01Facts
The complainant, Subhash Yadav (PW-4), complained on 13.03.2014 to the SPE, Lokayukt, that the respondent, a Deputy Ranger at Chunahajuri, had registered a false forest theft case against him and Shambhu Adivasi and demanded Rs. 15,000 to close it.
¶ 2(A)A second application on 15.03.2014 alleged a demand of Rs. 6,000 on 14.03.2014.
¶ 2(A)A trap was laid on 15.03.2014. Twelve phenolphthalein-treated Rs. 500 notes were handed to the complainant, who allegedly passed them to the respondent. The respondent allegedly threw the notes near a wall at Balai Forest Chowki. His hand wash turned pink.
¶ 2(B)After sanction and charge-sheet, the Special Judge (PC Act), Betul, framed charges under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act, 1988.
¶ 2(C)The respondent pleaded innocence, stating that the amount was a compounding fee for the forest offence, which the complainant was asked to deposit by bank draft or challan.
¶ 2(C)By judgment dated 07.09.2021, the trial court acquitted the respondent, holding that demand and acceptance were not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 2(C)The State applied under Section 378(3) CrPC for leave to appeal against the acquittal.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether leave to appeal against the acquittal should be granted, i.e., whether the trial court's findings are arguable, perverse, or require reappreciation of evidence.
¶ 7, 8 · ¶ 28ii.2. Whether the prosecution proved the demand of illegal gratification, given that the complainant did not support the prosecution in examination-in-chief and admitted in cross-examination that no bribe was demanded.
¶ 3, 5, 16–17iii.3. Whether the recorded conversation (CD Article A-1 and transcript Exhibit P-14) is admissible and proves the demand and the identity of the speakers.
¶ 18–21iv.4. Whether the trap proceedings, the recovery of tainted notes, and the positive phenolphthalein test establish acceptance, and whether the Section 20 presumption can be raised.
¶ 22–24, 27v.5. Whether the defence of compounding fee was an afterthought or a plausible explanation.
¶ 4, 25–2603Law Applied
The court applied Section 378(3) CrPC and the principles in State of Maharashtra v. Sujay Mangesh Poyarekar (2008) 9 SCC 475. Under these principles, leave must be granted where arguable points or a need for reappreciation are shown, though an acquittal is not to be disturbed where two reasonable conclusions are possible.
¶ 7, 8The court relied on Khujji v. State of M.P. (1991) 3 SCC 627, under which a hostile witness's evidence may be accepted to the extent it is trustworthy, but not where the witness was not hostile at the time of examination-in-chief.
¶ 16Proof of demand is a sine qua non for offences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d), and the Section 20 presumption arises only on proof of demand and acceptance.
¶ 9–10Neeraj Dutta v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2023) 4 SCC 731 (Constitution Bench) holds that demand may be proved by direct or circumstantial evidence, that the Section 20 presumption applies only to Section 7 and not Section 13(1)(d), and that hostility does not abate the trial.
¶ 14, 27Under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act, an electronic record requires a certificate satisfying sub-sections (2), (3) and (4), as held in Anvar P.V. (2014) 10 SCC 473 and Arjun Panditrao Khotkar (2020) 7 SCC 1.
¶ 19–20A positive phenolphthalein test proves only contact, not conscious acceptance.
¶ 24Evidence of a compounding amount paid through official channels cannot be presumed to be bribery.
¶ 25Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 378Section 313
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 7Section 13Section 20
Indian Forest Act, 1927 Section 68Section 26
04Reasoning
The court rejected the State's reliance on Khujji because the complainant's partial admissions favouring the defence were made in cross-examination on the same day as his examination-in-chief, so the inference of later "winning over" did not arise.
¶ 16The complaint and second application were treated as previous statements usable only to corroborate or contradict under Sections 145 and 157 of the Evidence Act, not as substantive proof.
¶ 17The Section 65-B certificate (Exhibit P-27) was issued by the Trap Laying Officer and did not address the conditions in Section 65-B(2)–(4). The CD was prepared by an unexamined expert. The original recorder was not produced. Voice identity was not established by scientific comparison, and the complainant denied the conversation in Court.
¶ 18–21The transcript, being derivative, had no independent value.
¶ 21The trap narrative was undermined by the TLO's own spot map and trap memorandum, which did not record acceptance on the road, and by inconsistencies among trap members.
¶ 23The notes were found on the floor, not recovered from the respondent's person or exclusive possession. The respondent was made to pick them up, and the phenolphthalein result was plausibly explained. The non-examination of forest guard Sitaram Dhurve was treated as a relevant omission.
¶ 24On the compounding defence, PW-1, PW-2 and PW-8 proved that competent forest officers fixed a compounding amount of Rs. 12,000 and directed the respondent to recover it. The Rs. 6,000 figure matched that amount. The complainant and PW-3 corroborated the bank-draft demand, so the defence was not an afterthought.
¶ 25–26Because demand was not proved and acceptance was doubtful, Section 20 was not attracted.
¶ 27The court found that the trial court's view was reasonable, plausible, and founded on proper appreciation, with no misreading, perversity, or arguable point requiring reappreciation.
¶ 2805Holding
The High Court held that the prosecution failed to establish demand, voluntary acceptance, or conscious obtainment of illegal gratification, and that no arguable case warranting leave was made out.
¶ 28Leave to appeal against the acquittal dated 07.09.2021 under Section 378(3) CrPC is declined, and the Misc. Criminal Case is dismissed. The acquittal of the respondent under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act, 1988 stands.
¶ 29–30Original Court PDF
The State Of Madhya PradeshvsKrishnakant Dubey
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
