01Facts
On 29.04.2018, the claimant, riding a two-wheeler, was struck from behind by a car insured with the second respondent. He suffered fractures of both bones of the right leg, requiring amputation, along with dental and other injuries.
¶ 2.1At the time, he was a Relationship Manager with Muthoot Micro Fin Corporation Ltd., Thoothukudi. He resigned because of his impairment.
¶ 2.2He claimed Rs.75,00,000. The insurer disputed negligence, disability and quantum.
¶ 2.3The Tribunal (MCOP No. 1256 of 2018, Tirunelveli) relied on PW1–PW3 and Exs. P1–P19, and awarded Rs.12,53,840. It assessed loss of disability at Rs.3,75,000 and loss of income at Rs.60,000, and awarded Rs.5,000 per percentage of disability.
¶ 3.1–3.2, 4.2The claimant appealed for enhancement, contending 75% disability and a loss of earning capacity requiring the multiplier method.
¶ 4.1–4.2The insurer argued that resignation did not establish permanent loss of earning capacity.
¶ 5.102Issues
i.1. Whether the 75% physical disability, resulting from amputation, warrants a separate assessment of loss of future earning capacity, and whether the multiplier method applies.
¶ 7.2–7.3ii.2. Whether the Tribunal's rate of Rs.5,000 per percentage of permanent disability requires enhancement.
¶ 7.5iii.3. Whether awarding both loss of disability and loss of future earning capacity amounts to duplication of compensation.
¶ 7.603Law Applied
The Court proceeded under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which governs the appeal.
PrayerThe percentage of physical disability cannot automatically be equated with the percentage of loss of earning capacity. The latter must be assessed with reference to the claimant's occupation and the practical consequences of the injury.
¶ 7.2Where employment particulars are established by documentary evidence, the multiplier method may be applied to assess loss of future earning capacity.
¶ 7.3Compensation for permanent disability (physical impairment) and for loss of earning capacity (reduced ability to earn) address different consequences and may both be awarded, provided there is no duplication of the same loss, following K. Suresh v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., (2012) 12 SCC 274.
¶ 7.6Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
04Reasoning
The Court accepted the medical evidence of amputation and treated the 75% disability as a permanent impairment affecting the claimant's occupation and daily life.
¶ 7.1Because amputation substantially impaired mobility and the ability to perform occupational duties, and because the employment and relieving documents (Ex. P19) supported the claimant's earlier employment, the Court found that loss of earning capacity required multiplier-based assessment.
¶ 7.3It adopted a monthly income of Rs.10,000, added 40% future prospects to reach Rs.14,000, applied a multiplier of 17 and a 40% functional loss, and computed the figure as "1400 X 17 X 12 X 40/100 = 11,42,400/-".
¶ 7.4The Court raised the rate for permanent disability from Rs.5,000 to Rs.7,000 per percentage, given the amputation, yielding Rs.5,25,000.
¶ 7.5It treated the two heads as distinct, so no duplication arose. The remaining heads were confirmed.
¶ 7.6, 8.105Holding
The Court held that loss of earning capacity from the amputation warranted a multiplier-based award, and that the rate for permanent disability should be enhanced to Rs.7,000 per percentage. It further held that these two heads, addressing different consequences, could both be awarded without duplication.
¶ 7.3, 7.5, 7.6The appeal was partly allowed. The compensation was enhanced from Rs.12,53,840 to Rs.24,86,239, with interest at 7.5% per annum from the claim petition date.
¶ 8.1, 9.1–9.2The insurer was directed to deposit the enhanced amount, with interest at the Tribunal-awarded rate, within eight weeks, after credit for any deposit, and the claimant was permitted to withdraw the amount. No costs were awarded.
¶ 9.3–9.4Original Court PDF
T. MuthukrishnanvsT.Santhosh Arokia Rajesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
