01Facts
The claimant, aged 33, was injured in a road accident on 13.09.2010 and filed a claim for Rs. 3,00,000.
p. 2The Tribunal (MACT, Bengaluru) awarded Rs. 45,000 with 6% interest from the date of petition.
pp. 2–3The claimant appealed for enhancement, contending that the Tribunal erred in denying future loss of earning capacity merely because his examining doctor (PW2) was not the treating doctor.
p. 3The claimant also argued that Exs. P15–40 were wrongly disregarded, that interest should be 12%, and that the other heads were meagre.
p. 3The claimant claimed income of Rs. 18,000 per month as an Executive Assistant (Ex. P9), but did not examine the employer or produce bank statements.
p. 4PW2, an orthopaedic surgeon, found a fracture of the radial head and right forearm and assessed 30% disability of the right arm and 9% whole-body disability.
pp. 4–5PW2 admitted he did not treat the claimant, whose treatment was given by another doctor in the same hospital, and that the X-ray reports were unavailable.
pp. 4–5The claimant was hospitalised for three days, and the Tribunal disallowed many medical bills for want of prescriptions.
pp. 5–602Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in denying compensation for loss of future earning capacity on the ground that PW2 was not the treating doctor.
p. 5ii.2. Whether the notional monthly income should be fixed at Rs. 5,500 (per the KSLSA chart) rather than the claimed Rs. 18,000.
p. 4iii.3. Whether the awards under the heads of pain and suffering, loss of amenities, attendant charges, and loss of income during laid-up period were inadequate, and whether interest should be enhanced to 12%.
p. 3 · pp. 5–603Law Applied
The Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, s. 173(1), provides the appellate route against the Tribunal's award.
pp. 1–2For quantification, the multiplier method is applied, adopting a multiplier of 16 for a claimant aged 33, together with a notional income drawn from the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority chart where actual income is unproved.
p. 4A disability assessment by a non-treating expert witness may be accepted if made on proper lines and supported by the medical record, so that the absence of treatment by the examining doctor is not by itself fatal.
p. 5Medical expenses unsupported by prescriptions may be disallowed, while the accepted medical expenses are retained.
p. 6No precedent is cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
04Reasoning
The Tribunal's rejection of PW2's evidence was set aside because the claimant's treatment at the same hospital was undisputed, and PW2 had verified the treatment records, so the disability assessment could not be discarded for lack of treatment.
p. 5The court accepted 30% arm disability, applied one-third (10%) as the functional loss, and derived future loss of earning capacity by applying the multiplier of 16 to notional income.
p. 5Actual income of Rs. 18,000 was rejected because the employer was not examined and no bank statements were produced.
p. 4Although the judgment states that taking Rs. 5,500 as notional income is "just unreasonable," the computation proceeds on that figure, so the court evidently adopted it as the reasonable notional income; the wording appears to be a drafting error.
p. 4The computed loss of future earning capacity is Rs. 1,05,600 (5,500 × 12 × 16 × 10%).
p. 5The court enhanced the award for pain and suffering (Rs. 40,000), loss of amenities (Rs. 20,000), attendant and nourishment charges (Rs. 30,000), and laid-up income (Rs. 22,000), reasoning from the three-day hospitalisation and the claimant's age and occupation.
pp. 5–6Medical expenses of Rs. 15,000 were confirmed in view of the missing prescriptions.
p. 6The judgment does not address the claimant's 12% interest plea, and it grants 6%.
p. 705Holding
The claimant is entitled to total compensation of Rs. 2,32,600 with 6% interest per annum from the date of petition until realisation.
pp. 6–7The appeal is allowed in part, and the Tribunal's award dated 22.03.2013 is modified accordingly. The Insurer (Respondent No. 2), which had already deposited the original award, is directed to deposit the enhanced amount of Rs. 1,87,600 with 6% interest within one month. On deposit, the claimant may withdraw the entire amount with accrued interest, and the records are to be returned to the Tribunal.
p. 7Original Court PDF
PRAVEEN KUMAR K.H.vsR.K. PRAKASH
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
