CAT - ['Ahmedabad']Administrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Law Graduate Who Joined As Railway Fitter On Compassionate Grounds Can't Claim Chief Law Assistant Post

AADILv.WESTERN RAILWAY

Law Graduate Who Joined As Railway Fitter On Compassionate Grounds Can't Claim Chief Law Assistant Post. AADIL vs WESTERN RAILWAY. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the applicant, appointed as Technician/Fitter Grade-III on compassionate grounds, was validly appointed despite his non-technical (LL.B.) qualification.

The court held

The applicant failed to establish any enforceable right to appointment as Chief Law Assistant on compassionate grounds from the date of his initial appointment as Technician/Fitter Grade-III, or to notional seniority and consequential benefits.

It also directed

No sufficient ground was found to set aside the communications dated 26.06.2024 and 14.08.2025 or the appointment order dated 13.02.2024.

The OA was dismissed, with no order as to costs, and any pending MA was disposed of.

01Facts

The applicant's father, an ASI in the Railway Protection Force, died in harness on 09.08.2021.

¶ 2.1

The applicant sought compassionate appointment. He failed the Physical Efficiency Test for Sub-Inspector, RPF, on 24.03.2022.

¶ 2.3

He then obtained 48/100 in the common CBT.

¶ 2.4

He was screened as medically fit.

¶ 2.5

He qualified the written examination for Station Master but failed the Psychological/Aptitude Test after a second chance.

¶ 2.6, 2.9

On 02.01.2024 the Screening Committee recommended him for Technician (Fitter) Grade-III, Level-2.

¶ 2.10

An offer dated 13.02.2024 was issued.

¶ 2.11

The applicant sought appointment as Welfare Inspector (15.02.2024) and, later, as Chief Law Assistant (CLA) (01.06.2024), citing his B.A., LL.B. (Labour Laws).

¶ 2.7, 2.11, 2.14, 23

The respondents rejected the Welfare Inspector request and directed him to join within 15 days.

¶ 2.12

He joined on 05.09.2024.

¶ 4.9, 10

Pursuant to an earlier Tribunal direction in O.A. No. 216/2025, the General Manager (Establishment) rejected the CLA request on 14.08.2025, holding that change of category was impermissible after acceptance of the offer and medical examination.

¶ 2.15, 2.16, 24

The applicant relied on the case of Ku. Shanu Singh, who was allotted Welder Grade-III and later appointed CLA.

¶ 2.13, 20

The applicant sought quashing of the orders dated 14.08.2025, 26.06.2024 and 13.02.2024, and a direction to appoint or reconsider him as CLA with notional seniority.

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the applicant, appointed as Technician/Fitter Grade-III on compassionate grounds, was validly appointed despite his non-technical (LL.B.) qualification.

¶ 11-15

ii.2. Whether the applicant has an enforceable right to appointment or reconsideration as Chief Law Assistant from the date of his initial appointment, with notional seniority and consequential benefits.

¶ 8, 16-18, 27

03Law Applied

The Railway Board's compassionate appointment instructions, RBE No. 113/2000 (10th pass as minimum qualification for Skilled Artisan Grade-III, with three years' training), prescribe the educational requirement for such appointments.

¶ 12.1

RBE Nos. 34/2008 and 166/2010 govern training for matriculates and for non-technical higher qualifications.

¶ 13

RBE Nos. 92/2024 and 51/2025 revise the training categories, and concern training period only.

¶ 14

RBE No. 274/1989 leaves the type of job offered to the discretion of the competent authority.

¶ 4.10

Under Master Circular No. 16, suitability is assessed by the Screening Committee, but the circular does not confer an unconditional right to a particular post.

¶ 19

RBE No. 26/2021 prescribes eligibility for CLA, but eligibility alone creates no automatic right.

¶ 18

Compassionate appointment is a concession, not a right, as held by the Supreme Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana, (1994) 4 SCC 138.

¶ 16-17

Belated claims to a higher post after appointment on a lower post fail, ignorance of law is no excuse, and negative discrimination cannot be claimed where no right exists, as applied in The Director of Town Panchayat v. M. Jayabal, Civil Appeal Nos. 12640-12643 of 2025 (decided 12.12.2025).

¶ 22, 23.1, 26

A case of another employee cannot create an enforceable right unless the cases are identical in all material respects.

¶ 21

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The Tribunal accepted the respondents' position that RBE No. 113/2000 sets a different educational requirement for compassionate appointment to Skilled Artisan Grade-III than open-market recruitment, so the absence of ITI/Act Apprenticeship did not render the appointment illegal.

¶ 12.1, 13, 15

The applicant's appointment was subject to prescribed training.

¶ 13, 15

The applicant's LL.B. qualification was relevant to eligibility but could not by itself create a right to a specific post.

¶ 16, 18, 27

The applicant had been screened for several categories and allotted a post by the Screening Committee. His representations sought a post of his choice based on educational qualification alone, and so fell within the principle in M. Jayabal.

¶ 23.1

The grounds now argued (Master Circular No. 16, RBE dated 07.08.2009, Shanu Singh, and Articles 14 and 16) were not raised in the representations and could not be faulted for not being considered.

¶ 23

The impugned order of 14.08.2025 was a reasoned decision on the request as actually made, and no lack of competence was shown.

¶ 24

The RTI reply on seniority did not establish a right to the CLA post.

¶ 25

The Tribunal distinguished Shanu Singh on material facts: transfer of her case to Vadodara, M.A./LL.M. qualifications, medical category B/1, and consideration against an anticipated vacancy.

¶ 20-21

The Tribunal distinguished the Principal Bench decision in O.A. No. 1128/2015 and the Jammu Bench decision in O.A. No. 61/1001/2021 as turning on different facts and on discrimination against similarly situated persons, which was absent here.

¶ 26

05Holding

The applicant failed to establish any enforceable right to appointment as Chief Law Assistant on compassionate grounds from the date of his initial appointment as Technician/Fitter Grade-III, or to notional seniority and consequential benefits.

¶ 27

No sufficient ground was found to set aside the communications dated 26.06.2024 and 14.08.2025 or the appointment order dated 13.02.2024.

¶ 27

The OA was dismissed, with no order as to costs, and any pending MA was disposed of.

¶ 28
CAT - ['Ahmedabad']

Original Court PDF

AADILvsWESTERN RAILWAY

CAT - ['Ahmedabad'] · November 05, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment

Related judgments

Recent judgments that share this one’s subject or court. Hover a card to read what was held.

All Administrative and Public Law judgments →