01Facts
The petitioner owns a residential house at Ward No. 01, Choti Haldwani, Kaladhungi, District Nainital, and his tenant was the addressee of a notice dated 29.09.2026 issued by the Nagar Palika Parishad, Kaladhungi (respondent no. 3).
¶ 2(i), 3The notice, though addressed to the tenant (named as "Rahis Ahmad" in the prayer and "Rais Bharti S/o Tola Ahmed" in the facts, an inconsistency the court does not address), directed removal of alleged encroachments within 15 days, failing which the authorities would remove them, and called for the tenant's objections at a personal hearing.
¶ 2(i), 3The petitioner sought certiorari quashing the notice, mandamus for a fair hearing and right of appeal before any coercive action, and mandamus directing the respondents to consider his case under the directions in WPPIL No. 117 of 2023.
¶ 2(i)–(iii)The petitioner relied on the order dated 17.10.2023 in WPPIL No. 117 of 2023, reproduced in WPPIL No. 161 of 2024 (order dated 15.12.2025), directing the State to constitute district-level Coordination Committees for demarcation and removal of encroachments on public land.
¶ 4The State Counsel submitted that such committees had been constituted in all 13 districts.
¶ 6The connected petition (WPMS No. 3478 of 2026) was disposed of by the same order, with the court deciding the facts of WPMS No. 3518 of 2026 alone.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether a notice for removal of alleged encroachment, issued to a tenant of the petitioner-owner, can be quashed or the petitioner can be restrained from coercive action where the matter falls within the district Coordination Committee framework.
¶ 2(i)–(ii), 5, 7ii.2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to have the encroachment dispute examined by the Coordination Committee under the directions in WPPIL No. 117 of 2023 before any order is passed.
¶ 2(iii), 5, 703Law Applied
The directions of the Division Bench in WPPIL No. 117 of 2023 (order dated 17.10.2023) directed the State to constitute a Coordination Committee in each district comprising the concerned Divisional Forest Officer, District Magistrate, and Superintending Engineers of PWD and Irrigation, to ensure demarcation of boundaries so that encroachments on public land could be removed, with the concerned Sub-Divisional Magistrate associated for demarcation and identification of encroachments.
¶ 4–5The same directions were reproduced in WPPIL No. 161 of 2024 (order dated 15.12.2025).
¶ 4Where a binding administrative mechanism for demarcation and removal of encroachments exists, the affected person must first be afforded an opportunity to place his ownership and possession material before that mechanism, and the mechanism must decide the matter as per law.
¶ 5, 7The judgment cites no statute and no other precedent.
04Reasoning
Because the State had constituted the Coordination Committees under the 2023 directions, the court held that the ends of justice would be met by channelling the petitioner's objections to the District Nainital Committee rather than quashing the notice.
¶ 6, 7The court did not examine the merits of the encroachment allegation or the validity of the notice. It addressed the petitioner's grievance about lack of an adequate forum by relegating the dispute to the statutory-administrative mechanism created under the 2023 directions, which the petitioner had himself invoked.
¶ 5, 705Holding
The petitioner's objections to the encroachment notice must first be decided by the District Nainital Coordination Committee under the directions in WPPIL No. 117 of 2023.
¶ 4, 7The petitioner may file a detailed reply with ownership and possession documents before the Committee within three weeks; the Committee shall consider the reply and take an appropriate decision as per law within three months; and status quo as to the land in the petitioner's possession shall be maintained for four months or until the Committee's decision, whichever is earlier.
¶ 7The notice was not expressly quashed, and the prayers for mandamus regarding a fair hearing and appeal were effectively addressed through the Committee process. The writ petition was disposed of on these terms, and pending applications were disposed of.
¶ 2(ii)–(iii), 7, 8, 9Original Court PDF
NAEEM UDDINvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
