Punjab and Haryana High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Tenant's admission of a dilapidated roof sustains eviction as unfit and unsafe; expert evidence is not mandatory.

Vikramjit Sharmav.Satwant Kaur (Deceased) Through Her Legal Representatives And Others

Tenant's admission of a dilapidated roof sustains eviction as unfit and unsafe; expert evidence is not mandatory.. Vikramjit Sharma vs Satwant Kaur (Deceased) Through Her Legal Representatives And Others. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the framing of additional issues 1A and 1B on the date of pronouncement, without further opportunity to lead evidence, vitiates the eviction order.

The court held

No ground warranted interference with the concurrent findings.

It also directed

The concurrent finding that the premises are unfit and unsafe for human habitation is sustainable and is the independent basis for eviction.

The objections regarding additional issues, res judicata, and bona fide requirement were rejected.

The eviction order is sustained independently of the arrears finding. The revision petition is dismissed, and pending miscellaneous applications stand disposed of.

01Facts

The petitioner, a tenant, occupied a shop forming part of property No. 4335, Uttam Nagar, Amritsar. The tenancy began on 01.09.1996 under a rent note dated 17.08.1996, at ₹300 per month, with the petitioner's father as the original tenant and the landlord's husband as the original landlord.

¶ 2

After the landlord's husband and the tenant's father died, the landlady, Satwant Kaur, and the tenant's successors continued in that relationship.

¶ 2

On 23.08.2018 the landlady filed an eviction petition on four grounds: non-payment of rent from 01.01.2013, non-payment of house/property tax, the premises being unfit and unsafe for human habitation, and bona fide requirement for herself and four grandsons.

¶ 3

The tenants admitted the landlord-tenant relationship and rate of rent but disputed the other grounds and pleaded res judicata.

¶ 4

The Rent Controller, Amritsar, allowed eviction on the unsafe-premises and bona fide requirement grounds, decided the tax ground against the landlady, and assessed outstanding rent at ₹7,592, with two months granted to pay.

¶ 5

Additional issues 1A and 1B were framed on the date of the order, 31.03.2023.

¶ 10

Only the petitioner appealed. The landlady died during the appeal, and her legal representatives continued the proceedings.

¶ 6

The Appellate Authority, Amritsar, affirmed the findings and dismissed the appeal on 17.09.2026.

¶ 6

The petitioner then filed this revision under Section 15(5) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949.

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the framing of additional issues 1A and 1B on the date of pronouncement, without further opportunity to lead evidence, vitiates the eviction order.

¶ 8, 10–13

ii.2. Whether the concurrent finding that the premises are unfit and unsafe for human habitation is sustainable in the absence of expert evidence.

¶ 8, 14–21

iii.3. Whether the concurrent finding of bona fide personal requirement is sustainable, particularly after the landlady's death during the appeal.

¶ 8, 22–30

iv.4. Whether the eviction petition is barred by res judicata due to earlier litigation between the parties.

¶ 8, 31–35

v.5. Whether the High Court, in revisional jurisdiction, may interfere with the concurrent findings of fact.

¶ 38–41

03Law Applied

Section 15(5) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 confers revisional jurisdiction wider than Section 115 CPC but not equivalent to appellate review.

¶ 38

Section 13(3)(a)(iii) of the Act provides that unfitness and unsafety for human habitation may be established by reliable evidence, not necessarily expert evidence.

¶ 18

Nedunuri Kameswaramma v. Sampati Subba Rao, AIR 1963 SC 884: omission to frame an issue is not fatal where parties knew the rival case and led evidence.

¶ 12

Nagindas Ramdas v. Dalpatram Ichharam, (1974) 1 SCC 242: an admission is substantive evidence against its maker unless explained.

¶ 15

Joginder Pal v. Naval Kishore Behal, (2002) 5 SCC 397: "own use" extends to family members and persons the landlord is morally obliged to accommodate.

¶ 25

Sarla Ahuja (1998) 8 SCC 119 and Prativa Devi v. T.V. Krishnan, (1996) 5 SCC 353: the landlord is ordinarily the best judge of his requirement.

¶ 26

Gaya Prasad v. Pradeep Srivastava, (2001) 2 SCC 604, and Shakuntala Bai v. Narayan Das, (2004) 5 SCC 772: bona fide requirement is ordinarily assessed on the date of filing, though a subsequent event extinguishing it may be considered.

¶ 28

Surajmal v. Radheyshyam, (1988) 3 SCC 18: dismissal of an earlier eviction petition does not bar a fresh petition based on changed circumstances.

¶ 33

Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dilbahar Singh, (2014) 9 SCC 78: the High Court may interfere with findings of fact only where they are perverse, based on no evidence, the result of misreading evidence, or otherwise illegal.

¶ 39

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 115

04Reasoning

On the additional issues, the grounds of rent arrears and tax were specifically pleaded, the parties had already led evidence on them, and the petitioner had testified on them as RW1. Since the tenants had met the controversy on the merits, the belated framing caused no prejudice, particularly as the tax ground was decided in their favour and the eviction rested on two other independently framed issues.

¶ 10, 11, 13

On unfitness, the Court relied on the petitioner's own admission in an earlier proceeding that the shop's roof was dilapidated and could fall, and that the building was 40–50 years old. Because the petitioner occupies the premises, the admission carried weight. No explanation or structural repair was shown, so a bare denial could not displace it.

¶ 14, 15–16

The absence of an expert report was not fatal. The landlady's evidence, the Town Planning application, and the civil engineer's site plan were sufficient. Age alone was not the basis of the finding, and the landlord need not await collapse before seeking eviction.

¶ 17–20

On bona fide requirement, the Court accepted the testimony of AW1–AW3, rejected the argument that advanced age barred starting a business, and treated dependency as not limited to financial dependency. The petitioner gave no particulars of the grandsons' existing businesses or of alternative accommodation.

¶ 22–24, 27

The landlady's death did not extinguish the requirement of the grandsons, which was not purely personal to her. Even if the death affected the personal-requirement ground, the unfitness ground survived independently.

¶ 29, 30

On res judicata, the Court held that the earlier proceedings concerned different grounds, and a decree restraining forcible dispossession except in due course of law does not bar resort to the statutory eviction remedy.

¶ 31, 34–35

On arrears, the Court declined to examine the computation because the eviction order stood independently on unfitness.

¶ 36–37

The Court found that the unfitness finding rested on relevant admissions and evidence, and that no perversity, misreading, or ignored material evidence had been shown.

¶ 40

05Holding

No ground warranted interference with the concurrent findings.

¶ 9

The concurrent finding that the premises are unfit and unsafe for human habitation is sustainable and is the independent basis for eviction.

¶ 21, 30, 40

The objections regarding additional issues, res judicata, and bona fide requirement were rejected.

¶ 13, 31–35

The eviction order is sustained independently of the arrears finding. The revision petition is dismissed, and pending miscellaneous applications stand disposed of.

¶ 37, 42
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Vikramjit SharmavsSatwant Kaur (Deceased) Through Her Legal Representatives And Others

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 21, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment