01Facts
The applicant was appointed as Junior Physiotherapist at JIPMER, Puducherry, on 27.11.1996 and had not been promoted.
¶ 2He claimed entitlement to the first financial upgradation (ACP-1) under the Assured Career Progression (ACP) Scheme, introduced on 09.08.1999, on completing 12 years in the same post, i.e., on 27.11.2008.
¶ 2The Modified ACP (MACP) Scheme, introduced by DoP OM dated 19.05.2009, was given effect retrospectively from 01.09.2008.
¶ 2The applicant's representation dated 07.12.2018 was rejected by the respondent on 22.11.2019 on the ground that the ACP Scheme was discontinued w.e.f. 01.09.2008 and his 12 years fell after that date; a further representation was rejected on 03.07.2020.
¶ 5The respondent stated that the applicant received MACP-I and MACP-II, raising his Grade Pay from Rs. 4200 to Rs. 4600 (w.e.f. 01.09.2008) and to Rs. 4800 (w.e.f. 11.12.2016).
¶ 6–7The applicant relied on the Madras High Court judgment dated 14.02.2017 in W.P. No. 33946 of 2014, which held that rights accrued under the ACP Scheme before the MACP's introduction could not be negated by retrospective application.
¶ 4The respondent contended that it was not a party to that judgment and that it was under challenge before the Supreme Court (SLP pending).
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether an employee who completed 12 years of service in the same post on 27.11.2008, after the MACP Scheme's effective date of 01.09.2008, is entitled to ACP-1 under the superseded ACP Scheme.
¶ 5 · ¶ 9ii.2. Whether the Madras High Court judgment in W.P. No. 33946 of 2014 binds the respondent or entitles the applicant to ACP benefits despite the MACP Scheme's retrospective effect.
¶ 4 · ¶ 703Law Applied
The MACP Scheme, notified by OM dated 19.05.2009, superseded the ACP Scheme with effect from 01.09.2008.
¶ 2, 10Union of India v. M.V. Mohanan Nair, (2020) 5 SCC 421, holds that financial upgradation under MACP is not promotion, that purposive interpretation cannot be used to revive ACP benefits, that the MACP is not arbitrary, that courts should defer to pay commission-based policy, and that employees cannot "cherry-pick" beneficial features from both schemes.
¶ 10–12Union of India v. Ex. HC/GD Virender Singh, SLP (C) No. 16442 of 2021, holds that the ACP Scheme stands superseded from 01.09.2008 as a matter of government policy and that employees on or after the MACP's implementation cannot claim ACP benefits.
¶ 11The Madras High Court in W.P. No. 33946 of 2014 recognised that accrued ACP rights cannot be defeated by retrospective MACP application, but it was treated as inter partes and not binding on the respondent.
¶ 4, 7Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19
04Reasoning
The applicant's entitlement turned on a single fact: his 12-year qualifying period ended on 27.11.2008, after the MACP Scheme took effect on 01.09.2008.
¶ 2, 5The ACP Scheme therefore no longer applied to him, and the respondent correctly processed his case under the MACP Scheme, granting MACP-I and MACP-II.
¶ 6–7The Tribunal held the issue was no longer res integra, as settled by the Supreme Court in Mohanan Nair and Virender Singh.
¶ 9The Madras High Court's reasoning, which favoured employees who had accrued ACP rights before the MACP's introduction, did not apply because the applicant had not accrued that right before 01.09.2008.
¶ 4, 5The High Court decision did not bind the respondent, which was not a party, and the Supreme Court's later pronouncements carry greater authority.
¶ 7, 9The applicant's demand for ACP-1 while retaining MACP benefits amounted to the impermissible cherry-picking condemned in Mohanan Nair.
¶ 10The Tribunal declined to interfere with a policy grounded in Pay Commission recommendations, finding no arbitrariness or injustice.
¶ 1205Holding
On Issue 1, the Tribunal answered in the negative: an employee completing 12 years after 01.09.2008 is not entitled to ACP-1 under the superseded ACP Scheme and is governed by the MACP Scheme.
¶ 5, 11, 12On Issue 2, the Madras High Court judgment, being inter partes and under challenge before the Supreme Court, does not compel the respondent to grant ACP benefits to the applicant, and binding Supreme Court precedent prevails.
¶ 7, 9The Original Application was dismissed with no order as to costs, leaving the impugned orders dated 22.11.2019 and 03.07.2020 undisturbed.
¶ 13Original Court PDF
DR J MOHANAKRISHNANvsJipmer
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![ACP Scheme stands superseded by MACP from 01.09.2008; employees cannot claim ACP benefits thereafter.. DR J MOHANAKRISHNAN vs Jipmer. CAT - ['Chennai']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/acp-scheme-stands-superseded-by-macp-from-01-09-2008-employees-cannot-claim-acp-benefits-t-ecff490523304a4aaf0cde99194cf7b9.webp)