01Facts
Deva Singh sold the suit land (6 Bighas 8 Biswas) by registered sale deed dated 27.04.1943 to the predecessors of Respondent Nos. 1-2 and to Respondent No. 3 (50% share).
¶ 7The plaintiff, Deva Singh's successor, sued for a declaration of ownership, contending that the sale was revoked by an endorsement dated 24.05.1951 made by Hardev Kaur, widow of the vendee.
¶ 2The plaintiff and Respondent Nos. 4-9 claimed ownership by adverse possession, as they had remained in possession without paying rent and the revenue records showed them as non-occupancy tenants.
¶ 7-8The defendants contested the suit, asserting that the sale was never revoked and that Deva Singh had been inducted as a tenant at will.
¶ 3The trial court decreed the suit in the plaintiff's favour.
¶ 5The First Appellate Court (Additional District Judge, Ropar) reversed, holding that adverse possession was neither pleaded nor proved, and dismissed the suit.
¶ 1, 6The revenue entries relied upon were Jamabandis for 1974-75, 1979-80 and 1984-85 and Khasra Girdawaris for 1980-81 to 1985-86, describing possession as "Ba Khayal Wapsi Peh".
¶ 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the sale deed dated 27.04.1943 stood validly revoked by the endorsement dated 24.05.1951.
¶ 8-11ii.2. Whether the plaintiff and Respondent Nos. 4-9 acquired ownership of the suit land by adverse possession, given non-payment of rent and the revenue entries.
¶ 12-1803Law Applied
A document purporting to revoke rights in immovable property worth more than Rs. 100 must be registered, and an unregistered endorsement is inadmissible in evidence.
¶ 9The signatures on such an endorsement must be proved under the Indian Evidence Act, and proof is required that the person executing it was authorised to cancel the transaction.
¶ 10-11In Bhag Singh (D) Thr. Mahant Kashmir Singh v. Basant Kaur (D) Thr. LRs (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1822), quoting T. Anjanappa v. Somalingappa, the claimant must prove actual, open, continuous and hostile possession, by clear and unequivocal evidence, amounting to denial of the true owner's title.
¶ 16Possession with a lawful or permissive origin cannot become adverse by mere lapse of time.
¶ 16The claimant must plead and prove the date from which possession became hostile, since the limitation period cannot begin to run otherwise.
¶ 16, quoting Bhag Singh · ¶ 29-30Mere long possession, without open and hostile assertion of exclusive ownership, does not confer title, and a "Ba Khayal Wapsi Peh" revenue entry without a valid revocation deed is of no effect.
¶ 14-15The judgment does not identify the statutory provisions for registration or the Limitation Act provision for the 12-year period.
04Reasoning
On Issue 1, the Court held that the 1951 endorsement was unregistered, despite purporting to revoke rights worth over Rs. 100, and was therefore inadmissible.
¶ 9Even if admitted, the plaintiff failed to prove that Hardev Kaur's signatures were genuine, or that she had succeeded to the property or was authorised by Respondent No. 3, the 50% purchaser, to cancel the sale. The revocation plea therefore failed.
¶ 10-11On Issue 2, the only ground pleaded was non-payment of rent. Long possession is not enough. The possession was consistent with a tenancy or permissive occupation, and the revenue entries did not establish hostility.
¶ 14-15Applying Bhag Singh, neither the pleadings nor the evidence identified when possession became hostile or showed any overt act communicating repudiation to the true owners.
¶ 16-17The 12-year adverse possession period therefore could not begin to run, and the plea failed for want of pleading and proof.
¶ 17-1805Holding
The sale deed dated 27.04.1943 was not validly revoked, since the endorsement was unregistered, unproved and unsupported by authority.
¶ 9-11The appellant and Respondent Nos. 4-9 did not establish open and hostile possession for more than 12 years, so no ownership vested by adverse possession.
¶ 14-18The First Appellate Court's judgment and decree dismissing the suit were affirmed, and the second appeal was dismissed. Pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of.
¶ 18-20Original Court PDF
Lekh SinghvsGurdeep Singh And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
