01Facts
The petitioner had worked as a cook at Government Higher Primary School, Mallapur, for about 23 years and was appointed Head Cook to implement the Aksharadasoha (Mid-Day Meal) Scheme. She avers an unblemished service record.
¶ 3On 18.08.2026, villagers and public authorities raised concerns about the quality of the mid-day meal, and Food Safety Department officials visited the school and collected samples.
¶ 3Before the samples were received, Respondent No. 2 (Gram Panchayat / Three Member Committee for Mid-Day Meal) passed a resolution on 19.08.2026 to remove all cooks at the school (Annexure-B).
¶ 3A letter dated 19.08.2026 issued by Respondent No. 4 (Headmaster) (Annexure-B1) described the action as suspension, although the resolution used the term removal.
¶ 3Respondent No. 4 stated that over 55 students fell ill after eating food prepared by the petitioner and other cooks.
¶ 4The petitioner made representations dated 31.08.2026 and 10.09.2026 (Annexures-D, D1–D3) and produced Food Analysis Report(s) (Annexure-C series).
¶ 1, 5On 17.09.2026, an endorsement (Annexure-E) constituted a three-member committee to consider the petitioner's representation.
¶ 4–5The petitioner sought certiorari quashing the 19.08.2026 resolution and letter, and mandamus for reinstatement.
¶ 1The Respondents contended that the petition had become infructuous in view of the 17.09.2026 endorsement.
¶ 402Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner's removal or suspension, pending the Food Analysis Report and the committee's consideration, warrants quashing of the Gram Panchayat resolution dated 19.08.2026 and the Headmaster's letter dated 19.08.2026.
¶ 3, 5 (inferred)ii.2. Whether the petitioner's representation seeking revocation of the suspension and continuation as Cook is required to be considered by the Three Members Committee constituted under the endorsement dated 17.09.2026, and whether a mandamus should issue for that purpose.
¶ 5, 6(ii)iii.3. Whether the writ petition survives for adjudication in light of the 17.09.2026 endorsement.
¶ 4 (inferred)03Law Applied
The petition was filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
p. 1The court's power to issue a writ of mandamus under Article 226 was exercised to direct a statutory or administrative committee to decide a pending representation in accordance with law within four weeks.
¶ 6(ii)The governing principle is that where a competent authority has a pending representation, the court may direct its consideration on merits without itself adjudicating the underlying dispute.
¶ 5The court also directed that the Food Analysis Report be taken into account as relevant material.
¶ 5No specific statute (such as the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, or the Mid-Day Meal Scheme guidelines) and no precedent were cited or relied upon in the order.
04Reasoning
The court noted that the Gram Panchayat resolution described the action as removal while the Headmaster's letter described it as suspension, and that the suspension was required to be ordered by the Three Members Committee.
¶ 3The Respondents' position that the petition had become infructuous rested on the 17.09.2026 endorsement constituting the committee.
¶ 4The court held that the petitioner's representation seeking revocation of the suspension remained live and had to be decided by that committee.
¶ 5Rather than quashing the impugned action or adjudicating the allegations of food contamination, the court left the factual determination to the committee. It directed that the committee consider the petitioner's prayer to continue as Cook, revoke the suspension in accordance with law, and take into account the Food Analysis Report produced by the petitioner.
¶ 5Because the representation was pending before the committee, the court treated the petition as disposed of with a mandamus rather than granting the reinstatement and quashing relief sought.
¶ 5–6The court did not record findings on the merits of the quality complaints or on the legality of the 19.08.2026 resolution.
05Holding
The court did not answer the issues on the merits. It held that the petitioner's representation for revocation of suspension and continuation as Cook must be considered by the Three Members Committee constituted under the endorsement dated 17.09.2026.
¶ 5The writ petition was disposed of with a direction (order para. (ii)) for a writ of mandamus to the said committee to consider the representation in accordance with law, taking into account the Food Analysis Report, within four weeks from receipt of the order, if not already considered.
¶ 6(ii)The prayers for certiorari quashing the 19.08.2026 resolution and letter, and for direct reinstatement, were not granted. No order as to costs.
¶ 6The record contains inconsistent references to the constituting authority (Education Officer, Zilla Panchayat in para. 4; BEO, Raichur in para. 5), which the court did not resolve.
¶ 4–5Original Court PDF
DYAVAMMAvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
