01Facts
The respondent-petitioner (Smt. M.R. Sujatha) purchased about 2 acres of agricultural land in Chellur Village, Kanakapura Taluk, under a sale deed dated 06.04.2005, intending to set up a garment unit, "Sujatha Garments," for which a provisional small-scale industry registration was issued.
¶ 5.2–5.3On 25.10.2006 the State issued notifications under Sections 3(1), 1(3) and 28(1) of the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Act, 1966 ("KIAD Act"), including three of her survey numbers (186/1, 371/2, 370/P2; total 1 acre 2 guntas).
¶ 5.5She filed objections on 06.12.2006 and 08.02.2007.
¶ 5.6The Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) rejected the objections by order dated 13.02.2009 under Section 28(3).
¶ 5.7, 5.9The Final Notification under Section 28(4) was issued on 02.02.2010, about 3 years 4 months after the Preliminary Notification.
¶ 5.8The petitioner contended that this delay was unexplained and that her objections on two survey numbers were not considered.
¶ 5.13, 8.3The KIADB explained that the 1,612-acre acquisition involved numerous objections requiring hearings under Section 28(3), and that about 2 years 4 months was consumed in that process.
¶ 5.11, 24The Writ Court, following H.N. Shivanna v. State of Karnataka (DB, 2012), held the delay prejudicial and quashed the notifications insofar as they related to the petitioner's lands.
¶ 2, 5.14No award has been passed, and further proceedings were stayed by court order.
¶ 5.10, 8.5, 902Issues
i.1. Whether the Writ Court was right in applying H.N. Shivanna to hold that the delay in issuing the Final Notification under Section 28(4) of the KIAD Act is fatal to the acquisition.
¶ 10ii.2. Whether the non-consideration of the petitioner's objections in respect of certain survey numbers vitiates the acquisition.
¶ 2603Law Applied
Section 28 of the KIAD Act contains no fixed time limit between the Section 28(1) notification and the Section 28(4) Final Notification, and differs from the one-year limit in the proviso to Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 ("LA Act").
¶ 16, quoting P. Narayanappa v. State of Karnataka (2006) 7 SCC 578 · ¶ 20Absent a specific statutory provision and where the gap is not very long, a Section 28(4) notification is not invalid merely on account of delay.
¶ 16The KIAD Act is a self-contained code, and the LA Act's provisions (including Section 11-A) are not supplemental to it.
¶ 18, M. Nagabhushana v. State of Karnataka (2011) 3 SCC 408 · ¶ 33–36Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Anasuya Bai (2017) 3 SCC 313 holds the field for KIAD Act acquisitions.
¶ 19Bangalore Development Authority v. State of Karnataka (2018) 9 SCC 122 and the Full Bench decision, which affirmed Ananthaswamy's rejection of H.N. Shivanna, mean that H.N. Shivanna is no longer good law.
¶ 19, 27An unexplained, inordinate delay may be fatal to an acquisition.
¶ 20, 24, Shimoga Urban Development Authority v. State of Karnataka (ILR 2002 KAR 2078)Postponement of market-value determination where awards are delayed.
¶ 32–34, Bernard Francis Joseph Vaz v. Government of Karnataka (2025) 7 SCC 580Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
KARNATAKA INDUSTRIAL AREAS DEVELOPMENT ACT, 1966 Section 1Section 3Section 28
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 Section 19Section 24Section 25Section 105
KARNATAKA URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITIES ACT, 1987 Section 18Section 19
04Reasoning
The Court first held that H.N. Shivanna had been impliedly overruled and was not good law, so the Writ Court's sole basis for quashing was unsustainable.
¶ 27, 29Excluding the time consumed in deciding objections under Section 28(3) (order dated 13.02.2009), the Final Notification issued on 02.02.2010 fell within one year of the Preliminary Notification.
¶ 21–22, 30The Court distinguished Shimoga Urban Development Authority, where the delay was unexplained, whereas here the authority identified a concrete, statutorily mandated cause for the delay (hearing objections from a large number of landowners over a large area).
¶ 20, 24The petitioner failed to show that the authority ought to have issued declarations stage by stage, or that the delay was intentional or wilful, and Roy Rodrigues was distinguished because there was no material showing landowners avoiding notice.
¶ 23, 25, 30The SLAO's order had answered the petitioner's objection at Sl. No. 255, so the omission in the entries for survey numbers 377 and 379 was a technical plea without material support.
¶ 26Since no award had been passed and the proceedings were stayed by court order, the delay in the award could not be attributed to the KIADB.
¶ 9, 32The Government's scheme of allotting developed land in lieu of compensation at about 10,000 sq. ft. per acre offered a remedy to the petitioner.
¶ 31, 3405Holding
Issue 1 is answered in the negative: the delay in issuing the Section 28(4) Final Notification was not fatal, because the KIAD Act has no prescribed time limit, H.N. Shivanna is no longer good law, and the delay was reasonably explained and within one year after excluding the Section 28(3) period.
¶ 11, 27–30On Issue 2, the objection was adequately answered and the omission was technical.
¶ 26The writ appeal is allowed. The Writ Court's order dated 05.03.2014 in W.P. Nos. 21613–21615/2010 is set aside, and the writ petition is dismissed. The petitioner is left free to elect either developed land under the Government notification or compensation under Bernard Francis Joseph Vaz. Pending interlocutory applications are disposed of.
¶ 34, 35(i)–(iii), 36Original Court PDF
KARNATAKA INDUSTRIAL AREA DEVELOPMENT BOARDvsSMT M R SUJATHA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
