01Facts
Respondent No. 4 was appointed on an ad hoc basis as Junior Clerk on 30.08.1989.
p. 1His services were terminated on 30.06.1992.
p. 1He was reinstated pursuant to an interim order in WPSS No. 6614 of 2001 (old No. 5996 of 1996).
p. 2The Tribunal recorded that he rejoined on 23.09.2002, was treated as on duty for the intervening period, and was paid salary and consequential benefits.
p. 1His services were regularised on 28.01.2013 under the Regularisation Rules, 2011. The regularisation order stipulated that he stood regularised "with immediate effect".
p. 2 · p. 4Respondent No. 4 did not challenge the regularisation or its stipulation.
p. 4About nine years later, he filed Claim Petition No. 68/NB/DB/2022 before the Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal seeking seniority from the date of his ad hoc appointment.
pp. 2–3The Tribunal's ad hoc service had been counted for grant of ACP.
p. 3On 06.03.2025 the Tribunal allowed the claim, treated seniority as running from 30.08.1989, and directed that the seniority list dated 06.08.2022 be modified to place respondent No. 4 at Sl. No. 4, above Sri Rajendra Prasad Pant.
pp. 1–2The writ petitioners challenged that judgment.
p. 102Issues
i.1. Whether a regularised employee who served on an ad hoc basis is entitled to seniority from the date of ad hoc appointment, where Rule 10 of the Regularisation Rules, 2011 and the regularisation order provide seniority only from the date of assuming charge after regularisation.
pp. 3–4ii.2. Whether counting ad hoc service for the grant of ACP confers an entitlement to seniority for that service.
p. 3iii.3. Whether the Tribunal correctly relied on State of Haryana v. Devi Lal to grant seniority from the date of initial ad hoc appointment.
p. 4 · p. 603Law Applied
The Court primarily applied Rule 10(1) of the Regularisation Rules, 2011 (pari materia with Rule 10 of the Regularisation Rules, 2013), under which a regularised employee is entitled to seniority only from the date of assuming charge after regularisation and is placed below substantively appointed employees in the cadre.
p. 3An ad hoc employee does not acquire seniority from initial appointment unless the regularisation order or the rules so provide.
p. 4ACP is governed by executive instructions, whereas seniority is governed by statutory rules framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution; service counted for ACP does not by itself confer seniority.
p. 3Shyam Sunder Oberoi v. District & Sessions Judge, Tis Hazari Courts, (2022) 3 SCC 197: in the absence of a statutory seniority scheme, ad hoc employees cannot claim priority over substantively appointed employees.
p. 5Rashi Mani Mishra v. State of U.P., (2021) 17 SCC 399: ad hoc service is not "substantive appointment" and is not counted for seniority under the applicable seniority rules.
pp. 5–6State of Haryana v. Vijay Singh, (2012) 8 SCC 633: a person appointed on purely ad hoc basis without following the prescribed procedure is not entitled to have ad hoc service counted for seniority.
p. 604Reasoning
The Tribunal ignored Rule 10 of the Regularisation Rules, 2011, although the State had raised it, and gave no reasons for not dealing with it.
pp. 3–4The Tribunal's reliance on the ACP benefit was misplaced because ACP is governed by executive instructions and does not alter statutory seniority rules.
p. 3The regularisation order expressly made respondent No. 4's regularisation effective from 28.01.2013. He accepted that regularisation without challenge and attacked the seniority list only after nine years. Having accepted the benefit subject to that stipulation, he could not disregard it.
p. 4The Court distinguished Devi Lal on facts, since the Tribunal's reliance on continuous service did not override the statutory seniority rule and the regularisation terms.
p. 4 · p. 6The Tribunal did not address the Mohan Singh decision in a manner that displaced the rule-based analysis.
p. 7Read with Shyam Sunder Oberoi, Rashi Mani Mishra and Vijay Singh, ad hoc service, not made under the substantive appointment process, cannot be counted for seniority in the absence of a rule or order so providing.
pp. 5–6The Tribunal's view was therefore contrary to settled law.
p. 605Holding
Issue 1 is answered in the negative: seniority of a regularised ad hoc employee runs from the date of regularisation as provided by Rule 10 and the regularisation order, not from the date of ad hoc appointment.
p. 4Issue 2 is answered in the negative: ACP benefit for ad hoc service does not confer seniority.
p. 3Issue 3 is answered in the negative: Devi Lal does not support the Tribunal's order on these facts.
p. 4 · p. 6The Tribunal's judgment dated 06.03.2025 in Claim Petition No. 68/NB/DB/2022 is held unsustainable and interferable.
p. 4 · p. 6The writ petition is allowed and the Tribunal's judgment is set aside. The Tribunal's direction to modify the seniority list dated 06.08.2022 and place respondent No. 4 above Sri Rajendra Prasad Pant falls with it.
p. 7The judgment records no order as to costs.
Original Court PDF
SURENDRA DUTT BIJALWANvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
