01Facts
The plaintiff in O.S. No. 436/1989 sought a declaration of title and permanent injunction over a vacant site measuring 66 x 54 yards.
He traced title to Ramappa, who acquired the property under a registered family partition deed dated 31.03.1904, and to a registered sale deed dated 10.11.1975 executed by Ramappa's successors for Rs. 12,000.
¶ 3The plaintiff alleged that the defendants, owners of the adjoining western property, were encroaching and had sought building plan sanction over his land.
¶ 4Defendant No. 1 disputed the extent claimed, asserting that the plaintiff's frontage on Bellary Road (a National Highway) had been reduced by road widening.
¶ 5Defendant No. 1 filed O.S. No. 203/1992 claiming ancestral title, possession, and an injunction, and specifically pleaded a loss of nearly 15 feet in the east-west dimension.
¶ 6–7The suits were clubbed and tried on common evidence.
¶ 8The Trial Court held that the plaintiff failed to prove title and possession and dismissed O.S. No. 436/1989. It decreed O.S. No. 203/1992 in favour of defendant No. 1, relying on the discrepancy between the sale deed extent and the extent available on the ground.
¶ 10–11The First Appellate Court dismissed R.A. Nos. 4/2001 and 5/2001 after independent re-appreciation of evidence.
¶ 12A Commissioner had been appointed at the plaintiff's instance; the plaintiff objected to the measurement, filed no objections to the report, and did not cross-examine the Commissioner.
¶ 22, 29–30The plaintiff admitted in cross-examination that a portion of his property was lost to road widening, yet did not survey the land.
¶ 25, 3302Issues
i.1. Whether the Courts below erred in declining a decree of declaration and permanent injunction in O.S. No. 436/1989 despite the admitted registered sale deed dated 10.11.1975 and the absence of dispute over its execution.
¶ 15 (RSA 95, Q.1–3) · ¶ 35ii.2. Whether the Courts below erred in decreeing O.S. No. 203/1992 in favour of defendant No. 1 without sufficient dimensions in the 1966 release deed and without considering the merits of defendant No. 1's case.
¶ 15 (RSA 96, Q.1, Q.3) · ¶ 45iii.3. Whether the Courts below erred in refusing injunction in favour of the plaintiff in O.S. No. 436/1989 in respect of his property when no relief was sought against defendant No. 1's property.
¶ 15 (RSA 96, Q.2) · ¶ 38iv.4. Whether, at the second appeal stage, the Court may direct local inspection or scientific investigation under Order XXVI Rule 10-A CPC to determine the actual extent of the plaintiff's property.
¶ 18, 29v.5. Whether the concurrent findings of the Courts below suffer from perversity or material irregularity warranting interference under Section 100 CPC.
¶ 3103Law Applied
The Court applied Section 100 CPC, which permits interference with concurrent findings only where substantial questions of law arise, and treated perversity, non-consideration of material evidence, and error of law as the relevant tests.
¶ 31, 38A plaintiff seeking a comprehensive declaration of title with consequential injunction must establish both title and the identity and possession of the property as on the date of suit, and a registered sale deed alone does not discharge this burden where extent and identity are seriously disputed.
¶ 28, 32Order XXVI Rule 10-A CPC, which concerns scientific investigation, was held inapplicable to disputes of identification, measurement, and demarcation.
¶ 29The Court noted the reliance placed by the plaintiff on Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, (2008) 8 SCC 671, for the proposition that Order XXVI Rule 10-A may be invoked at second appeal stage, but did not expressly rest its decision on that authority.
¶ 18 · no separate ratio statedA claimant asserting title to a property must be restricted to the extent actually conveyed to him by his vendors under the chain of title, as reflected in the registered partition and sale deeds.
¶ 40, 42–43Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The plaintiff admitted, through cross-examination as P.W.1, that a portion of his property had been lost to road widening, yet he neither surveyed the land nor restricted his claim to the identifiable extent.
¶ 25, 33, 36Because the plaintiff sought a decree over the full extent in his sale deed, the Courts below were entitled to examine whether that extent exceeded what his vendors had actually acquired under the 1904 partition deed.
¶ 34, 42This discrepancy, coupled with the adjoining western property of defendant No. 1, supported the finding that the plaintiff could not establish the precise identity of the land claimed.
¶ 34–35The Court rejected the plea for fresh local inspection because the dispute concerned identification and measurement, the plaintiff had obstructed the Commissioner's work, and he filed no objections to the report or cross-examined the Commissioner.
¶ 29–30Although the Court did not rely on the Commissioner's report for its conclusions, it treated the plaintiff's conduct as relevant to the nature of the controversy.
¶ 30On the cross-appeal in RSA No. 96/2008, the Court held that defendant No. 1's title stemmed from the registered 1904 partition deed, and that the plaintiff's boundaries, read with that deed, supported defendant No. 1's location and identity claim.
¶ 39–40Since the First Appellate Court had independently re-appreciated the evidence, the concurrent findings were not perverse or based merely on the plaintiff's failure to prove his own case.
¶ 41, 4405Holding
The Court answered substantial questions of law (i) and (ii) in RSA No. 95/2008 in the negative and question (iii) in the affirmative, holding that the concurrent findings are not perverse and that the plaintiff failed to establish the identity and extent of the land claimed.
¶ 38The decree in O.S. No. 203/1992 requires no interference, and the questions in RSA No. 96/2008 were answered against the plaintiff.
¶ 45–46Both Regular Second Appeals were dismissed, and the judgments and decrees in O.S. Nos. 436/1989 and 203/1992, as affirmed in R.A. Nos. 4/2001 and 5/2001, were confirmed. The Court expressly preserved the plaintiff's liberty to have his property surveyed through competent authorities without encroaching on defendant No. 1's property, to seek municipal rectification, and to pursue remedies for any road-widening acquisition, without reopening the findings in these proceedings.
¶ 46(i)–(v)Original Court PDF
H RAMAIAH SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRSvsD.S. SURYANARAYANA RAO
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
