Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Karnataka HC Quashes Store Keeper's Dismissal, ₹85 Lakh Recovery After Ex-Parte Inquiry Held While Advocate Plea Pending

SHAKUNTALA W/O M.B. KATGALKARv.THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka HC Quashes Store Keeper's Dismissal, ₹85 Lakh Recovery After Ex-Parte Inquiry Held While Advocate Plea Pending. SHAKUNTALA W/O M.B. KATGALKAR vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether an ex parte departmental inquiry, concluded on 19.10.2004 while the employee's request for a defence representative was pending and without a communicated notice of that date, violated principles of natural justice, rendering the findings and penalty unsustainable

The court held

The ex parte inquiry conducted on 19.10.2004 violated the principles of natural justice, and the penalty of dismissal and recovery imposed on that basis could not stand

It also directed

The Writ Petition is allowed. The Tribunal's order dated 16.12.2017 in Application No. 2593/2006 is quashed, the application is allowed, and the penalty imposed on the deceased employee is obliterated. The legal representatives are entitled to all consequential service benefits that would have accrued had the employee died in service

01Facts

The deceased employee, M.B. Katagalkar, served as First Division Store Keeper, National Highways Division, Belgaum, from 11.06.1990 to 01.10.1996. He handed over charge in October 1996

¶ 4, 10

Accountant General audits conducted in 1997–1999 reported shortages, and a charge sheet dated 23.07.2001 was issued with four charges totalling ₹85,68,561

¶ 4, 10

The employee sought an adjournment on medical grounds (letter dated 14.09.2004). On 11.10.2004 he sought permission to engage an advocate as defence representative. That request was pending on 19.10.2004

¶ 11–13

On 19.10.2004 the Inquiry Officer conducted proceedings on Charges 2–4 in the employee's absence. No cross-examination took place, and the proceedings concluded within a single working day (less than 10 hours)

¶ 14–15

The employee was dismissed from service and directed to pay ₹85,00,000 as arrears of land revenue

¶ 4

The Tribunal (Application No. 2593/2006, order dated 16.12.2017) upheld the penalty, holding that the employee had no legal right to an advocate and that the penalty was not disproportionate

¶ 17

The employee died in 2018, and his legal representatives filed the present writ petition

¶ 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether an ex parte departmental inquiry, concluded on 19.10.2004 while the employee's request for a defence representative was pending and without a communicated notice of that date, violated principles of natural justice, rendering the findings and penalty unsustainable

¶ 15–16

ii.2. Whether the penalty of dismissal from service and recovery, imposed in such ex parte proceedings, warrants interference under Articles 226/227, notwithstanding the limited scope of judicial review in disciplinary matters

¶ 16, 19–22

03Law Applied

The Court relied on Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution as the source of its writ jurisdiction over disciplinary orders

¶ 1

Courts ordinarily do not reappreciate evidence or interfere with findings of fact in departmental proceedings, but may intervene where principles of natural justice or statutory procedures are violated, or where findings are perverse or based on no evidence (State of Jharkhand v. Ranjan Kumar, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 824; Union of India v. Subrata Nath)

¶ 16

B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India (1995) 6 SCC 749 and State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur v. Nemi Chand Nalwaya (2011) 4 SCC 584 set the same limits on judicial review of disciplinary matters

¶ 16–17

Union of India v. P. Gunasekaran (2015) 2 SCC 610 lists the grounds of judicial review, including violation of natural justice, and bars reappreciation of evidence and examination of proportionality unless the penalty shocks the conscience

¶ 19

Union of India v. Ex. Constable Ram Karan (2022) 1 SCC 373 holds that courts should normally remit the question of penalty to the disciplinary authority, substituting a penalty only in rare cases

¶ 20–22

V.M. Saudagar v. Divisional Commercial Manager, Central Railway, where, after the employee's death, consequential monetary benefits were directed to the legal heirs

¶ 17

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The record established that the inquiry on 19.10.2004 was held while the representation seeking an advocate was pending, the date was not communicated to the employee, and the inquiry was ex parte and concluded within hours

¶ 15–16

The Court rejected the State's contention that the employee deliberately absented himself

¶ 6

The employee had earlier notice of other hearings, but notice of the 19.10.2004 date was never communicated, which vitiated the ex parte proceedings

¶ 15

The Tribunal glossed over the ex parte nature of the inquiry while relying on the rule that findings are not open to review

¶ 16

The breach of natural justice was treated as a recognized ground for interference notwithstanding the restricted scope of review, distinguishing a mere disagreement with findings

¶ 16, 19

The extreme penalty of dismissal in ex parte proceedings shocked the conscience of the Court, which justified interference with the penalty itself rather than remand for reconsideration

¶ 15–16

The Court did not expressly decide whether a delinquent employee has a legal right to engage counsel, which the Tribunal had addressed. Its decision rests on the procedural defect of proceeding ex parte without communicated notice while a request was pending

¶ 17

Given the employee's death in 2018 and the lapse of time, the Court granted substantive relief directly rather than remitting the matter

¶ 4, 18

05Holding

The ex parte inquiry conducted on 19.10.2004 violated the principles of natural justice, and the penalty of dismissal and recovery imposed on that basis could not stand

¶ 15–16

The Writ Petition is allowed. The Tribunal's order dated 16.12.2017 in Application No. 2593/2006 is quashed, the application is allowed, and the penalty imposed on the deceased employee is obliterated. The legal representatives are entitled to all consequential service benefits that would have accrued had the employee died in service

¶ 18
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SHAKUNTALA W/O M.B. KATGALKARvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · October 14, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment