CAT - ['Ahmedabad']Administrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Widow Loses ₹9 Lakh Claim For Husband's CBI Defence, As Alleged Corruption Isn't Official Duty

ASLESHA MEHTAv.All India Radio

Widow Loses ₹9 Lakh Claim For Husband's CBI Defence, As Alleged Corruption Isn't Official Duty. ASLESHA MEHTA vs All India Radio. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the communication dated 15.10.2019 confers a right to reimbursement of the legal expenses incurred by late Shri Mihir Mehta in defending CBI Special Case No. 06/2009.

The court held

The communication dated 15.10.2019 confers no right to reimbursement of legal expenses, and the proceedings in CBI Special Case No. 06/2009 did not arise from acts done in the discharge of official duties, so the OM dated 08.01.1959 does not apply.

It also directed

The applicant is not entitled to reimbursement of the expenses incurred by her late husband.

Reliefs (B) and (C), seeking a declaration of inaction and payment of ₹9,00,000, are refused. The OA is dismissed with no order as to costs, and any pending MA stands disposed of.

01Facts

The applicant, a Transmission Executive with Doordarshan Kendra, Ahmedabad, is the widow of Shri Mihir Mehta, a former Programme Executive with All India Radio who retired from service.

¶ 2.1

The CBI registered RC-2(A)/2008, which led to CBI Special Case No. 06/2009. Both the applicant and her husband were accused.

¶ 2.2

On 04.05.2019 the CBI Special Court acquitted Shri Mehta.

¶ 2.3

Disciplinary proceedings against him under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, were closed on 02.06.2022 following his death.

¶ 2.4

The Directorate General, All India Radio, by letter dated 15.10.2019, addressed TA for attending CBI proceedings and the treatment of the period spent there as duty, referring to Supplementary Rules 153-A and 154.

¶ 2.5 · ¶ 7.2

On 21.07.2020 Shri Mehta sought reimbursement of ₹9,00,000 as legal expenses, together with TA and duty treatment.

¶ 2.6

He died on 25.11.2021, and the applicant pursued the claim.

¶ 2.7 · ¶ 7.10

The CBI has appealed the acquittal to the Gujarat High Court, and that appeal is pending.

¶ 4.2 · ¶ 7.10

The respondents issued a speaking order dated 24.08.2022 rejecting the claim.

¶ 4.7

The invoice gave no item-wise break-up, and the respondents contended that the fees could not be attributed exclusively to the deceased.

¶ 4.3 · ¶ 7.11

02Issues

i.1. Whether the communication dated 15.10.2019 confers a right to reimbursement of the legal expenses incurred by late Shri Mihir Mehta in defending CBI Special Case No. 06/2009.

¶ 7(i) · ¶ 7.2–7.5

ii.2. Whether the proceedings in CBI Special Case No. 06/2009 arose out of acts done by late Shri Mihir Mehta in the discharge of his official duties, so as to bring the claim within the instructions governing reimbursement of legal expenses.

¶ 7(ii) · ¶ 7.6–7.10

03Law Applied

The Tribunal relied principally on the Ministry of Home Affairs O.M. No. F-45/5/53-Ests.(A) dated 08.01.1959.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 2(a) permits reimbursement of defence costs only for proceedings connected with official duties or position, and only where the proceedings conclude in the Government servant's favour and the Government is satisfied that he was subjected to the strain of proceedings without proper justification.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 2(b) bars any assistance for matters not connected with official duties.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 4 requires that the act bear such relation to official duties that a reasonable, not fanciful, claim can be made that it was done in the performance of duty.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 5 vests the decision in the administrative Ministry, after consulting Finance and Law where necessary.

¶ 7.4, 7.6

Article 320(3)(d) of the Constitution, which requires UPSC consultation, applies only to acts done or purporting to be done in the execution of duty.

¶ 4.6 · ¶ 7.9

Supplementary Rules 153-A and 154 govern TA for attending proceedings and the duty treatment of such periods.

¶ 4.4–4.5 · ¶ 7.2

No estoppel or legitimate expectation can arise contrary to governing instructions.

¶ 7.5

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 168Section 420

Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 13

04Reasoning

The Tribunal held that the 15.10.2019 communication is a TA and duty-treatment advisory, not a sanction of legal expenses.

¶ 7.2

Paragraph 2(i) makes TA conditional on reimbursement ("only if"), which treats reimbursement as uncertain rather than assured. Paragraph 2(ii) treats attendance at CBI proceedings as the employee's own affair to be covered by leave, not as duty.

¶ 7.3

Because a claim for legal expenses lies with the administrative Ministry under OM paragraph 5, an office communication on TA could not decide or bind the Government on it.

¶ 7.4

Turning to the OM, the Tribunal reasoned that the connection with official duty is a threshold condition.

¶ 7.7

The applicant's own representation described the allegations of private firm trade, cheating and criminal misconduct for pecuniary advantage. The Tribunal held these are acts done for personal gain, where the official position merely furnished the occasion, so they do not arise from official duty.

¶ 7.8

The acquittal did not alter this, because the OM looks to the nature of the matter, not its outcome. Consequently the case falls under paragraph 2(b) and Article 320(3)(d) is inapplicable.

¶ 7.9

Even under paragraph 2(a), reimbursement requires a conclusion in the employee's favour. The CBI's appeal against the acquittal is pending, so the acquittal is not final.

¶ 7.10

The lump-sum invoice without item-wise break-up and the inconsistent claim regarding counsel's role were additional, unnecessary grounds.

¶ 7.11

The pendency of the representation created no legal right.

¶ 7.12

05Holding

The communication dated 15.10.2019 confers no right to reimbursement of legal expenses, and the proceedings in CBI Special Case No. 06/2009 did not arise from acts done in the discharge of official duties, so the OM dated 08.01.1959 does not apply.

¶ 7.12

The applicant is not entitled to reimbursement of the expenses incurred by her late husband.

¶ 7.13

Reliefs (B) and (C), seeking a declaration of inaction and payment of ₹9,00,000, are refused. The OA is dismissed with no order as to costs, and any pending MA stands disposed of.

¶ 7.13 · ¶ 8–10
CAT - ['Ahmedabad']

Original Court PDF

ASLESHA MEHTAvsAll India Radio

CAT - ['Ahmedabad'] · October 30, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment

Related judgments

Recent judgments that share this one’s subject or court. Hover a card to read what was held.

All Administrative and Public Law judgments →