01Facts
The complainant (appellant) alleged that the accused (respondent) borrowed Rs. 4,00,000 for his legal necessities and issued a post-dated cheque dated 15.10.2008 drawn on Canara Bank, Suntikoppa Branch, in repayment.
p. 3On presentation through the complainant's banker, the cheque was dishonoured with the endorsement "Account Closed".
p. 3A legal notice dated 28.11.2008 demanding payment within 15 days was served, but the accused did not pay.
pp. 3–4A complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act) followed. The complainant examined himself as PW1 and proved Exs. P1–P8. The accused examined himself as DW1 and Smt. Usha Kumari as DW2, and proved Exs. D1–D2.
p. 5The Principal Civil Judge and JMFC, Somwarpet, convicted the accused on 08.06.2015 in C.C. No. 762/2010 and sentenced him to simple imprisonment for one year and a fine of Rs. 8,00,000.
p. 6On appeal in Crl.A. No. 48/2015, the I Addl. District and Sessions Judge, Kodagu, Madikeri, allowed the accused's appeal and acquitted him on 05.07.2016.
p. 6The complainant then filed this appeal under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC).
pp. 1–2, 6The accused had deposited Rs. 4,00,000 before the trial court.
p. 702Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court's failure to sign the deposition of DW2 and to comply with the mandatory requirements of Sections 274 and 277 CrPC renders DW2's evidence inadmissible as evidence, so that the matter must be remitted for its recording.
pp. 6–7ii.2. Whether, in these circumstances, it is just and proper to remit the case to the trial court to afford the accused an opportunity to adduce DW2's evidence and to dispose of the case afresh, rather than determining the merits of the acquittal.
pp. 6–703Law Applied
Sections 274 and 277 of the CrPC prescribe the mandatory procedure for recording evidence before a Magistrate, including the Magistrate's signature on the deposition. Non-compliance with these provisions means the recorded testimony cannot be treated as evidence in the case.
pp. 6–7The court's appellate power to set aside the conviction and acquittal and to remit the case for the purpose of curing the procedural defect and disposing of the matter in accordance with law.
p. 7The statutory provisions of the NI Act (Section 138) and CrPC (Sections 357, 378(4)) are referenced only to describe the nature of the proceedings and the relief sought.
pp. 1–3The judgment cites no precedent.
Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 378Section 357Section 200Section 313Section 274Section 277
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138
04Reasoning
The court noted that DW2's deposition bore no signature of the learned Magistrate, which violated the mandatory requirements of Sections 274 and 277 CrPC.
p. 6Because these requirements were not met, the court held that DW2's evidence "cannot be called as evidence".
pp. 6–7Rather than assessing the merits of the conviction and acquittal on an incomplete evidentiary record, the court found it just and proper to give the accused an opportunity to lead DW2's evidence in compliance with the statute.
p. 7Accordingly, both the trial court's conviction and the appellate court's acquittal were set aside, and the matter was sent back for fresh recording of DW2's evidence. The court also directed expedited disposal, as the case dated from 2010.
p. 705Holding
DW2's evidence is not admissible as evidence where the mandatory requirements of Sections 274 and 277 CrPC are not complied with, and the accused must be given an opportunity to adduce it properly.
pp. 6–7The appeal was allowed. The judgments dated 08.06.2015 (C.C. No. 762/2010) and 05.07.2016 (Crl.A. No. 48/2015) were set aside. The case was remitted to the Principal Civil Judge and JMFC, Somwarpet, to record DW2's evidence in accordance with Sections 274 and 277 CrPC and then dispose of the case according to law, within six months from the parties' appearance. Both parties were directed to appear before the trial court on 11.01.2027. The trial court was directed to place the Rs. 4,00,000 deposited by the accused in a fixed deposit in the court's name in a nationalised bank for one year under an auto-renewal scheme. Pending IA I/2018 was disposed of.
pp. 7–8Original Court PDF
H.K. CHANDRASHEKARvsS.U. MOHAMMED
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
