01Facts
The plaintiff (H. Ramaiah) sued in O.S. No. 436/1989 for declaration of title and permanent injunction over a vacant site measuring 66 x 54 yards.
He traced title to a registered family partition deed dated 31.03.1904 in favour of Ramappa, through whose descendants he purchased the property under a registered sale deed dated 10.11.1975 for Rs. 12,000.
¶ 3He pleaded municipal records and tax payments, and alleged that the western neighbours were encroaching.
¶ 4Defendant No. 1 (D.S. Suryanarayana Rao) denied the claim, contended that the plaintiff had lost a substantial portion of the property to the widening of Bellary Road, and disputed the stated measurements.
¶ 5Defendant No. 1 filed O.S. No. 203/1992 asserting title and seeking an injunction, claiming ancestral property allotted under the family partition.
¶ 6–7The suits were clubbed and tried on common evidence.
¶ 8The Trial Court dismissed O.S. No. 436/1989 and decreed O.S. No. 203/1992 in favour of defendant No. 1, relying on the discrepancy between the sale deed extent and the extent available on the ground.
¶ 10–11The First Appellate Court dismissed R.A. Nos. 4/2001 and 5/2001 after independent re-appreciation.
¶ 12The plaintiff's counsel had earlier secured a court commissioner, but the plaintiff objected to the measurement and did not file objections to or cross-examine the report.
¶ 22, 29–30The plaintiff admitted in cross-examination that a portion of his property was lost to road widening.
¶ 19, 2502Issues
i.1. Whether the Courts below erred in declining declaration of title and permanent injunction in O.S. No. 436/1989 despite the undisputed registered sale deed dated 10.11.1975 (RSA 95/2008, Q. 1–3).
¶ 15 · ¶ 35–38ii.2. Whether the plaintiff, having sought a comprehensive declaration over the entire sale-deed extent, could succeed without first establishing the identity and extent of the property remaining after road widening.
¶ 27 · ¶ 28, 32–33iii.3. Whether the plaintiff could obtain a local inspection or scientific investigation under Order XXVI Rule 10-A CPC at the second appeal stage.
¶ 18 · ¶ 29iv.4. Whether the decree in O.S. No. 203/1992 in favour of defendant No. 1 was correctly granted, and whether the Courts below were right in granting it on merits rather than merely for the plaintiff's failure to prove his case (RSA 96/2008, Q. 1–3).
¶ 15 · ¶ 39–4503Law Applied
The Court applied Section 100 CPC, which confines second appeals to substantial questions of law and bars interference with concurrent findings absent perversity or material irregularity.
¶ 31A plaintiff seeking a comprehensive decree of declaration and consequential injunction must succeed on the strength of his own title and must establish identity and possession as on the date of suit; a registered sale deed establishes the source of title, but where extent and identity are seriously disputed, the plaintiff must correlate the document with the property actually available on the ground.
¶ 28, 32Order XXVI Rule 10-A CPC (scientific investigation) was held unavailable to cure deficiencies in proof of identity, measurement and demarcation.
¶ 29The Court noted counsel's reliance on Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, (2008) 8 SCC 671, for the proposition that Order XXVI Rule 10-A may be invoked at second appeal, but did not expressly adopt or apply that proposition in its reasoning.
¶ 18Regarding defendant No. 1's claim, the Court relied on the registered family partition deed and the boundary recitals as establishing the independent title and location of his property.
¶ 39–41Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The title dispute was not one of mere documentary proof. The plaintiff himself admitted that part of the purchased land was taken for road widening, yet he neither surveyed the remaining extent nor confined his claim to an identifiable area.
¶ 25, 33, 36The sale deed recited an extent that, when measured against the family partition deed, exceeded what the plaintiff's vendors could have conveyed, which the Court treated as overreach affecting defendant No. 1's possession.
¶ 20, 42–43Because the plaintiff's own conduct, including his objection to the commissioner's measurement and his failure to challenge the report, left the identity question unresolved, the Court found the concurrent findings free from perversity and non-consideration of evidence.
¶ 29–30, 34–35, 37–38The Court declined to use Order XXVI Rule 10-A to remedy this evidentiary gap.
¶ 29On RSA 96/2008, defendant No. 1's decree rested on independent title documents, boundary recitals and admissions, not solely on the plaintiff's failure to prove his case, and the concurrent findings on his title and possession were upheld.
¶ 40–4405Holding
Substantial Questions 1 and 2 in RSA 95/2008 were answered in the negative and Question 3 in the affirmative, meaning the Courts below were right in refusing the plaintiff's declaration and injunction.
¶ 38The Court held that the concurrent findings do not suffer from perversity or non-consideration of material evidence.
¶ 38RSA 96/2008 was answered in the affirmative against the appellants, and the decree in O.S. No. 203/1992 was upheld.
¶ 45Both appeals were dismissed and the judgments and decrees in O.S. Nos. 436/1989 and 203/1992, as affirmed in R.A. Nos. 4/2001 and 5/2001, were confirmed.
¶ 46(i)–(ii)The Court granted liberty to the plaintiff to have his property surveyed through competent authorities without encroaching on defendant No. 1's property, and to seek municipal rectification or road-widening remedies if the surveyed extent so warrants, without reopening the findings or conferring any right over defendant No. 1's decreed property.
¶ 46(iii)–(v)Original Court PDF
H RAMAIAH SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.vsD S SURYANARAYANA RAO
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
