CAT - ['Chennai']Employment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Recovery of excess HRA from a Group 'C' employee, erroneously paid by the employer, is impermissible in law.

KAMLESH KUMAR CHOUBEYv.M/O DEFENCE

Recovery of excess HRA from a Group 'C' employee, erroneously paid by the employer, is impermissible in law.. KAMLESH KUMAR CHOUBEY vs M/O DEFENCE. CAT - ['Chennai']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the respondents are entitled to recover the excess HRA of Rs. 1,24,692 from the applicant's salary without issuing him any notice.

The court held

The respondents are not entitled to recover the Rs. 1,24,692 HRA overpayment from the applicant's salary, because the applicant is a Group 'C' employee, the overpayment was caused by the respondents' own error without any misrepresentation by him, and the recovery was ordered more than five years after the overpayment began.

It also directed

The Tribunal quashed and set aside the impugned order dated 29.03.2025 and directed the respondents not to effect any recovery from the applicant's monthly pay. Any amount already recovered must be refunded forthwith. The OA is allowed, with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The applicant, a Civil Motor Driver (Ordinary Grade), a Group 'C' post, was appointed in 1999 and posted to the office of Respondent No. 2 from 01.01.2019, with pay fixed and HRA granted at 16%.

¶ 2

The respondents state that Sukna is a 'Z' class city with an 8% HRA rate, and that the 16% rate was paid erroneously by PCDA Bangalore on information supplied by Respondent No. 1.

¶ 4

The HRA was reduced to 8% from April 2022.

¶ 2

On transfer to Respondent No. 5 on 03.03.2025, the Last Pay Certificate recorded an excess HRA payment of Rs. 1,24,692 for 01.01.2019 to 31.03.2022.

¶ 2

Respondent No. 3 directed Respondent No. 4 on 31.07.2025 to recover that sum; the impugned order is dated 29.03.2025.

¶ 2

The Tribunal granted interim stay on recovery on 22.12.2025.

¶ 2

The respondents rely on Rule 43(2) of the Central Government Account (Receipts and Payments) Rules, 2022, read with Rule 14 of the Financial Regulations, Part I, Volume I, to justify recovery.

¶ 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether the respondents are entitled to recover the excess HRA of Rs. 1,24,692 from the applicant's salary without issuing him any notice.

¶ 8

ii.2. Whether the applicant is entitled to the relief sought, namely quashing of the order dated 29.03.2025 and a restraint on recovery.

¶ 8 · ¶ 13

03Law Applied

The Tribunal relied on Rule 43(2) of the Central Government Account (Receipts and Payments) Rules, 2022, and Rule 14 of the Financial Regulations, Part I, Volume I, which impose a statutory obligation to recover overpayments of pay and allowances.

¶ 4 · ¶ 7

The Tribunal applied State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334, which holds that recovery of wrongly paid benefits is impermissible where the employee had no role in the mistake and, among other situations, where the employee belongs to Class III or IV (Group 'C' or 'D') service, subject to the principle of equity and good conscience under Articles 14–16, 38, 39, 39A, 43 and 46.

¶ 9 · ¶ 10

The Tribunal relied on Thomas Daniel v. State of Kerala (2022) SCC Online SC 536, which reiterates the White Washer principles.

¶ 11

DoPT instructions dated 02.03.2016 direct ministries to follow White Washer.

¶ 11

A Department of Expenditure OM dated 01.04.2025 and a communication dated 16.07.2025 on waiver of HRA overpayments, which apply the same principle, were produced.

¶ 12

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The Tribunal found the applicant to be a Group 'C' employee. The erroneous 16% HRA was fixed by the respondents themselves, the applicant had no role in that fixation, and there was no misrepresentation or fraud on his part.

¶ 9

The overpayment began in January 2019, but the recovery demand was raised only on 29.03.2025.

¶ 9

Applying White Washer, the case fell within category (i), recovery from Group 'C' employees, and, as the Tribunal noted, the overpayment period also exceeded five years before recovery was ordered, falling within category (iii).

¶ 9 · ¶ 10

The Tribunal held that statutory obligations under Rule 43(2) and FR 14 do not override the constitutional equity principles set out in White Washer.

¶ 10 · ¶ 11

The later departmental instructions and waiver communications confirmed that the Department itself accepts this position.

¶ 11 · ¶ 12

Because the recovery was impermissible in law on these grounds, the impugned demand could not stand, and the respondents' reliance on the statutory rules did not justify it.

¶ 9–para. 12

05Holding

The respondents are not entitled to recover the Rs. 1,24,692 HRA overpayment from the applicant's salary, because the applicant is a Group 'C' employee, the overpayment was caused by the respondents' own error without any misrepresentation by him, and the recovery was ordered more than five years after the overpayment began.

¶ 9 · ¶ 10 · ¶ 13

The Tribunal quashed and set aside the impugned order dated 29.03.2025 and directed the respondents not to effect any recovery from the applicant's monthly pay. Any amount already recovered must be refunded forthwith. The OA is allowed, with no order as to costs.

¶ 13
CAT - ['Chennai']

Original Court PDF

KAMLESH KUMAR CHOUBEYvsM/O DEFENCE

CAT - ['Chennai'] · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment