01Facts
The Uttarakhand Rural Roads Development Agency (URRDA) issued e-tender NIT No. 08(P-III)/2024-25 dated 11.09.2024 for upgradation of the MRL-15 Kalika to Talla Khumti Motor Road (4.675 km), Package No. UT-09512.
¶ 1, 2The petitioner's technical bid was rejected by the Bid Evaluation Committee on 08.11.2024 on three grounds: (i) non-compliance with ITB Section 2, Clause 4.2(c), as similar-nature work experience was insufficient; (ii) the methodology bar chart was not as per work requirements; and (iii) no affidavit regarding VTS/GPS was submitted as per NIT footnote S.N. 21.
¶ 2The petitioner's complaint seeking revocation was rejected by a speaking order dated 05.12.2024, and the petitioner challenged that order by amendment.
¶ 3, 9The petitioner contended that its experience certificate (Agreement No. 14/SE dated 14.09.2018, S.E. PWD) established Stage-I work (hill-side cutting, retaining walls, breast walls, scuppers) and Stage-II work through Water Bound Macadam (WBM) experience, and that its construction schedule and methodology chart appeared at p. 170 of the bid and its VTS/GPS affidavits at pp. 172 and 175.
¶ 4–6, 12Respondents 2–4 contended that the certificate covered only Stage-I work, that the petitioner had admittedly submitted no Stage-II experience certificate in breach of NIT Condition 18, that the methodology chart sequenced Item 7 before Item 6 impossibly, and that the affidavit did not conform to footnote 21.
¶ 7, 8NIT Clauses 17 and 18 and SBD Clause 4.4A(b) are reproduced in the judgment.
¶ 10, 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner possessed the requisite Stage-I and Stage-II similar-nature work experience under NIT Clauses 17–18 and SBD Clauses 4.2(c) and 4.4A(b), such that rejection on that ground was arbitrary.
¶ 4, 7, 12, 13ii.2. Whether the rejection of the methodology bar chart as not conforming to work requirements suffered from illegality.
¶ 5, 8, 14iii.3. Whether the absence of the VTS/GPS affidavit under NIT Note 21 was a valid ground of rejection, and whether the affidavits filed could be read as compliance.
¶ 6, 8, 14, 15iv.4. Whether the Court should interfere with the employer's tender evaluation under Article 226.
¶ 16–2103Law Applied
The tender conditions are controlling. The author of the tender documents is the best interpreter of its terms, and judicial review is confined to mala fides, favouritism, arbitrariness, irrationality or perversity, as stated in Central Coalfields Ltd. v. SLL-SML (2016) 8 SCC 622.
¶ 16Courts apply the deferential standard in Afcons Infrastructure v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corp. (2016) 16 SCC 818, paras 13 and 15.
¶ 17Under Raunaq International Ltd. v. I.V.R. Construction Ltd. (1999) 1 SCC 492, a writ court must find a substantial public interest or mala fides before intervening in disputes between rival tenderers, and may examine only whether the tender requirements were considered.
¶ 18Under Air India Ltd. v. Cochin International Airport Ltd. (2000) 2 SCC 617, the State may fix its own tender terms and is not bound to accept the lowest bid, but must adhere to its prescribed norms and procedures and may be scrutinised for mala fides, unreasonableness, and arbitrariness, with caution.
¶ 19Under N.G. Projects Ltd. v. Vinod Kumar Jain (2022) 6 SCC 127, courts should refrain from interfering with infrastructure tender processes, and the question is whether the procedure contemplated by the tender conditions was followed.
¶ 20Under Tata Motors Ltd. v. BEST (2023) 19 SCC 1, a writ court should not interfere absent "something very gross or palpable".
¶ 21NIT Clauses 17–18 and SBD Clause 4.4A(b) required experience of Stage-I and Stage-II work, and the similar-work list is limited to BC, SDBC, MSS, and OGPC works, with WBM absent.
¶ 10, 11, 13NIT Note 21 required an affidavit undertaking installation of the URRDA-provided VTS/GPS on all equipment.
¶ 1404Reasoning
The Court read NIT Clauses 17–18 together with SBD Clause 4.4A(b) and held that the petitioner needed experience in both Stage-I and Stage-II prime work.
¶ 12The petitioner's Stage-II claim rested only on WBM, which is not an enumerated similar work under SBD Clause 4.4A(b); the Committee therefore correctly found no Bituminous Concrete (Stage-II) experience.
¶ 13On the methodology and VTS/GPS grounds, the Court found the Committee's reasons cogent. It held that the affidavit was not submitted as Note 21 required and that the petitioner's argument that the bid's existing affidavits satisfied Note 21 could not be accepted.
¶ 14, 15Applying the deferential standard in Central Coalfields, Afcons, and N.G. Projects, the Court found no mala fides, favouritism, or perversity, and treated the Committee's speaking order of 05.12.2024 as a procedurally compliant response to the complaint.
¶ 22The dispute being between rival bidders, with no overriding public interest shown, the Court declined to substitute its own evaluation of the bids.
¶ 18, 20, 2105Holding
The grounds for rejecting the petitioner's technical bid, and the Bid Evaluation Committee's order dated 05.12.2024 rejecting the complaint, were free from infirmity.
¶ 23Since the petitioner lacked the required Stage-II (BC/SDBC/MSS/OGPC) experience and did not satisfy the VTS/GPS affidavit requirement under Note 21, the evaluation was upheld as procedurally proper and non-arbitrary.
¶ 13–15, 22The writ petition was dismissed, and the pending application was disposed of.
¶ 24, 25The mandamus sought to declare the petitioner's technical bid responsive and proceed to financial bid opening was refused.
¶ 1(ii), 24Original Court PDF
M/S KUNWAR CONSTRUCTION HAVING ITS REISTEREDvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
