Bombay High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceArbitration and Mediation

Undertakings recorded in consent terms to the court sustain contempt despite arbitration and contractual remedies.

Tilak Nagar Sri Gurudatta Cooperative Housing Society Limitedv.Mishal Construction Pvt Ltd

Undertakings recorded in consent terms to the court sustain contempt despite arbitration and contractual remedies.. Tilak Nagar Sri Gurudatta Cooperative Housing Society Limited vs Mishal Construction Pvt Ltd. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Consent Terms dated 10 October 2024 contain undertakings given to this Court.

The court held

The Court answered Issue 1 in the affirmative: the Consent Terms contain undertakings to the Court.

It also directed

On Issues 2 and 3, the Court held that a prima facie case of wilful breach of the Clause 13 undertaking, and of the continuing cooperation undertakings in Clauses 7, 15 and 46 read with Clause 4, is made out. Contractual remedies and arbitration do not bar contempt proceedings.

On Issue 4, notice may issue under Rule 1035(1) read with Rule 1036.

The final order directs: (i) a show-cause notice to Respondent Nos. 1–3 under Section 12 read with Section 2(b) of the 1971 Act for alleged wilful breach of Clauses 7, 13, 15 and 46 read with Clause 4; (ii) the notice to cover Cheque Nos. 000955 (Rs. 51 lakhs) and 000956 (Rs. 77 lakhs) and the Rs. 77 lakh non-payment within the Clause 13 period; (iii) the notice to cover the alleged failure to cooperate in obtaining permissions and progressing the work; (iv) noting that service of the petition has already been effected under Rule 1036; (v) a 14-day reply period under Rule 1037, failing which the right to reply stands forfeited; and (vi) personal appearance of Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 on the returnable date unless dispensed with.

The notice excludes the separate October–November 2024 deadlines and the six-month completion period unless the MHADA revocation date is established. No final finding is recorded on guilt or on the personal liability of any Respondent. The petition is listed on 16 December 2026.

01Facts

The Petitioner, a co-operative housing society, appointed Respondent No. 1, Mishal Construction Pvt. Ltd., as developer under a Development Agreement dated 20 July 2010, supplemented on 10 November 2014. Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 are its directors.

¶ 1

Disputes over transit rent and delay led the Petitioner to terminate the agreements by notice dated 12 September 2023 and to file a Section 9 petition under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

¶ 1

The parties then signed Consent Terms on 10 October 2024, which the Court accepted on 17 October 2024, disposing of the petition in their terms.

¶ 1–2

The Consent Terms provide that the parties' obligations are "undertakings given to the Hon'ble Court" (Clause 4).

¶ 2

Under Clause 7, Respondent No. 1 is to complete the remaining work and obtain Full OC within six months of MHADA's revocation of the stop-work notice, with steps to be taken within 7 and 30 days.

¶ 4

The Consent Terms provide for a joint Project Bank Account and deposit obligations (Clauses 8, 11).

¶ 4

Under Clause 13, two cheques were issued: Rs. 51 lakhs, encashable only after MHADA permission and MahaRERA removal from abeyance; and Rs. 77 lakhs, for transit rent, payable by handover or within 180 days, whichever is earlier. Dishonour of "even one" cheque is to be treated as breach.

¶ 5

Clause 26 provides for arbitration of disputes after six months.

¶ 6

Clause 38 provides for revival of termination on breach, treated as an undertaking to the Court.

¶ 6

Clause 39 grants the Society the right to complete the work and deal with three unregistered flats.

¶ 7

Clause 46 contains a no-obstruction and cooperation covenant, with express preservation of execution and contempt remedies. See also Clauses 15, 56 and 57.

¶ 7, 29

Both cheques were returned unpaid on 5 December 2025 for "Funds Insufficient".

¶ 19

The Petitioner's letters of 11 September and 20 October 2025 sought funds and MahaRERA/MHADA action. Respondent No. 1 replied on 7 November 2025 seeking accounts and bank statements.

¶ 30–31

The Petitioner issued a termination confirmation notice dated 9 January 2026.

¶ 35

The Respondents resisted contempt on the grounds of contractual remedies, arbitration, unfulfilled cheque conditions, and the Petitioner's alleged non-disclosure of accounts.

¶ 9–10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Consent Terms dated 10 October 2024 contain undertakings given to this Court.

¶ 11(i) · ¶ 15, 41

ii.2. Whether the allegations and documents show a prima facie case of wilful breach of any continuing undertaking by the Respondents.

¶ 11(ii) · ¶ 19–33, 43–44

iii.3. Whether the Respondents can avoid contempt proceedings merely because the Consent Terms provide other remedies, including termination and arbitration.

¶ 11(iii) · ¶ 34–36, 42–43

iv.4. Whether notice can be issued against the three Respondents under the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules.

¶ 11(iv) · ¶ 13–14, 44–45

03Law Applied

Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 defines civil contempt to include a deliberate breach of an undertaking given to a Court. The failure must be wilful and deliberate, and not every contractual failure is contempt.

¶ 12

Under Rama Narang v. Ramesh Narang (2006) 11 SCC 114, a consent order's enforceability through execution does not bar contempt, but a clear undertaking to the Court is required. A promise to a party does not become an undertaking to the Court merely because it appears in a consent document, following Babu Ram Gupta v. Sudhir Bhasin (1980) 3 SCC 47.

¶ 12

Rules 1035(1), 1036 and 1037 of the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1980 govern the preliminary hearing, the issue of notice in Form I, personal presence, and a 14-day reply. At the notice stage, the material need only call for an explanation, not a final finding, citing Anchor Point Developer Ltd. v. PMT Machines Ltd., Contempt Petition (L) No. 32546 of 2026.

¶ 13–14

The Court relied on Nirmal Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Mamta Kennedy Naidu, 2019 SCC OnLine Bom 5636 and Starlift Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Alba Asia Pvt. Ltd., 2024 SCC OnLine Bom 1170 to distinguish cases where the consequences of default were set out in the order itself and the undertaking was given to the other party.

¶ 16–18

On limitation, Section 20 of the 1971 Act (one-year bar) applies, with Pallav Sheth v. Custodian (2001) 7 SCC 549 on the filing date. S. Tirupathi Rao v. M. Lingamaiah, 2024 INSC 544 holds that a completed breach does not become continuing merely because its effects persist.

¶ 37–38

Sections 12(4) and 12(5) of the Act govern the liability of directors.

¶ 40

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 Section 2Section 12Section 20

04Reasoning

On Issue 1, the Court relied on Clause 4, which expressly characterises the obligations as undertakings to the Court, the acceptance and recording of the Consent Terms, and the disposal of the Section 9 petition in their terms. Clauses 7 and 38 are likewise described as undertakings to the Court, so the document is not a mere private arrangement.

¶ 15, 41

On Issue 2, the Court found a prima facie breach of Clause 13. Clause 13 itself declares that dishonour of "even one" cheque is a breach, and both cheques were dishonoured for insufficient funds, which the Respondents did not deny.

¶ 21–22, 27, 43

The Respondents' argument that the Rs. 51 lakh cheque was not encashable because MHADA/MahaRERA conditions were unmet raises a factual question for explanation.

¶ 23

As to the Rs. 77 lakh cheque, the 180-day period expired in April 2025 and the Respondents did not show payment. The presentation date in December 2025 therefore did not answer the allegation.

¶ 24

On the cooperation allegations (Clauses 7, 15, 46), the Court noted that these clauses concern actual progress and not merely money. The September–November 2025 correspondence and Respondent No. 1's reply did not show what steps it had taken with MHADA and MahaRERA.

¶ 29–32

The accounts dispute was held not resolvable at this stage.

¶ 32

On Issue 3, the Court held that Clauses 38 and 39 (termination, flats) and Clause 26 (arbitration) do not oust the Court's power to examine a wilful breach of an undertaking. Clause 46 expressly preserves contempt proceedings.

¶ 18, 25–26, 35–36, 42

Disputed money claims such as transit rent belong in arbitration, but the question whether an express undertaking was deliberately breached differs from a claim for money. The Court also refused to treat termination as an absolute bar, while leaving the validity of the termination for later determination.

¶ 35–36

On limitation, the Court held that the fixed 7-day and 30-day steps of October–November 2024, and the six-month completion period (whose start date, MHADA's revocation of the stop-work notice, was not established), could not be treated as fresh breaches daily. The continuing non-cooperation obligation under Clause 46, evidenced by events from September 2025 to January 2026 and within one year of filing, was held within time.

¶ 37–39

The Court distinguished Nirmal Urban and Starlift on the basis that those orders stipulated their own consequences and did not contain an undertaking to the Court in the same terms.

¶ 16–18

On directors, the Court held that Respondent Nos. 2 and 3, who signed the Consent Terms and are named in Clauses 38 and 46, must explain their role. Vicarious liability is not automatic and will be assessed under Section 12(4)–(5).

¶ 40

On Issue 4, the Court found the material sufficient to call for an explanation, and noted that the Petitioner had already served the complete petition.

¶ 13–14, 44–45

05Holding

The Court answered Issue 1 in the affirmative: the Consent Terms contain undertakings to the Court.

¶ 41

On Issues 2 and 3, the Court held that a prima facie case of wilful breach of the Clause 13 undertaking, and of the continuing cooperation undertakings in Clauses 7, 15 and 46 read with Clause 4, is made out. Contractual remedies and arbitration do not bar contempt proceedings.

¶ 42–44

On Issue 4, notice may issue under Rule 1035(1) read with Rule 1036.

¶ 44–45

The final order directs: (i) a show-cause notice to Respondent Nos. 1–3 under Section 12 read with Section 2(b) of the 1971 Act for alleged wilful breach of Clauses 7, 13, 15 and 46 read with Clause 4; (ii) the notice to cover Cheque Nos. 000955 (Rs. 51 lakhs) and 000956 (Rs. 77 lakhs) and the Rs. 77 lakh non-payment within the Clause 13 period; (iii) the notice to cover the alleged failure to cooperate in obtaining permissions and progressing the work; (iv) noting that service of the petition has already been effected under Rule 1036; (v) a 14-day reply period under Rule 1037, failing which the right to reply stands forfeited; and (vi) personal appearance of Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 on the returnable date unless dispensed with.

¶ 45(i)–(vi)

The notice excludes the separate October–November 2024 deadlines and the six-month completion period unless the MHADA revocation date is established. No final finding is recorded on guilt or on the personal liability of any Respondent. The petition is listed on 16 December 2026.

¶ 39, 40, 14, 46
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

Tilak Nagar Sri Gurudatta Cooperative Housing Society LimitedvsMishal Construction Pvt Ltd

Bombay High Court · November 21, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment