01Facts
The applicant was appointed as a Messenger in Vehicle Depot Workshop (VDW), EME, Avadi, on 04.02.1984 and promoted as Vehicle Mechanic (MV) on 27.07.1993.
¶ 2The MoD Scheme of 14.06.2010 restructured artisan cadres with effect from 01.01.2006, with placement permitted by relaxing trade tests and other conditions as a one-time measure.
¶ 3, 11Restructuring created two HS-II vacancies from 01.01.2006 and one HS-I vacancy from 01.04.2006, following the retirement of Arunachalam, VM (HS-I).
¶ 3The DPC Board (2013) placed the applicant in HS-II with effect from 01.01.2006, not HS-I from 01.04.2006. He was placed in HS-I only from 22.06.2015.
¶ 3–4Respondents stated that HS-I was created by SRO 54 dated 21.08.2014, that two promotions could not be granted at once, and that promotion to HS-I could not precede SRO 54.
¶ 5The applicant retired on 30.11.2020.
¶ 6In OA 269/2022, the Tribunal directed a reasoned order on his representation.
¶ 6The 4th respondent's speaking order dated 18.07.2022 upheld the 22.06.2015 placement.
¶ 7The applicant relied on Kalavati S v. Ministry of Defence, OA 395/2023 (CAT Bengaluru, 05.12.2024).
¶ 8The respondents contended that MCM promotion is governed by corps roster and pending recruitment rules.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether the applicant's placement in HS-II with effect from 01.01.2006 under the 2010 restructuring constituted a promotion, thereby barring a further placement in HS-I with effect from 01.04.2006.
¶ 14, 16ii.2. Whether the respondents' stand that HS-I promotion could take effect only from SRO 54 (21.08.2014) and the subsequent DPC was consistent with the MoD Circular dated 14.06.2010.
¶ 16iii.3. Whether the speaking order dated 18.07.2022 was sustainable in law.
¶ 17–1803Law Applied
The MoD Circular dated 14.06.2010 restructured artisan grades with effect from 01.01.2006, permitted placement with relaxation of trade tests as a one-time measure, and provided for bifurcation of Highly Skilled posts into HS-I and HS-II in a 50:50 ratio.
¶ 11Under the Circular, only the placement of HS-I in Master Craftsman (Pay Band I to II) was treated as promotion, while placements in the other grades were restructuring and placement, not promotion.
¶ 15, citing OA 395/2023 (CAT Bengaluru) · ¶ (ii)The Ernakulam, Kolkata, Guwahati and Bengaluru Benches had held that restructuring placements are not promotions.
¶ 14A speaking order must consider the Circular in its correct perspective.
¶ 17Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19
04Reasoning
The Tribunal held that the applicant's HS-II placement from 01.01.2006 was a placement under the restructuring scheme, not a promotion. The respondents' objection that "two promotions cannot be granted at one go" therefore failed.
¶ 16The respondents' reliance on SRO 54 and the 2015 DPC to fix the HS-I date was found contrary to the Circular, which did not treat HS-I placement as a promotion dependent on post-2014 rules.
¶ 16The Tribunal found that the 18.07.2022 speaking order was passed before the Bengaluru decision of 05.12.2024 and failed to consider the Circular in its correct perspective. The order was therefore vitiated.
¶ 17The Tribunal did not itself adjudicate the applicant's entitlement to HS-I from 01.04.2006 or to MCM promotion. It left those determinations to the respondents in light of the Bengaluru ruling.
¶ 1805Holding
The HS-II placement under the 2010 restructuring was not a promotion, and the respondents misread the Circular in limiting HS-I placement to post-SRO 54 dates.
¶ 16The speaking order dated 18.07.2022 was quashed and set aside. The respondents were directed to reconsider the applicant's case in light of Kalavati S (OA 395/2023) and pass a fresh, appropriate order within three months of receipt of the order. The OA was disposed of with no order as to costs.
¶ 18Original Court PDF
N PANDIANvsM/o Defence
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Placement of artisans in restructured grades under the 2010 MoD scheme is not promotion.. N PANDIAN vs M/o Defence. CAT - ['Chennai']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/placement-of-artisans-in-restructured-grades-under-the-2010-mod-scheme-is-not-promotion-d73b2264130f4909bb283ba50cfe360f.webp)