01Facts
The petitioner was appointed as Junior Training Officer (Electrician) at the Government ITI, Yadahalli, and was on probation.
pp. 4-5By order dated 01.10.2024 (Annexure-A8), his services were terminated/discharged during the probation period.
pp. 4-5The order referred to a complaint by one Shashikumar B. and recorded serious allegations concerning the petitioner's conduct during prior service (2015–2017) at a private ITI, Mahalingapur, including alleged irregularities in training records.
pp. 4-5No departmental enquiry was held before the order was passed.
p. 5The petitioner challenged the order before the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal, Belagavi Bench (Application No. 10011/2025).
p. 5By order dated 30.06.2025, the Tribunal held that the discharge was stigmatic, as it was founded on serious allegations without an enquiry, and therefore unsustainable.
p. 5The Tribunal set aside the termination and remitted the matter for a regular departmental enquiry, with six months' time for compliance.
p. 6The Tribunal rejected the prayer for reinstatement with backwages, holding that the petitioner must wait until the enquiry concluded.
pp. 6-7The petitioner filed the present writ petition under Articles 226 and 227, challenging only the rejection of reinstatement and the direction to wait outside service.
p. 1 · p. 302Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in refusing reinstatement and directing the petitioner to wait outside service until the conclusion of the departmental enquiry, once it had set aside a stigmatic discharge.
p. 3 · pp. 6-7ii.2. Whether, in light of Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar and the co-ordinate Bench decision in State of Karnataka v. Swetha G, reinstatement is to be granted for the limited purpose of conducting the enquiry, and what consequential benefits follow.
p. 1303Law Applied
Under the Karnataka Civil Services (Probation) Rules, 1977, Rule 7 requires an enquiry where allegations are made against a probationer, and a discharge founded on such allegations is stigmatic and cannot be made without enquiry.
pp. 12-13, citing Swetha GIt is settled that no government servant may be discharged or terminated attaching stigma.
p. 10, citing Swetha GIn Chairman, LIC v. A. Masilamani (2013) 6 SCC 530, it was held that where an order of punishment is set aside for procedural defects in the enquiry, the Court must remit the matter to the disciplinary authority to conduct the enquiry from the point of vitiation, and cannot reinstate the employee.
p. 6In Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar, AIR 1994 SC 1074, it was held that where an order is set aside for want of a fair enquiry, the proper relief is reinstatement with liberty to proceed with the enquiry from the stage at which it was vitiated, with backwages and other benefits left to the final outcome of the fresh proceedings.
pp. 7-8In Swetha G (W.P. No. 25028/2025, decided 15.09.2025), the High Court upheld a Tribunal order setting aside a stigmatic discharge with liberty to hold a regular enquiry.
pp. 9-1304Reasoning
The Court did not re-examine the Tribunal's finding that the discharge was stigmatic. It confined its scrutiny to the reinstatement issue.
p. 3Applying Karunakar, the Court held that reinstatement is ordered only to enable the departmental enquiry to proceed, and it is not an unconditional reinstatement.
p. 13The Court noted that an enquiry cannot ostensibly be conducted against a terminated employee, so reinstatement is the necessary step to make the enquiry possible.
p. 13The Court therefore modified the Tribunal's order. It held that consequential benefits, including backwages and continuity of service, depend on the outcome of the enquiry.
p. 13The one exception is salary for the period from the date of reinstatement until the enquiry order is passed.
p. 13The Court's reasoning reflects the distinction in Masilamani and Karunakar between a remittal for fresh enquiry and an unconditional reinstatement. The Tribunal's refusal to reinstate was therefore inconsistent with the requirement that reinstatement be granted to permit the enquiry to proceed, and the Court corrected it.
pp. 13-1405Holding
The Court held that the Tribunal's order must be modified. The petitioner is to be reinstated for the purpose of conducting the regular departmental enquiry, as directed in Karunakar and Swetha G.
p. 13All consequential benefits, except salary from the date of reinstatement until the enquiry order, are subject to the outcome of the enquiry.
pp. 13-14The Tribunal's order stands modified to this extent, and the writ petition is disposed of accordingly. Pending interlocutory applications stand disposed of.
p. 14Original Court PDF
SRI RAFIQ I. SANADIvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
