01Facts
Akshay Gupta (Respondent No. 1) filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, alleging dishonour of Cheque No. 251012 dated 25 April 2017 for ₹20,00,000
¶ 2The JMFC (NI Act)-04, South, Saket, convicted the petitioners by order dated 18 July 2025 in CT Case 8416/2017
¶ 3The complaint rested on a Return Memo dated 11 July 2017 recording "insufficient funds"
¶ 4 · pp. 2–3The petitioners' Axis Bank statement for petitioner no. 2 shows the cheque was returned on 27 April 2017 for "Drawer's signature differs," and the statement contains no 11 July 2017 return entry
¶ 5–7 · pp. 3–4The petitioners contend the 11 July 2017 memo is forged and that the cheque was presented only once
¶ 8–11An Axis Bank letter dated 1 September 2026 states the cheque was presented once, not twice
¶ 12 · pp. 5–6Respondent No. 1 states the trial court noted a double presentation but no proof of the earlier presentation was placed before it
¶ 14The petitioners' application to adduce additional evidence in CA No. 369/2025 was dismissed by the Additional Sessions Judge-06 (South), Saket, by order dated 9 October 2026
¶ 1The petitioners challenged that dismissal under Sections 438 r/w 442 BNSS
¶ 1 · pp. 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioners should be permitted to lead additional evidence before the Appellate Court under Section 432 BNSS, concerning the 11 July 2017 Return Memo, the bank statement showing return on 27 April 2017, and the Axis Bank letter dated 1 September 2026
¶ 16–18 · pp. 6–7ii.2. Whether the grant of such leave should be conditioned on a deposit of ₹20,00,000 by the petitioners, given their prior conviction
¶ 2103Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 432 BNSS, which corresponds to Section 391 CrPC and empowers the Appellate Court to take additional material on record for the complete and effective adjudication of an appeal
¶ 18Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat, (2004) 4 SCC 158, holds that a fair trial is a right of all parties, including the accused, and the failure to hear material evidence amounts to denial of a fair trial
¶ 19, quoting paras. 36 and 38 of ZahiraZahira holds that the power to admit additional evidence is discretionary, must be exercised judicially with reasons, and is aimed at preventing miscarriage of justice and securing truth rather than technical outcomes
¶ 19, quoting paras. 47–49 and 55 of ZahiraZahira holds that the power extends to either side and is not limited to formal defects
¶ 19, quoting paras. 49–50 of ZahiraSuch powers serve the ends of justice rather than filling lacunae, as referred to in Zahira quoting Rambhau v. State of Maharashtra, (2001) 4 SCC 759
¶ 19, quoting para. 50 of ZahiraProvisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 438Section 442Section 432
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 391Section 386
04Reasoning
The petitioners' documents raised a material discrepancy: the complaint relied on a 11 July 2017 return memo citing "insufficient funds," whereas the bank records showed return on 27 April 2017 for "Drawer's signature differs" and no July presentation
¶ 17Because the Axis Bank letter bears directly on whether the cheque was presented twice, the evidence goes to the core of the Section 138 liability and bears on whether the conviction rests on a genuine dishonour
¶ 17 · ¶ 19Applying Zahira, the Court held that excluding this evidence would risk a miscarriage of justice, so leave to adduce it was warranted
¶ 20To balance the equities after conviction, the Court conditioned leave on deposit of ₹20,00,000 within two weeks
¶ 21The Court imposed procedural safeguards: an expeditious timeline of two months for examination, a bar on adjournments, a full right of cross-examination for the complainant, and a parallel right of rebuttal evidence
¶ 23–2605Holding
The petitioners ought to be allowed to lead additional evidence before the Appellate Court in the interests of justice under Section 432 BNSS
¶ 20The leave is subject to the petitioners depositing ₹20,00,000 before the Appellate Court within two weeks, and the additional evidence covers the 11 July 2017 Return Memo, the bank statement showing return on 27 April 2017, and the Axis Bank letter dated 1 September 2026
¶ 21–22The evidence must be completed within two months, with no adjournments, and the complainant is entitled to cross-examine and, if needed, lead rebuttal evidence. The petition is disposed of, along with pending applications
¶ 23–28Original Court PDF
Rajesh Ebrahimkutty Majidha BeevivsAkshay Gupta
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
