01Facts
The applicant, initially a Khalasi, was promoted to Junior Clerk on 12.09.2011, subject to clearing a typing test within two years.
¶ 3.1 · ¶ 6Typing tests held in 2012 and 2013 were unsuccessful for him, and he was reverted. He challenged this in OA No. 315/2013.
¶ 3.2–3.4On 15.02.2017 the Tribunal directed one more typing test for the applicants. He qualified on 18.04.2017, with the result declared on 04.05.2017.
¶ 3.2–3.4Respondents then granted him proforma promotion to Senior Clerk with effect from 01.11.2013 and to Office Superintendent with effect from 29.12.2015.
¶ 3.8–3.14He opted for the Non-Ministerial category on 02.07.2019 and was promoted to Depot Material Superintendent (DMS) on 24.12.2019.
¶ 3.19–3.24Headquarters later advised that the promotions to Senior Clerk and Office Superintendent were erroneous and should be withdrawn (letter dated 26.05.2021), and clarified the dates as 2013 and 2015 (letter dated 19.08.2021).
¶ 3.26–3.27A show-cause notice dated 26.08.2021 proposed withdrawal of those promotions and regularisation as Junior Clerk from 04.05.2017.
¶ 3.28The applicant replied on 06.09.2021.
¶ 3.29In OA No. 360/2021, the Tribunal, on 14.09.2021, recorded that the reply was pending and expected its consideration in accordance with natural justice.
¶ 3.30The respondents' remarks followed on 30.09.2021. A personal hearing was fixed for 06.10.2021, but the applicant was on sanctioned leave from 04.10.2021 to 16.10.2021.
¶ 3.31–3.34Office Order No. E/56/2021 dated 07.10.2021 withdrew the promotions to Senior Clerk, Office Superintendent and DMS, reverted him to Senior Clerk with effect from 28.02.2020, and fixed pay at Rs. 31,000/-.
¶ 3.3502Issues
i.1. Whether the respondents were justified in withdrawing the applicant's promotions to Senior Clerk, Office Superintendent and DMS, and reverting him with retrospective effect from 28.02.2020 with pay revision, through Office Order dated 07.10.2021.
¶ 8.1ii.2. Whether the applicant's qualification in the additional typing test of 2017 validated his earlier promotions with retrospective effect.
¶ 8.4–8.5iii.3. Whether the respondent No. 3 was competent to withdraw the promotions, and whether the erroneous-promotion determination was made by the authority next higher than the appointing authority as required by IREM Para 228.
¶ 8.11–8.13iv.4. Whether the withdrawal of the DMS promotion was independently examined, given the applicant's option for the Non-Ministerial cadre.
¶ 8.13–8.14 · 9.2v.5. Whether the principles of natural justice were complied with, given the pending reply, the scheduled personal hearing and the applicant's sanctioned leave.
¶ 8.15–8.26vi.6. Whether the retrospective pay fixation and reversion were permissible in law.
¶ 10–10.403Law Applied
The Tribunal relied on the principle from Union of India v. Narendra Singh, (2008) 2 SCC 750, that an erroneous promotion, including one granted through the administration's mistake, may be corrected by applying the rules correctly, but only through due process and natural justice.
¶ 8.2The Tribunal applied Paragraph 228 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual (IREM) and Rule 1326 of the Indian Railway Establishment Code, Vol. II. Under these, an erroneous promotion must be cancelled, the employee restored to his correct position, and the question of erroneousness decided by an authority next higher than the appointing authority, except where the Railway Board or the President is the appointing authority.
¶ 8.7–8.8 · 6.7The Tribunal relied on Rajendra v. State of Maharashtra, (2008) 11 SCC 90, which disapproved abrupt cancellation without hearing the affected party.
¶ 8.18The Tribunal relied on Lt. Governor of Delhi v. Dr. Davindera Kumar, W.P.(C) No. 11186/2025 (Del. HC), which held that reversion after promotion entails civil consequences requiring natural justice.
¶ 8.19On recovery and pay, the Tribunal applied State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih, (2015) 4 SCC 334, which lists situations where recovery is impermissible.
¶ 10.2Railway Master Circular No. 34, Paras 20–20.4, governs administrative-error cases and consequential promotions.
¶ 5.6 · 9.5–9.6The Tribunal's order in OA No. 315/2013 (dated 15.02.2017) granted only a further typing test opportunity.
¶ 8.4Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution were considered for the discrimination plea.
¶ 9.3–9.4Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19
04Reasoning
The Tribunal held that the 2017 typing test qualification did not, by itself, validate the 2013 and 2015 promotions, since OA No. 315/2013 conferred no right to retrospective promotion or seniority.
¶ 8.4–8.5The Headquarters' communications showed a direction to examine and correct the promotions, and the 19.08.2021 letter only corrected dates and did not withdraw that direction. Therefore, the respondents were not barred from examining erroneousness, but the impugned order did not show an independent determination by the competent authority.
¶ 8.9–8.13The DMS promotion, being a separate Non-Ministerial promotion made after an option and Headquarters approval, required separate examination, and the impugned order did not do so.
¶ 8.14 · 9.1–9.2 · 10.4On natural justice, the show-cause notice was issued, and the Tribunal had expected the pending reply to be considered. However, the impugned order was passed the day after a hearing scheduled during the applicant's sanctioned leave, without awaiting his appearance, which rendered the opportunity illusory.
¶ 8.20–8.24The later hearing on 28.10.2021 could not cure this, because the order had already been passed and there was no evidence of reconsideration.
¶ 8.25On pay, the Tribunal held that the rationale for fixing pay at Rs. 31,000/- from 28.02.2020 was not shown, particularly given the DMS service rendered, and that correction of promotion must be distinguished from recovery.
¶ 10.1, 10.3Comparison with junior employees did not by itself establish entitlement. However, the respondents must examine such claims objectively.
¶ 9.3–9.405Holding
The Tribunal held that the respondents were entitled to correct an erroneous promotion, but that the impugned Office Order dated 07.10.2021 was unsustainable because it lacked an independent determination of erroneousness, failed to examine the DMS promotion separately, did not justify the retrospective pay fixation, and was passed without an effective opportunity of hearing.
¶ 11, 13The Original Application was partly allowed. The Tribunal set aside Office Order No. E/56/2021 dated 07.10.2021 and remitted the matter to the competent authority at Headquarters. The authority must: (i) examine eligibility for Senior Clerk and Office Superintendent in light of the typing tests; (ii) independently examine the DMS promotion, including the Non-Ministerial option and approvals; (iii) determine erroneousness under IREM Para 228 and Rule 1326; (iv) consider the reply dated 06.09.2021, the representation dated 01.10.2021, and the comparator plea; (v) afford an effective personal hearing if desired; and (vi) decide consequential seniority, pay fixation and promotion. A reasoned, speaking order must be passed within three months of receipt of a certified copy of the order. No order as to costs was made. The applicant's prayer for restoration of promotions with consequential benefits was not granted at this stage.
¶ 14–19Original Court PDF
Hariom MeenavsM/o Railways
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Railway Employee Reverted During Sanctioned Leave: Tribunal Quashes Order, Remits Matter for Fresh Decision. Hariom Meena vs M/o Railways. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/railway-employee-reverted-during-sanctioned-leave-tribunal-quashes-order-remits-matter-for-ac5450457902432eb0e4ad721da664eb.webp)