01Facts
The complainant Narendra (PW-1) lodged a report alleging that, on 06.10.2016, the appellant was speaking with his mother, Nirmala Bai, outside her house, took an axe from his vehicle, and struck her on the head.
¶ 3 · p. 1The prosecution case is that Kadwa, the complainant's brother-in-law and the deceased's son, had eloped with the appellant's wife. The appellant had been searching for her for one to two months and went to Kadwa's house, where an altercation with the deceased followed and she was killed.
¶ 3 · p. 2 · ¶ 4 · p. 2The trial court convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 1,000.
¶ 2 · p. 1The co-accused, Mukesh, was acquitted.
¶ 4 · p. 2The appellant had not been granted suspension of sentence and had remained in custody since arrest.
¶ 4 · p. 2Counsel for the appellant contended that the case falls under Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC and should be punished under Section 304 Part II.
¶ 4 · p. 3The State opposed, contending that the appellant carried the axe with intent to murder and inflicted repeated blows to a vital part.
¶ 5 · p. 3PW-1, in cross-examination, admitted the elopement and that the appellant had earlier threatened to kill Kadwa.
¶ 7 · pp. 3–4The appellant has served about 12 years and has no criminal record.
¶ 7 · p. 402Issues
i.1. Whether the appellant's conviction under Section 302 IPC is sustainable, or whether the act falls within Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, warranting conviction under Section 304 IPC.
¶ 7 · p. 4 · ¶ 14 · p. 8ii.2. Whether the sentence of life imprisonment is excessive in view of the sudden provocation, the period already undergone, and the absence of any criminal antecedents.
¶ 7 · p. 4 · ¶ 12 · pp. 6–7 · ¶ 14 · p. 803Law Applied
The court applied Section 302 IPC, under which murder is punishable, and Section 300 IPC, Exception 4 of which excludes from murder culpable homicide committed without premeditation in a sudden fight, in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel, and without the offender taking undue advantage or acting in a cruel or unusual manner.
¶ 10 · p. 5 · ¶ 13 · p. 6The court relied on Section 304 IPC for the punishment of such culpable homicide.
¶ 14 · p. 8On the Exception 4 requirements, the court followed Surinder Kumar v. UT Chandigarh (1989) 2 SCC 217, as quoted in Arjun v. State of Chhattisgarh, AIR 2017 SC 1150, and Arumugam v. State (2008) 15 SCC 590, which hold that the sudden quarrel must be unpremeditated and that "undue advantage" means "unfair advantage."
¶ 9 · p. 4 · ¶ 10 · pp. 4–5The court followed Prabhakar Vithal Gholve v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 2016 SC 2292, and Sikandar Ali v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 2017 SC 2614, for converting Section 302 convictions to Section 304 where the assault arose from a sudden fight.
¶ 11 · p. 5The court relied on Ankush Shivaji Gaikwad v. State of Maharashtra (2013) 6 SCC 770 for the factors of absence of premeditation, non-lethal weapon, and flight after the act.
¶ 13 · pp. 6–7For sentence reduction, the court relied on Gurpal Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 2017 SC 471, and Madhavan v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 2017 SC 3847, which consider the lapse of time, absence of antecedents, and the spontaneous nature of the act.
¶ 8 · pp. 3–4 · ¶ 12 · pp. 5–6Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 300Section 302Section 304Section 307
04Reasoning
The court accepted PW-1's testimony that the appellant was searching for his wife, that an altercation with the deceased arose when he did not find her, and that he then struck the deceased out of anger and fled.
¶ 7 · p. 4On this basis, the court held that the act was not a pre-planned murder and that the appellant had no intention to kill.
¶ 7 · p. 4The court applied the four Exception 4 requirements (sudden fight, no premeditation, heat of passion, no undue advantage or cruelty) and found them satisfied.
¶ 7 · p. 4 · ¶ 9 · p. 4The court did not treat the prosecution's account of a carried axe and repeated blows as displacing this finding, and it relied on the appellant's flight from the scene as consistent with a sudden, unplanned act.
¶ 7 · p. 4The court then considered sentence and held that the 12-year period undergone, the absence of any criminal record, and the appellant's non-habitual status justified reducing the punishment to the period served.
¶ 7 · p. 4 · ¶ 14 · p. 805Holding
The appeal is partly allowed. The court held that the appellant's culpability is maintained, but the conviction is altered from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC because the offence falls within Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC.
¶ 14 · p. 8The life sentence is reduced to the period already undergone, and the fine of Rs. 1,000 is maintained.
¶ 14 · p. 8The appellant is to be released after depositing the fine, unless required in any other case.
¶ 14 · p. 8The trial court record is to be returned along with a copy of the judgment.
¶ 15 · p. 8Original Court PDF
Shantilal GurjarvsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
