01Facts
The petitioners challenge the order dated 23.02.2021 of the Commissioner, Gwalior Division (Case No. 710/Appeal/2017-18), which affirmed the order dated 12.07.2018 of the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO), Karera (Case No. 100/2012-13/Appeal).
p. 1The Tehsildar settled Survey No. 247/min-1, Village Sirsona, in favour of the petitioners' predecessor, Narayan, by order dated 08.09.1997, following publication, a spot report and consideration of the record.
pp. 1–2About fourteen years later, the private respondents appealed to the SDO, alleging non-compliance with the Revenue Book Circular and no condonation-of-delay application.
p. 2The SDO heard the matter on 04.04.2018 and reserved orders. After the Presiding Officer was transferred, the successor on 08.05.2018 directed that the next date be communicated to the petitioners' counsel.
pp. 2–3 · pp. 8–9The date (23.05.2018) was not communicated, and counsel did not appear.
p. 3 · p. 9The SDO then set aside the 1997 settlement and declared the land Government land.
p. 3The Commissioner dismissed the appeal without addressing the non-communication grievance.
pp. 10–11The State contends the settlement violated Clause 24(3), Part-IV, Chapter 3 of the Revenue Book Circular and that Survey No. 250/1 is not adjacent to the land.
pp. 6–802Issues
i.1. Whether the SDO's order dated 12.07.2018, setting aside a 1997 settlement after about fourteen years, could be passed without an effective opportunity of hearing to the affected petitioners, given the non-communication of the hearing date.
pp. 8–9ii.2. Whether the Commissioner, in appeal, was required to examine the procedural infirmities, including the denial of hearing and the maintainability and limitation of the SDO proceedings, and whether his failure to do so sustains the impugned order.
pp. 10–11iii.3. Whether the alleged irregularity in the original settlement dispensed with the mandatory requirement of natural justice.
p. 8 · p. 1003Law Applied
The principle of natural justice requires notice and an effective opportunity of hearing before any order affecting civil rights is passed, unless the statute expressly excludes it.
p. 10Even where review or reopening power exists, no order reopening a concluded matter and affecting a party's interests may be passed behind its back, as held by the Division Bench in Shahid Anwar v. Board of Revenue, 2000 RN 76.
p. 9The principle was reiterated in Jai Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh, W.P. No. 22033 of 2019 (decided 18.04.2026).
p. 9The limitation and maintainability questions under the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, Sections 44 and 51 (appeal and review), as raised by the petitioners, are relevant to the proceedings.
pp. 4–5 · pp. 11–12Clause 24(3), Part-IV, Chapter 3 of the Revenue Book Circular governs settlement of small plots with adjoining land.
pp. 6–7Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
MP Land Revenue Code 1959 Section 44Section 51
04Reasoning
An allegation that the 1997 settlement was irregular could not dispense with natural justice when the later order stripped the petitioners of rights flowing from a settlement operative for about fourteen years.
p. 8The successor Presiding Officer's own order of 08.05.2018 contemplated communication of the next date to the petitioners' counsel, and the failure to communicate it meant the petitioners had no effective hearing before the 12.07.2018 order.
pp. 8–9Applying Shahid Anwar, the SDO reopened a concluded settlement behind the petitioners' back. The delay of about fourteen years and the absence of any condonation application are material questions the SDO had not properly considered.
pp. 9–10The Commissioner's failure to examine the specific non-communication grievance, which went to the fairness of the first-instance proceedings, rendered the appellate order equally unsustainable.
pp. 10–11The Court expressly did not decide the merits of the settlement or the State's Revenue Book Circular objection, leaving those for the competent authority after hearing all parties.
pp. 10–1205Holding
The Court answered all three issues in the affirmative: the SDO's order of 12.07.2018 suffered from a serious procedural infirmity because the petitioners were denied an effective hearing, and the Commissioner's order of 23.02.2021 could not be sustained because it failed to address that infirmity.
p. 11The writ petition is allowed, both impugned orders are quashed and set aside, and the matter is remitted to the SDO, Karera, for fresh decision. The SDO must afford an effective hearing to all concerned parties, pass a reasoned order, and independently examine limitation, maintainability and the applicability of the MPLRC, 1959. The decision is to be made within six months of receipt of a certified copy, without any expression on the merits.
pp. 11–12Original Court PDF
Mahila MukhivsHardas
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
