01Facts
An excise case under the M.P. Excise Act was registered against Jagdish Chouksey, a relative of the complainant Suresh Chouksey (PW-1). The appellant, a public servant, was associated with its investigation.
The prosecution alleged that the appellant had already taken Rs. 8,000 in February 2013 and demanded Rs. 5,000 to file the charge-sheet favourably.
The complainant filed a written complaint (Ex. P-1), and a trap was laid on 25.03.2013 with a voice recorder and shadow witness Ram Swaroop Gurjar (PW-3).
¶ 2–3On 26.03.2013, a second application (Ex. P-3) was filed, ten Rs. 500 notes were treated with phenolphthalein, and the trap proceeded to Pithampur Police Station.
¶ 3–4The prosecution alleged that the appellant took the money, ran, threw the notes, and fell, after which the notes were seized and a positive hand-wash test was recorded (Ex. P-32).
¶ 4On 30.03.2013, the recordings were played on an office computer, CDs were made, and transcripts were prepared (Exs. P-8, P-9; Articles P and Q).
¶ 5A charge-sheet was filed on 23.09.2013.
¶ 6The appellant denied guilt and alleged that the trap was staged, the notes were not found, substitute notes were arranged, and he was forcibly made to take the money and was assaulted.
¶ 7The complainant (PW-1) resiled from the prosecution case in Court, denying the demand, the earlier payment, and the complaint's contents, though he accepted that his photograph appeared on Ex. P-1.
¶ 21, 40The trial court convicted the appellant under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act and sentenced him to two years' RI on each count with fine.
¶ 9The defence contended that the Rs. 5,000 found in flex-factory waste bore different serial numbers and that the appellant was the victim of a conspiracy by Rajesh Chouksey.
¶ 47, 49, 6302Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt the demand of illegal gratification by the appellant.
¶ 23ii.2. Whether the recorded conversations, CDs and transcripts were legally admissible and sufficiently authenticated.
¶ 23iii.3. Whether the evidence of delivery, handling, recovery, chemical examination and conduct establishes conscious acceptance of illegal gratification.
¶ 23iv.4. Whether the mandatory presumption under Section 20 of the PC Act arose and, if so, whether the defence displaced it.
¶ 2303Law Applied
The Court applied Sections 7, 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the PC Act and Section 20 as they stood before the 2018 amendment.
¶ 24Under Neeraj Dutta v. State (NCT of Delhi) (Constitution Bench), proof of demand and acceptance is a sine qua non. Demand may be proved by direct, documentary or circumstantial evidence, and a hostile complainant does not automatically defeat the case.
¶ 27, 34 (quoting paras 88.1–88.8)Courts may presume demand as a matter of fact only after foundational facts are proved by admissible evidence, and the Section 20 presumption arises only under Section 7, not under Section 13(1)(d).
¶ 25, 28B. Jayaraj and P. Satyanarayana Murthy hold that recovery without proof of demand is insufficient.
¶ 25–26C.M. Girish Babu holds that the Section 20 presumption is rebuttable.
¶ 31N. Vijayakumar and Suraj Mal hold that recovery divorced from substantive evidence and an unexplained delay in phenolphthalein testing do not establish the offence.
¶ 32–33Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi requires reliable independent verification.
¶ 34–35Under Sections 65A and 65B of the Evidence Act, read with Anvar P.V. and Arjun Panditrao Khotkar, a certificate under Section 65B(4) is a mandatory condition precedent to admissibility of electronic copies, subject to a court's power to summon it.
¶ 24, 37Tape-recording precedents (N. Sri Rama Reddy; Ziyauddin Burhanuddin Bukhari) do not dispense with the requirements of Sections 65A and 65B of the Evidence Act.
¶ 39M. Narsinga Rao and Hazari Lal permit proof through official and circumstantial evidence.
¶ 36, 65Under Punjabrao, the accused need only establish a probable defence.
¶ 67Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, flight is relevant only if it is connected to a duly proved transaction.
¶ 61Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 313Section 374
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 415
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 7Section 13Section 20
04Reasoning
The Court held that the complainant's repudiation removed the primary evidence of demand, leaving only circumstantial material.
¶ 40–41, 68PW-3 was not an ear-witness and relied on information from the investigating officer, so his evidence cannot prove the demand.
¶ 50–51PW-2 saw the hand-to-hand transfer, flight and recovery, but no witness described any corrupt demand by the appellant at the trap site.
¶ 52–53PW-4 and PW-6 proved only the process of copying, not the underlying conversations.
¶ 54–55The trial court itself recorded that the Section 65B certificate (Ex. P-31) was non-compliant, yet treated the recordings as corroboration. No original device was authenticated through a competent witness, so the primary-record exception under Arjun Panditrao was not satisfied. The transcripts could not serve as the decisive link.
¶ 54–59The chemical test and recovery established contact with treated notes but not the reason for it, and the flight and CCTV footage were consistent with either guilt or the defence account of forcible tendering.
¶ 60–62The separate Rs. 5,000 with mismatched serial numbers did not prove the defence conspiracy, but the defence motive evidence (the externment action against Jagdish Chouksey and the official context) left a reasonable evidentiary gap on the corrupt purpose.
¶ 42–44, 47–48, 63–64The trial court erred by using the Section 20 presumption to fill the foundational gap and by shifting the burden to the appellant to explain the currency.
¶ 65–67The Section 20 presumption is unavailable for the Section 13(1)(d) charge, so that conviction fails for the same reason.
¶ 69The Court distinguished this from a per se rule against hostile-complainant cases: the acquittal rests on insufficiency of the admissible proof.
¶ 73–7405Holding
The prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt either the demand or the knowing acceptance of Rs. 5,000 as bribe, and the electronic evidence was unreliable.
¶ 74–75The appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentence dated 03.07.2015 in Special Case No. 6/2013 (Special Judge, PC Act, Dhar) are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of charges under Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act.
¶ 76The trial court's direction confiscating the Rs. 5,000 cash is upheld.
¶ 76The bail bond and surety are discharged, the fine, if deposited, is refundable, and a copy of the judgment is to be sent to the trial court.
¶ 77–78Original Court PDF
Ashok YadavvsSpecial Police Establishment Lokayukt
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
