Engineer Promotion: Officiating SDE Years Don't Count as Regular Service. praDipsinh B thakor vs BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the OA is within limitation for each of the reliefs claimed and, if not, whether the delay should be condoned.

The court held

The challenge to Respondent No. 5's promotion (Prayer D) is time-barred and delay is not condoned, with no opinion on its merits

It also directed

The claim to regular SDE promotion from 10.06.2008 is barred and delay is not condoned

The applicant was not eligible for promotion from 01.01.2016 and has shown no right to promotion in any round held before the OA was filed, so Prayers B, C, and G are dismissed on merits

The Tribunal disposed of pending miscellaneous applications and made no order as to costs

The Tribunal expressed no view on the equivalence question

01Facts

The applicant joined the Department of Telecommunications as Junior Engineer (Electrical) on 21.01.1991 and was absorbed in BSNL from 01.10.2000

¶ 2.1 · ¶ 8.1

He officiated as AE/SDE (Electrical) from 26.02.2001 and was regularly promoted as SDE (Electrical) with effect from 16.02.2010, joining on 15.03.2010

¶ 2.2 · ¶ 8.2

The applicant sought promotion to Executive Engineer (Electrical) with effect from 01.01.2016 under the BSNL Management Services Recruitment Rules, 2009 (MSRR 2009)

¶ 2.3

Clause (b) of the relevant entry requires regular SDE/AE service of seven years as on "1 January of the year" for engineering graduates

¶ 8.3

The applicant disputes only the date from which his regular service counts

¶ 8.3

Respondent No. 5 was promoted by order dated 29.06.2018 and the applicant was placed at serial No. 380 in the provisional seniority list dated 03.11.2016, against Respondent No. 5 at serial No. 122

¶ 8.4

Fifty-three officers were promoted by order dated 09.11.2022, not including the applicant

¶ 8.4

The applicant made a representation on 18.04.2023, rejected on 30.10.2023 while the OA was pending, and filed the OA on 25.09.2023 without any application for condonation of delay

¶ 2.4 · ¶ 8.5 · ¶ 9

Earlier, the applicant had litigated in OA No. 417/2012, the order in which was challenged in SCA No. 14581/2016

¶ 4.3 · ¶ 9.3

02Issues

i.1. Whether the OA is within limitation for each of the reliefs claimed and, if not, whether the delay should be condoned.

¶ 7.1 · ¶ 9

ii.2. Whether the applicant is entitled to promotion as Executive Engineer (Electrical) with effect from 01.01.2016 or any later date, and to the further promotions claimed in Prayer G.

¶ 7.2 · ¶ 10

03Law Applied

The Tribunal applied Section 21(1) and 21(3) of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, which require an OA within one year of the final order (or of the expiry of six months after a representation), and permit later admission only on "sufficient cause"

¶ 9

Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar: a representation on a stale claim does not restart limitation

¶ 9.2

P.S. Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil Nadu: aggrieved persons must approach court within a reasonable time; settled promotions should not be disturbed after many years

¶ 9.2

Shiba Shankar Mohapatra v. State of Orissa: seniority and promotion must be challenged within a reasonable time

¶ 9.2

Under MSRR 2009, promotion requires seven years of regular service, and an employee has a right to be considered under the Rules but no right to promotion from a date of his choice

¶ 8.3 · ¶ 10

Officiating service is not regular service for this purpose

¶ 10

A claim to be considered in a particular round arises when that round is held

¶ 9.4

V. Vincent Velankanni v. Union of India (2024 INSC 748): settled seniority lists should not be reopened after long periods

¶ 11.1

State of Tamil Nadu v. R. Sasipriya (2026 INSC 446): stale claims and fence-sitters are disfavoured once third-party rights crystallise

¶ 11.1

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19Section 21

04Reasoning

The Tribunal divided the OA into three claims with different limitation dates

¶ 9.1

The challenge to Respondent No. 5's promotion dated 29.06.2018 was filed over four years after the one-year period expired on 28.06.2019. The representation of 18.04.2023 could not revive the stale claim under M.K. Sarkar, and no explanation was offered, so delay was not condoned

¶ 9.2

The Tribunal therefore expressed no view on whether Respondent No. 5 held the required educational qualification, which disposed of the related submissions

¶ 9.2

The claim that regular SDE promotion should date from 10.06.2008 was raised for the first time in the rejoinder, without amending the OA. It was also made over thirteen years after the 16.02.2010 promotion, although the applicant knew of the grievance from OA No. 417/2012. Delay was not condoned, and the Tribunal did not reach the respondents' res judicata objection

¶ 9.3

On merits, the applicant completed seven years of regular SDE service only on 15.02.2017, so he lacked the required service on 01.01.2016 and on 01.01.2017

¶ 10

His satisfactory APAR record bears on suitability but cannot substitute for the qualifying service the Rules require

¶ 10.1

For later rounds, the respondents stated he could be considered from 2018, and he was placed at serial No. 380 behind senior officers who had to be considered first

¶ 10.2

He did not challenge the 03.11.2016 seniority list or the 09.11.2022 order, and he did not show that any junior officer was promoted

¶ 10.2

The Tribunal declined to decide the effect of the equivalence orders in OA No. 2905/2015, OA No. 892/2018, and SCA No. 16060/2016, because the officers promoted under that equivalence, other than Respondent No. 5, were not parties and the challenge to Respondent No. 5 was time-barred

¶ 10.3

Prayer G depended on promotion to Executive Engineer from 01.01.2016, so it failed with that claim

¶ 10.4

05Holding

The challenge to Respondent No. 5's promotion (Prayer D) is time-barred and delay is not condoned, with no opinion on its merits

¶ 9.2 · ¶ 11(i) · ¶ 12(i)

The claim to regular SDE promotion from 10.06.2008 is barred and delay is not condoned

¶ 9.3 · ¶ 11(ii) · ¶ 12(i)

The applicant was not eligible for promotion from 01.01.2016 and has shown no right to promotion in any round held before the OA was filed, so Prayers B, C, and G are dismissed on merits

¶ 10 · ¶ 10.2 · ¶ 10.4 · ¶ 12(ii)

The Tribunal disposed of pending miscellaneous applications and made no order as to costs

¶ 12(iii)–(iv)

The Tribunal expressed no view on the equivalence question

¶ 10.3
CAT - ['Ahmedabad']

Original Court PDF

praDipsinh B thakorvsBHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED

CAT - ['Ahmedabad'] · October 30, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment