01Facts
On 12.02.2020, a motorcycle ridden by the claimant (then aged 19) collided with a BMTC bus (KA-57/F-3215) near the Udupi Garden Signal, 100 Feet Road, BTM 2nd Stage, Bengaluru.
¶ 3, 4, 15The claimant alleged that the bus driver rashly and negligently dashed the motorcycle from behind.
¶ 4BMTC contended that the motorcycle rider attempted to overtake the bus from the right, and the motorcycle's left handle struck the bus's right middle portion.
¶ 5, 16The claimant suffered three injuries: left iliac wing fracture, right superior and inferior pubic rami fracture, and open perineal injury with rectal tear. He was an inpatient for 61 days and underwent surgery.
¶ 15The treating doctor assessed disability at 55% to a particular limb and 19% to the whole body.
¶ 15, 19The Tribunal (MACT-15, Bengaluru) awarded ₹17,30,700 under seven heads, holding the bus driver wholly negligent.
¶ 6, 7The claimant sought enhancement; BMTC challenged both negligence and quantum.
¶ 1, 802Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in attributing the entire negligence to the driver of the offending BMTC bus.
¶ 13, 14 (Point No. 1)ii.2. Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal requires modification.
¶ 13, 14 (Point No. 2)03Law Applied
The claim was brought under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and the appeals under Section 173(1) of the same Act.
¶ 1, 3The appellate court assesses negligence on the evidence on record, including the MV Accident Report, spot panchanama, spot sketch, and oral testimony, and a party's contention must be proved to displace the Tribunal's finding.
¶ 17, 18On quantum, the KSLSA notional income chart for Lok Adalat is relied upon to fix income, and a multiplier of 18 is applied.
¶ 20Compensation under pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and loss of income during the laid-up period must be reasonable and not exorbitant.
¶ 20The judgment cites no decided case law.
Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166
04Reasoning
On negligence, the Court found BMTC's version unproven. The driver (RW.1) was examined and produced the criminal case records (Exs. R1, R2), but the Court found his evidence unhelpful, as he admitted that a chargesheet was filed against him after investigation.
¶ 17Ex. P5 (MV Accident Report) recorded damage to the rear of the motorcycle and no visible damage to the bus, which is inconsistent with BMTC's overtaking account.
¶ 17The spot panchanama and sketch corroborated the claimant's version, and the Court upheld the Tribunal's finding of rashness and negligence against the bus driver alone.
¶ 18On quantum, the Court accepted the Tribunal's reduction of whole-body disability from 19% to 15%, holding that the Tribunal had assigned cogent reasons. The income of ₹14,500 and multiplier of 18 were upheld as correct.
¶ 19, 20The Court found the awards under pain and suffering (₹1,00,000) and loss of amenities (₹1,00,000) excessive given three grievous injuries, and reduced them to ₹50,000 each. It also reduced loss of income during the laid-up period from five months (₹72,500) to three months (₹43,500).
¶ 20, 22The remaining heads were held just and reasonable.
¶ 2105Holding
The Court answered Point No. 1 in the negative, holding that the Tribunal properly attributed the entire negligence to the bus driver.
¶ 14, 18The Court answered Point No. 2 in the affirmative, holding that the award required modification under the pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and laid-up period heads.
¶ 14, 20MFA No. 1776/2024 (BMTC) is allowed in part, and MFA No. 5069/2024 (claimant) is dismissed. The claimant is entitled to ₹16,01,700 in place of ₹17,30,700 (a reduction of ₹1,29,000). No order as to costs. A modified award is to be drawn, the deposit transmitted to the Tribunal, and the TCR returned forthwith.
¶ 22, 23(i)-(vii)Original Court PDF
SYED ABBAS PASHAvsTHE MANAGING DIRECTOR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
