01Facts
The respondent-3 (M. Jayaramulu) owned a property that the Ballari Urban Development Authority (BUDA) proposed to acquire for a layout under a 50:50 ownership scheme.
p. 2BUDA issued a public notice on 12.04.2017.
p. 2The owner executed a consent agreement with BUDA, but BUDA did not proceed with the scheme or de-notify the land.
pp. 3, paras 2–4An endorsement dated 04.10.2016 from the Acquisition Officer had recorded that the property was not acquired.
p. 3, para 4The owner sought quashing of the acquisition proceedings as lapsed and of the agreement, relying on a co-ordinate bench decision in W.P. No. 100828/2023, where a similar Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) was revoked.
pp. 3–4, paras 5–6The learned Single Judge in W.P. No. 103008/2022 (order dated 03.07.2024) allowed the petition, held the acquisition lapsed, directed de-notification, and revoked the MoU.
pp. 4–5BUDA appealed.
p. 5In the co-ordinate bench decision in CCC No. 100200/2024 with W.A. No. 100424/2024, the court had upheld the quashing of a BUDA endorsement rejecting revocation of an MoU where no development had occurred.
pp. 5–802Issues
i.1. Whether an MoU for layout formation between a landowner and BUDA, which has no statutory character, is governed by Section 19 of the Karnataka Urban Development Authorities Act, 1987, so as to bar its revocation absent Government action.
p. 5, para 3 · pp. 7–8, para 5 (co-ordinate bench)ii.2. Whether acquisition proceedings lapse, and the land must be de-notified, where the notified scheme has not been implemented and the owner has revoked the consent arrangement.
pp. 4–5 (Single Judge order) · p. 5, para 3iii.3. Whether the writ appeal against the Single Judge's order in W.P. No. 103008/2022 is sustainable in light of the co-ordinate bench ruling on identical facts.
p. 5, para 503Law Applied
Section 19 of the Karnataka Urban Development Authorities Act, 1987, which governs acquisition and development schemes, does not apply to a contractual MoU that is not a development scheme.
pp. 7, para 5 (co-ordinate bench)An MoU has all the features of a contract and carries no statutory flavour, so it is revocable on the ordinary contractual footing where no performance has occurred.
pp. 7, para 4 (co-ordinate bench)An MoU not acted upon may be revoked, and the authority must accept the revocation, as laid down in W.P. No. 100828/2023 and followed in CCC No. 100200/2024 with W.A. No. 100424/2024.
p. 5, para 4 · pp. 6–7 (co-ordinate bench, paras 3, 8–9 of the Single Judge's order quoted therein)The lapse of acquisition for non-formation of layout, as applied in the Single Judge's order in W.P. No. 103008/2022.
p. 5Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
KARNATAKA URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITIES ACT, 1987 Section 19
04Reasoning
The Court treated the matter as squarely covered by the co-ordinate bench decision in CCC No. 100200/2024 and did not independently reason through the issues.
p. 5, para 3The factual matrix was identical: the MoU was not acted upon, no layout was formed, possession was not taken, and the owner revoked the arrangement.
pp. 6, para 7 (quoting co-ordinate bench) · p. 7, para 4Applying the co-ordinate bench's reasoning, BUDA's reliance on Section 19 failed because the MoU was not a development scheme under Chapter 3 of the Act, so the Government sanction requirement did not arise.
p. 7, para 5Because the owner's revocation of a non-performed contract was valid, the Single Judge's direction to de-notify and treat the acquisition as lapsed was not disturbed.
p. 5, para 3 · p. 8, para 505Holding
An MoU without statutory character, not acted upon for the layout, is revocable, and Section 19 of the 1987 Act does not bar such revocation. BUDA's position on the issues is answered in the negative.
p. 5, para 5 · p. 7, para 5The writ appeal is dismissed, and the Single Judge's order in W.P. No. 103008/2022 (acquisition lapses, land to be de-notified, and MoU revoked) stands. BUDA's counsel undertook to return the original documents to respondent-3 within four weeks. All liberties are reserved.
p. 5, para 5 · p. 5, para 7 · p. 5, para 8 · pp. 8, para 7 (co-ordinate bench)Original Court PDF
THE BALLARI URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITYvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
