01Facts
The petitioner was appointed Assistant Commissioner on 06.07.2005, promoted Deputy Commissioner on 26.04.2011, and promoted Joint Commissioner (Pay Matrix Level 12) on 04.01.2022.
¶ 3Service is governed by the Uttarakhand Provincial Revenue Service (Tax) Rules, 2016. Under original Rule 5(d), eligibility for Additional Commissioner required 3 years as Joint Commissioner and 20 years' total service on the first day of the recruitment year.
¶ 4A G.O. dated 28.06.2024 restructured the cadre, creating 20 Joint Commissioner Grade-II posts (Level 12) and 06 Joint Commissioner Grade-I posts (Level 13).
¶ 4The Service Rules were amended on 26.05.2025. Under the amendment, Grade-II officers with 3 years' qualifying service as such, and 15 years in the Assistant Commissioner cadre, become eligible for Grade-I; Grade-I officers with 3 years' service and 20 years in the cadre become eligible for Additional Commissioner.
¶ 4, 5, 7The petitioner's request to advance his Joint Commissioner promotion to 11.05.2020 was rejected.
¶ 6A DPC was convened on 29.05.2025 and reconvened on 12.06.2025 after disposing of the petitioner's representation. His name was not in the eligible list.
¶ 8His request to postpone the DPC so that he could become eligible in the 2025-26 recruitment year was not acceded to.
¶ 11On 30.06.2025, five Grade-II officers were promoted to Grade-I. The petitioner challenged that order and the DPC proceedings, and sought mandamus for consideration for Additional Commissioner.
¶ 1, 2The State's counter-affidavit also relied on adverse service record entries.
¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the amended Service Rules notified on 26.05.2025 can be applied to the promotion exercise for recruitment year 2024-25, or whether the petitioner's right to consideration crystallized under the pre-amendment Rules.
¶ 6, 13ii.2. Whether the petitioner was eligible for promotion as Joint Commissioner Grade-I or Additional Commissioner on the cut-off date of 01.07.2024.
¶ 7, 10, 14iii.3. Whether the DPC or Competent Authority was bound to postpone the DPC meeting to enable the petitioner to acquire the requisite qualifying service.
¶ 11, 1203Law Applied
The Court applied the Uttarakhand Provincial Revenue Service (Tax) Rules, 2016, particularly Rule 5(d), and the amendment notified 26.05.2025, which fix eligibility by reference to qualifying service on the first day of the recruitment year.
¶ 4, 7The Constitution Bench decision in Roshan Lal Tandon v. Union of India (AIR 1967 SC 1889) holds that government service is a "status" governed by statutory rules that may be altered unilaterally, so that no vested contractual right to pre-amendment terms exists.
¶ 14State of Himachal Pradesh v. Raj Kumar (2023) 3 SCC 773 overruled Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao (1983) 3 SCC 284 to the extent that vacancies arising before an amendment are governed by the old Rules. Under Raj Kumar, conditions of promotion and seniority are governed by the extant rules, there are no vested rights independent of those rules, and recruitment confers only a right to fair consideration, not appointment.
¶ 10, 1404Reasoning
The Court first held that the amendment's effect on the petitioner's claim was immaterial because the outcome was the same under the old Rules. Under both regimes, eligibility for the 2024-25 year was measured on 01.07.2024. The petitioner, promoted Joint Commissioner on 04.01.2022, had less than 3 years on the feeder post on that date. He would complete 3 years only on 01.07.2025.
¶ 9, 10, 14The Court therefore rejected the "crystallization" argument, since no accrued right existed before the amendment. Relying on Raj Kumar, it held that a pre-amendment vacancy does not entitle an employee to be considered under the old Rules.
¶ 10, 14Once the amended Rules took effect on 26.05.2025, a Grade-II officer could be promoted only to Grade-I, and Additional Commissioner became reachable only after qualifying service on Grade-I.
¶ 15On the postponement issue, the Court held that an employee lacking the requisite service on the DPC date has no indefeasible right to a postponement, so the refusal could not be faulted.
¶ 12The judgment does not expressly address the petitioner's specific argument that Rule 1(2) of the amendment makes it prospective. The Court's reasoning rests on the absence of vested rights and on the eligibility date, not on a separate finding about the amendment's prospective operation.
¶ 6, 13-15The Court also did not separately discuss the petitioner's challenge to the 24.07.2025 rejection of his representation (prayer vi).
¶ 105Holding
The Court held that the petitioner had no vested right to consideration under the pre-amendment Rules, because the amendment's effect is governed by the extant rules and no accrued right existed.
¶ 10, 14The petitioner was ineligible on the 01.07.2024 cut-off date, having completed only about 2 years 6 months as Joint Commissioner.
¶ 10, 14No right to postponement of the DPC existed.
¶ 12The Court found no ground to interfere with the promotion order dated 30.06.2025.
¶ 16The prayer for relief regarding the request for consideration as Additional Commissioner was rejected.
¶ 15The writ petition was dismissed, the interim order dated 24.07.2025 was vacated, and no order as to costs was passed.
¶ 16, 17Original Court PDF
THAKUR RANVEER SINGHvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
