01Facts
On 01.01.2004, ASI Moti Ram, leading a patrolling party at the outer gate of General Bus Stand, Panipat, saw a person carrying a bag in his right hand. On noticing the police, the person turned back and walked briskly. On enquiry he disclosed his name as Door Singh, and a search recovered 1 kg of charas.
¶ 4FIR No. 4 dated 01.01.2004 was registered at Police Station City, Panipat, under Section 20 of the NDPS Act.
¶ 2After seizure, sealing, arrest, site inspection, and a rough site plan, the police filed a final report under Section 173 CrPC.
¶ 5The trial court convicted the appellant under Section 20 NDPS Act and sentenced him to rigorous imprisonment for ten years and a fine of ₹1,00,000, with two and a half years' further imprisonment in default.
¶ 3At the appellate stage, the appellant did not challenge the conviction and confined the appeal to sentence.
¶ 9He had undergone three years, four months and twenty-seven days of imprisonment, was over 50 years old, and had no other prosecution.
¶ 10, 11, 18(d), (g)02Issues
i.1. Whether the 1 kg of charas recovered from the appellant fell within "commercial quantity" under Section 2(viia) of the NDPS Act, so as to attract the statutory sentencing bracket for commercial quantities.
¶ 15–16ii.2. Whether the sentence of ten years' rigorous imprisonment, imposed on conviction under Section 20 NDPS Act, was harsh and required modification, having regard to the non-commercial quantity, the lapse of about 22 years, the protracted trial, the period already undergone, the first-offence status, and the appellant's age.
¶ 17–1903Law Applied
Section 2(viia) of the NDPS Act defines "commercial quantity" as any quantity greater than the quantity specified by the Central Government by notification in the Official Gazette.
¶ 16The applicable notification fixes the commercial quantity of charas at 1 kg, so 1 kg is not "greater than" that threshold and is non-commercial.
¶ 15–16Where no minimum sentence is prescribed for the relevant quantity, the sentence may be moderated on the facts; sentencing is to be proportionate and inspired by the ends of justice, with mitigating factors weighed in the appellate court's jurisdiction to interfere with the quantum of sentence.
¶ 18–20No precedent is cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 Section 20Section 2
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 173
04Reasoning
The court first affirmed the conviction on the evidence, which it found consistent and sufficient, noting the appellant had not contested it.
¶ 14On quantum, the court held that the recovered 1 kg equalled the notified commercial threshold but did not exceed it. Under the "greater than" wording of Section 2(viia), the quantity was therefore non-commercial.
¶ 15–16Because no minimum sentence applied to that category, the court treated the ten-year sentence as harsh.
¶ 17–18The court weighed seven cumulative factors: the non-commercial quantity; the roughly 22-year lapse since the incident; the protracted trial; the approximately three years, four months and twenty-seven days already served against a ten-year term; the first-offence status; the absence of any other prosecution in the intervening period; and the appellant's age above 50.
¶ 18(a)–(g)The court concluded that the sentence was disproportionate and that the sentence already undergone served the ends of justice.
¶ 19–2005Holding
The appeal is partly allowed. The conviction under Section 20 NDPS Act is upheld.
¶ 14, 21The 1 kg charas is held to be non-commercial quantity, since it does not exceed the notified commercial quantity under Section 2(viia).
¶ 16, 18(a)The sentence of ten years' rigorous imprisonment is modified and reduced to the period already undergone by the appellant.
¶ 19–21The judgment does not expressly address the fine or the default sentence, and it cites no statutory provision for the sentencing bracket applied.
¶ 21Practitioners should note that Section 20(b)(i) NDPS Act prescribes a different penal range for non-commercial quantities than for commercial quantities; the reduction to time served should be read against that statutory framework and verified against the certified copy.
Original Court PDF
Door SinghvsState Of Haryana
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
