01Facts
The applicant worked as a Mazdoor in the respondent's Accounts Office from 1993, providing drinking and hot water, and was engaged in leave vacancies under Rule 100, Vol. IV of the Posts and Telegraphs Manual
¶ 2He claims he suffered backache and shoulder pain and could not attend office from 2007 onwards
¶ 3The respondents state that he stopped attending on his own accord from 23.07.2005, and that his name does not appear in office records after that date
¶ 7, 13, 15Outsiders' HRA and CCA, stopped by order dated 17.07.1998, were restored following Tribunal orders
¶ 4The applicant's OA No. 1505/2011 for HRA/CCA arrears resulted in payment of Rs. 54,563/- on 21.05.2012 for the period 01.01.1996 to 22.07.2005
¶ 7, 11, 14G. Ellappan and five others were absorbed as MTS under OA No. 420/2010 and similar OAs, to which the applicant was not a party
¶ 8The applicant made representations on 08.10.2020 and 23.12.2020 seeking absorption as MTS and a second payment of HRA/CCA
¶ 5, 6The respondent rejected the absorption request on 31.03.2021 under the existing MTS recruitment rules
¶ 7, 11The OA was filed in February 2021
¶ 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the applicant, who stopped attending duty in 2005/2007, is similarly placed with G. Ellappan and others so as to entitle him to absorption as MTS.
¶ 15ii.2. Whether the benefit of the second payment of HRA/CCA granted to G. Ellappan and others under the order dated 29.06.2016 can be extended to the applicant.
¶ 8, 10, 16iii.3. Whether the applicant's claims are barred by delay, laches and acquiescence, rendering him a "fence-sitter."
¶ 16, 17, 1803Law Applied
When a court grants relief to a set of employees, identically situated persons should ordinarily be treated alike under Article 14 of the Constitution, as stated in State of Uttar Pradesh v. Arvind Kumar Srivastava [(2015) 1 SCC 347]
¶ 17That principle is subject to exceptions for laches, delay and acquiescence. Persons who sleep over their rights and seek relief only after counterparts succeed are "fence-sitters" whose claims may be dismissed
¶ 17(2)The benefit of a judgment in rem, such as one concerning policy matters, must be extended to all similarly situated persons, whereas a judgment in personam confers benefit only on the parties, unless the benefit is extended by the authorities
¶ 17(3)The applicant relied on Inder Pal Yadav for the proposition that similarly placed persons should not be compelled to approach the courts
¶ 10Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19
04Reasoning
The Tribunal held that the applicant was not similarly placed with G. Ellappan and others. Those persons were in continuous service and were later absorbed, whereas the applicant admitted his absence from duty and his name does not appear in office records after 23.07.2005
¶ 13, 15His claim of having approached the department to rejoin duty was unsupported by any document
¶ 15His earlier OA No. 1505/2011 sought only HRA/CCA arrears and no reinstatement, which indicated no intention to rejoin at that time
¶ 16The Tribunal further found that he did not raise his absorption claim until 23.12.2020, more than fifteen years after leaving service, with no explanation for the delay
¶ 14, 16Applying Arvind Kumar Srivastava, the Tribunal treated him as a fence-sitter whose delay and acquiescence bar the claim, without deciding whether the 2016 order was in rem or in personam
¶ 17, 18The claim for arrears of HRA for 01.09.2008 to 17.12.2008 failed because he was not working in that period
¶ 1105Holding
The applicant is a fence-sitter, not similarly placed with G. Ellappan and others, and not entitled to absorption as MTS or to a second payment of HRA/CCA
¶ 15, 18His claim was found baseless and time-barred. The OA was dismissed with no order as to costs
¶ 18Original Court PDF
C GANAPATHYvsD/o Post
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Laches and acquiescence bar a fence-sitter from claiming benefits of an in personam judgment extended to others.. C GANAPATHY vs D/o Post. CAT - ['Chennai']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/laches-and-acquiescence-bar-a-fence-sitter-from-claiming-benefits-of-an-in-personam-judgme-6a2651a2b74e4614bb1dc5a490eb8f88.webp)