CAT - ['Ahmedabad']Administrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Tribunal Denies Income Tax Officer 1994 Seniority After Inter-Charge Transfer, Says Transfer Terms Bind

Prem Meenav.D/o Income Tax

Tribunal Denies Income Tax Officer 1994 Seniority After Inter-Charge Transfer, Says Transfer Terms Bind. Prem Meena vs D/o Income Tax. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the applicant is entitled to restoration of her seniority in the Gujarat Charge Inspector cadre from her initial appointment at Delhi (04.07.1994) instead of from her joining date (09.01.1998).

The court held

Issues 1 and 2 are answered in the negative. The applicant's seniority in the Gujarat Charge is correctly reckoned from 09.01.1998, and Pratibha Rani does not automatically entitle her to restoration of seniority from 04.07.1994.

It also directed

Issue 3 is answered in the negative: she cannot be placed immediately after the 2003-based DPC because she did not satisfy the eligibility conditions as on the crucial date.

Issue 4 is answered in the affirmative: the respondents were justified in not considering her for the earlier vacancies.

The Original Application is dismissed for want of merit. Pending MAs, if any, stand dismissed, with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The applicant was appointed as a direct-recruit Inspector of Income Tax and joined at Delhi on 04.07.1994.

¶ 2.1

Pursuant to an inter-Charge transfer, she joined the Gujarat Charge on 09.01.1998.

¶ 2.1

Her seniority was fixed at the bottom of the Gujarat Charge Inspector seniority list from the date of joining, which she contends prejudiced her service career by disregarding her Delhi service.

¶ 2.2

She relied on Pratibha Rani v. Union of India (SC, 10.04.2019) and made representations, which the respondents kept in abeyance pending a committee constituted by CBDT.

¶ 2.3, 2.9

The Tribunal's earlier order in OA No. 197/2020 directed disposal of her representation, but the subsequent representations were not answered, leading to the present OA.

¶ 2.10

On promotion, the applicant appeared in the departmental examination in July 2003 and did not qualify.

¶ 2.4

The Income Tax Officer Recruitment Rules, 2004 (notified 21.12.2004) deleted the departmental examination requirement, so no examination was held in 2004 and 2005.

¶ 2.4

Ad hoc promotions and DPCs were held on multiple dates, including 02.03.2005 and 01.11.2006 to 01.03.2007.

¶ 2.5, 10.1

A 24.03.2005 amendment, retrospective to 21.12.2004, reintroduced the examination requirement.

¶ 2.6

The applicant qualified the October 2006 examination on 17.04.2007, was promoted as ITO in May 2007, and was assigned seniority after the DPCs held before her qualification.

¶ 2.7, 4.8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the applicant is entitled to restoration of her seniority in the Gujarat Charge Inspector cadre from her initial appointment at Delhi (04.07.1994) instead of from her joining date (09.01.1998).

¶ 7(i)

ii.2. Whether Pratibha Rani & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. applies to her claim for restoration of seniority in the new Charge.

¶ 7(ii)

iii.3. Whether the applicant is entitled to reallocation of her ITO-cadre seniority so as to be placed immediately after the DPC based on the 2003 examination.

¶ 7(iii)

iv.4. Whether the respondents were justified in not considering the applicant for promotion against vacancies of the relevant year, given she had not qualified the examination as on the crucial date.

¶ 7(iv)

03Law Applied

CBDT Circular F. No. 22020/76/89-Ad.VII dated 14.05.1990, para. (f), provides that service in the old Charge is not counted for seniority in the new Charge and the transferee is placed at the bottom of the new Charge's list from the date of joining.

¶ 4.3, 8.1

The transfer order dated 09.01.1998 expressly stipulated the same position.

¶ 8.2

Seniority is governed by applicable rules and instructions, and an employee cannot claim seniority in a new cadre or Charge based solely on previous service where the transfer policy provides otherwise.

¶ 8.4

Union of India v. C.N. Ponnappan, (1996) 1 SCC 524, holds that seniority and eligibility for promotion are distinct concepts, so past service may count for eligibility without preserving seniority.

¶ 9.3

The Recruitment Rules notified 21.12.2004 and amended 24.03.2005 (retrospective) make passing the departmental examination a condition precedent to promotion.

¶ 10.2

Eligibility is determined by the prescribed crucial date, here 01.01.2003.

¶ 10.4, 10.6

Rule 14 of the Rules for Departmental Examination for ITOs, 2004 provides that delay in holding the examination or declaring results gives no right to deemed eligibility and permits no relaxation.

¶ 11.1

State of Maharashtra v. Jagannath Achyut Karandikar, 1989 Supp (1) SCC 393, and M.M. Thomas v. Union of India, (2017) 13 SCC 722, were cited by the parties but the Tribunal's reasoning does not expressly rely on them.

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The applicant accepted a transfer order that expressly fixed her seniority from her joining date and placed her below existing Gujarat Charge Inspectors. She did not challenge those terms, so the Tribunal found no infirmity in reckoning seniority from 09.01.1998.

¶ 8.3, 8.5

The Tribunal drew a distinction between counting previous service for eligibility or experience and carrying forward seniority into a new Charge. It held that Pratibha Rani does not confer an automatic or unrestricted right to seniority that overrides a transfer policy providing for bottom placement.

¶ 9.2, 9.4

The applicant had not qualified the 2003 examination and therefore could not be placed after the 2003-based DPC. Qualification was obtained only on 17.04.2007, and the Recruitment Rules made the examination an essential eligibility condition.

¶ 10.3, 10.5, 10.8

The Department's failure to hold examinations in 2004–2005 was an administrative lapse that could not create a retrospective right absent fulfilment of prescribed eligibility conditions.

¶ 10.7

Rule 14 bars deemed eligibility for delay in examination or result declaration, and the applicant could not claim the benefit of ad hoc promotions made to others before declaration of her result. The Tribunal distinguished the Allahabad Bench decision in Ashwani Kumar Singh (OA 936/2005) and the Principal Bench decision in Sanjeev Kumar Meena (OA 3434/2016), relied on by the applicant.

¶ 11.2, 11.3

The applicant's challenge to the 2015 and 2018 All-India seniority lists raised delay and laches issues, but the Tribunal did not base its decision on them.

¶ 4.12

05Holding

Issues 1 and 2 are answered in the negative. The applicant's seniority in the Gujarat Charge is correctly reckoned from 09.01.1998, and Pratibha Rani does not automatically entitle her to restoration of seniority from 04.07.1994.

¶ 8.5, 9.4

Issue 3 is answered in the negative: she cannot be placed immediately after the 2003-based DPC because she did not satisfy the eligibility conditions as on the crucial date.

¶ 10.8

Issue 4 is answered in the affirmative: the respondents were justified in not considering her for the earlier vacancies.

¶ 11.2–11.3

The Original Application is dismissed for want of merit. Pending MAs, if any, stand dismissed, with no order as to costs.

¶ 12, 13
CAT - ['Ahmedabad']

Original Court PDF

Prem MeenavsD/o Income Tax

CAT - ['Ahmedabad'] · October 23, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment

Related judgments

Recent judgments that share this one’s subject or court. Hover a card to read what was held.

All Administrative and Public Law judgments →