Punjab and Haryana High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawAdministrative and Public Law

Sale deeds of small shop plots cannot determine the market value of a large agricultural tract; unproven potentiality is disregarded.

Malkiat Singhv.Punjab State

Sale deeds of small shop plots cannot determine the market value of a large agricultural tract; unproven potentiality is disregarded.. Malkiat Singh vs Punjab State. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Reference Court erred in refusing to rely on the agreement to sell dated 18.07.1997 (Ex. P-2), executed before the Section 4 notification.

The court held

The agreement to sell (Ex. P-2) was properly discarded.

It also directed

The 1993 sale deeds (Ex. P-4, P-5) were rightly rejected as non-comparable shop plots of 1 marla each.

The post-notification sale deed (Ex. P-8) could not be relied upon.

The land had no proven potential for residential or commercial development, so it was valued as agricultural land.

The findings of the Reference Court were upheld, the appeals were dismissed, and the enhancement claims were rejected, leaving the Collector's rates of ₹8,00,000 and ₹5,50,000 per acre intact.

Pending applications were disposed of.

01Facts

The State issued a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 on 01.12.1997 for acquiring 45 acres 4 kanals 18 marlas in Village Baghapurana, District Moga, for a New Mandi Township.

A Section 6 notification followed on 06.05.1998.

¶ 3

The Land Acquisition Collector's award dated 08.01.1999 fixed market value at ₹8,00,000/acre for the 7 acres 18 marlas abutting the Kot Kapura–Baghapurana Highway and ₹5,50,000/acre for the remaining 38 acres 4 kanals, with statutory benefits under Sections 23(1A) and 23(2).

¶ 4, 13

The landowners sought enhancement under Section 18, and the Reference Court (Additional District Judge, Moga) by award dated 15.03.2003 declined any enhancement, retaining the Collector's rates.

¶ 6–7

The landowners argued that the Reference Court disregarded exemplar sale deeds (Ex. P-4, P-5, P-8) and an agreement to sell (Ex. P-2), and misread the locational features of the land.

¶ 8

The State supported the findings that a cremation ground lay close to the land and no school, college, factory or other establishment was nearby.

¶ 9

Delay in all appeals was condoned by consent.

¶ 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Reference Court erred in refusing to rely on the agreement to sell dated 18.07.1997 (Ex. P-2), executed before the Section 4 notification.

¶ 8 · ¶ 14

ii.2. Whether the sale deeds dated 19.11.1993 (Ex. P-4 and P-5), covering 1 marla each, could be relied upon to determine the market value of the acquired large agricultural tract, with or without a reasonable deduction.

¶ 8 · ¶ 15

iii.3. Whether the sale deed dated 28.10.1998 (Ex. P-8), executed after the Section 4 notification, could be relied upon.

¶ 8 · ¶ 15

iv.4. Whether the acquired land had potential for residential or commercial development so as to warrant enhancement beyond agricultural value.

¶ 16

03Law Applied

The Court's reasoning rests on the Land Acquisition Act, 1894: Section 4 (preliminary notification), Section 6 (declaration), Section 18 (reference to the court against the Collector's award), Section 23(1A) and 23(2) (additional compensation and solatium), and Section 54 (appeal to the High Court).

¶ 1, 3, 4, 13

Exemplar sale deeds are admissible for valuation but must be comparable in area, nature, location and timing; a small-plot transaction for shop use cannot mechanically determine the value of a large agricultural tract.

¶ 15

Post-notification sales are unreliable for pre-notification valuation.

¶ 15

Additional compensation may be granted if land has potential for residential or commercial use, but such potential must be supported by evidence and remote prospects of development do not justify enhancement.

¶ 16

No judicial precedent is cited in the judgment; the principles are stated without authority.

Provisions in the judgment · 5

Land Acquisition Act, 1894 Section 54Section 4Section 6Section 18Section 23

04Reasoning

On Ex. P-2, the Court held that the agreement could not be relied upon because the sale was never executed, the earnest money was refunded, and the agreement's authenticity was not established. It also noted that surveys precede Section 4 notifications and that residents generally learn of acquisition in advance, which made the pre-notification agreement suspect.

¶ 14

On Ex. P-4 and P-5, the Court held that the 1-marla plots were used for shops, were not comparable to a 45-acre agricultural holding, and that the type of land must be considered; a large tract cannot be valued by reference to a 1-marla shop plot.

¶ 15

On Ex. P-8, the sale was executed after the Section 4 notification and was therefore excluded.

¶ 15

On potentiality, the Court relied on the Reference Court's categorical findings that no school, college, factory, petrol pump or other significant building lay nearby, and that development prospects were remote. In the absence of contrary concrete evidence, it declined to disturb those findings and treated the land as agricultural.

¶ 16

The landowners did not raise any further argument beyond those noted.

¶ 11

05Holding

The agreement to sell (Ex. P-2) was properly discarded.

¶ 14

The 1993 sale deeds (Ex. P-4, P-5) were rightly rejected as non-comparable shop plots of 1 marla each.

¶ 15

The post-notification sale deed (Ex. P-8) could not be relied upon.

¶ 15

The land had no proven potential for residential or commercial development, so it was valued as agricultural land.

¶ 16

The findings of the Reference Court were upheld, the appeals were dismissed, and the enhancement claims were rejected, leaving the Collector's rates of ₹8,00,000 and ₹5,50,000 per acre intact.

¶ 16–17

Pending applications were disposed of.

¶ 18
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Malkiat SinghvsPunjab State

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment