01Facts
On 15.09.2023 at about 3.40 p.m., the deceased Husenappa Vibhuti, riding motorcycle TN 61 S 9641 near V. Kaikatti Over Bridge on the Jayankondam–Trichy road, was struck by TNSTC bus TN 45 N 3969, allegedly driven rashly and negligently. He died of his injuries
p. 3 · ¶ 3He was 22 years old and claimed to earn Rs.1,000 per day selling bike seat covers
p. 4 · ¶ 4The Transport Corporation denied the manner of accident, alleging the deceased made a sudden U-turn and that he held no valid driving licence
p. 4 · ¶ 5The claimants examined P.W.1 (the fifth claimant) and one eyewitness (P.W.2) and marked Exs. P1–P34. The respondent led no oral or documentary evidence
p. 4 · ¶ 6The Tribunal held the bus driver negligent, fixed the deceased's monthly income at Rs.17,500, applied 40% future prospects, a 50% deduction for personal expenses, and a multiplier of 18, and awarded Rs.29,09,000 in total
p. 5 · ¶ 7–8The claimants (CMA 3395) sought enhancement of income and compensation. The Corporation (CMA 3827) sought reduction of income and compensation
pp. 5–6 · ¶ 8–9Negligence was not disputed in appeal
p. 6 · ¶ 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the notional monthly income of the deceased, fixed by the Tribunal at Rs.17,500 in the absence of proof of actual income, requires enhancement (CMA 3395) or reduction (CMA 3827).
p. 6 · ¶ 10–11 · p. 7 · ¶ 13–14 · p. 8 · ¶ 16ii.2. Whether the claimants (mother, brothers, sisters-in-law and minor sister) are legal heirs entitled to compensation.
p. 8 · ¶ 15iii.3. Whether the compensation under the heads of loss of dependency and loss of consortium, as computed by the Tribunal, should be modified.
pp. 8–9 · ¶ 16–1803Law Applied
The court proceeded under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (claim) and Section 173 (appeal), read with Rule 3 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Rules
p. 3 · ¶ 2 · p. 2 (CMA prayers)On the legal heirship question, the court relied on the uncontested legal heirship certificate (Ex. P6)
p. 8 · ¶ 15On compensation, the court applied the ratio of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) for adding 40% future prospects, deducting 50% for personal expenses of an unmarried deceased, and applying a multiplier of 18 for the deceased's age
pp. 8–9 · ¶ 17For loss of consortium, the court followed Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanuram @ Chuhru Ram (2018) 18 SCC 130, awarding Rs.44,000 per eligible claimant
p. 9 · ¶ 18The notional income of the deceased was assessed on the basis of his age, his dependants, and the cost of living at the relevant time
p. 8 · ¶ 16Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166
04Reasoning
Because the claimants produced no documentary or independent evidence of the Rs.1,000 daily income, the court held that the Tribunal's Rs.17,500 figure was not based on proof, but was a notional figure
p. 7 · ¶ 14The court nonetheless found the figure "on the lower side," having regard to the deceased's age of 22 (fixed from Aadhaar, Ex. P13, DOB 01.06.2001, and accident date 15.09.2023), the dependency of his parents and minor sister, and prevailing living costs
p. 8 · ¶ 16It therefore refixed the notional income at Rs.19,000, rejecting the Corporation's reduction plea. Applying Pranay Sethi, it added 40% future prospects (Rs.26,600), deducted 50% for personal expenses, and applied a multiplier of 18, yielding a loss of dependency of Rs.28,72,800
pp. 8–10 · ¶ 16, 17, 19 · p. 11 · ¶ 20(i)The Tribunal's awards under the other heads (loss of estate, funeral expenses and transportation charges) were left unchanged, and the consortium award was confirmed at Rs.44,000 per claimant for five eligible claimants
p. 9 · ¶ 18The court's reasoning gives no separate explanation for the upward revision of income in the face of its own finding that the income was unproved
pp. 7–8 · ¶ 14, 1605Holding
The court held that the claimants are legal heirs entitled to compensation
p. 8 · ¶ 15The court enhanced the notional monthly income of the deceased to Rs.19,000 and modified the compensation to Rs.31,36,000 (from Rs.29,09,000), with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition until deposit
pp. 9–10 · ¶ 19 · pp. 10–11 · ¶ 20(ii)CMA 3395 was partly allowed and CMA 3827 was dismissed
p. 10 · ¶ 20(i)The Corporation was directed to deposit the award within six weeks in M.C.O.P. No. 3047 of 2024. Shares of claimants 1–3 and 5 are to be disbursed on application, and the minor's (claimant 7's) share is to be invested under a re-investment scheme until majority, with interest withdrawable quarterly by the guardian
pp. 11–12 · ¶ 20(iii)–(v)Other directions and the Tribunal's mode of disbursement remain unaltered, with no order as to costs
p. 12 · ¶ 20(vii)–(viii)Original Court PDF
Ratnavva VibhutivsThe Managing Director
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
