01Facts
The Appellant owns Flat No. 602, Tower No. 7, Commonwealth Games Village, and was Vice President of Respondent No. 8, the Commonwealth Games Village Apartment Owners Association ("Association") for 2016–2018.
¶ 8In CS No. 28/2018, the Trial Court set aside the 2018–2020 Governing Body election and directed an urgent General Body Meeting ("GBM").
¶ 9Two RFAs followed. By judgment dated 24.03.2025 in RFA No. 269/2019, this Court laid down a one-time arrangement for elections, and elections were held on 20.07.2025. RFA No. 486/2019 was dismissed as infructuous on 06.05.2025.
¶ 10–11The Supreme Court dismissed the Appellant's SLPs on 25.07.2025.
¶ 12The Association issued AGM notices on 26.05.2026 and 27.05.2026, which the Appellant challenged in a suit filed on 03.06.2026. The Association withdrew the notices on 04.06.2026, and the suit is pending before the Trial Court.
¶ 13–15On 10.10.2026, the Association issued a fresh notice for a GBM on 25.10.2026, with an agenda covering auditor appointment, a CAM increase, and Bye-Law amendments.
¶ 16The Appellant sought stay of the notice or, alternatively, postponement to a date not earlier than 31.01.2027, or a direction that all GBM decisions be subject to the suit outcome.
¶ 17On 17.10.2026, the Trial Court refused stay or postponement but ordered that GBM decisions be subject to the suit's outcome.
¶ 18The Association then rescheduled the GBM to 22.11.2026 by E-Circular dated 24.10.2026.
¶ 19The Appellant contended that the Trial Court ignored several objections: uncirculated Bye-Law amendments, unspecified CAM increase, omission of audit, corpus for major repairs and unaudited accounts from the agenda, and dues-based eligibility without a circulated list.
¶ 20–21The Association argued that objections can be raised at the GBM itself.
¶ 2402Issues
i.1. Whether the GBM scheduled for 22.11.2026 ought to be stayed or postponed until the disposal of the suit.
¶ 26 · ¶ 27ii.2. Whether the GBM agenda must include the audit, CAM charges, and proposed Bye-Law amendments.
¶ 26 · ¶ 28iii.3. Whether members who have not paid outstanding dues may attend and vote at the GBM.
¶ 26 · ¶ 2903Law Applied
Clause 11 of the Association's Bye-Laws requires a minimum of seven elected Governing Body members.
¶ 9The GBM must be convened and conducted in accordance with the Bye-Laws.
¶ 21, 27The General Body is the forum entitled to decide matters affecting all members, including the audit, CAM charges, and Bye-Law amendments.
¶ 28Entitlement to attend and vote is linked to payment of outstanding dues, so defaulting members may attend and vote, with their votes recorded separately.
¶ 29Resolutions are to be decided by majority in accordance with the Bye-Laws, and a resolution passed only after excluding defaulters' votes remains subject to the suit's outcome.
¶ 30–31The procedural provisions invoked were Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC (interim relief), Order XLIII Rule 1(r) CPC (appeal against refusal of interim relief), and Order XLI Rule 27 CPC (additional documents).
¶ 3, 6–7No precedent is cited for these propositions in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 104Section 151
04Reasoning
Because the Appellant himself contended the GBM must be held under the Bye-Laws, no stay was warranted, and the Impugned Order did not require interference on that point.
¶ 27Because no GBM had been held since the Association's formation in 2013, the Court found that the General Body must be enabled to decide the audit, CAM charges, and Bye-Law amendments, which affect all members.
¶ 27–28Since voting rights depend on dues, the Court avoided excluding defaulters, which would have frustrated the meeting, and instead permitted their participation with separate recording of their votes.
¶ 29A two-stage voting mechanism resolves the conflict. First, resolutions are tested against the full membership, and if passed under the Bye-Laws they are final and binding.
¶ 30Second, if a resolution fails in the full count but passes after excluding defaulters, it remains subject to the suit outcome, which protects the Appellant's contentions without blocking the meeting.
¶ 31The Court expressly preserved the parties' rights and merits in the suit.
¶ 32The Court's directions do not expressly address the specific objections concerning corpus for major repairs and unaudited accounts, which were raised at paragraph 21.
¶ 21 · ¶ 3005Holding
The Court declined to stay the GBM and held that it must proceed under the Bye-Laws.
¶ 27The GBM agenda must include the audit, CAM charges, and Bye-Law amendments, and defaulting members may attend and vote, with votes recorded separately.
¶ 28–29Resolutions passed by majority inclusive of defaulters' votes are final and binding. Resolutions that pass only after excluding defaulters' votes remain subject to the suit's outcome.
¶ 30–31The Impugned Order dated 17.10.2026 is modified to this extent, and the Appeal and pending applications are disposed of with no order as to costs.
¶ 33Original Court PDF
Anoop SharmavsMr. Bhushan Kumar Narula & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
