01Facts
The Plaintiff, Pooja Gupta, ran a Paying Guest (PG) accommodation for girls at U-204, Shakarpur, Delhi, where each room held two beds, one per resident.
¶ 3The Defendant, Payal, lived there from July to November 2020, and returned in November 2021 and was allotted one bed in Room 403.
¶ 4–5The Plaintiff alleged misconduct, police complaints, and non-payment of rent from January 2023 onward.
¶ 6–10, 73–74She terminated the occupation by legal notice dated 29.12.2022 and sued for possession, arrears, damages and mandatory injunction.
¶ 13, 15The Defendant denied the Plaintiff's ownership. She relied on utility bills and a GST registration in third-party names, and claimed an oral tenancy from April 2018 under caretaker Umesh Kumar at ₹2,800 per month, with a ₹20,000 deposit.
¶ 17–19She also pleaded a plain-paper agreement dated 23.02.2023 under which she paid ₹2,00,000 for Rooms 403 and 406.
¶ 21, 78Her sworn statement under s.165 of the Indian Evidence Act, recorded 12.08.2024, admitted payments of ₹20,000–30,000 to the Plaintiff's husband as rent and ₹2,00,000 for the rooms, but stated she did not know the owners before buying.
¶ 27, 80–81In her own earlier suit (CS No. 1019/2022), she described the Plaintiff and her husband as "owners" and herself as a tenant paying ₹2,800.
¶ 82, 87A Trial Court application under O.VII R.11 CPC was dismissed with observations of "triable issues".
¶ 60–61The Trial Court decreed possession under O.XII R.6 CPC on 14.05.2025.
¶ 27–32The First Appellate Court dismissed the appeal as time-barred (51-day delay) but still considered the merits.
¶ 34–35, 68The Defendant then filed this Regular Second Appeal under s.100 CPC.
¶ 36–3702Issues
i.1. Whether the First Appellate Court erred in refusing to condone a 51-day delay in filing the first appeal without examining the sufficiency of the explanation.
¶ 63–67ii.2. Whether a prior O.VII R.11 finding of "triable issues" bars a decree on admissions under O.XII R.6 CPC.
¶ 59–62iii.3. Whether the Defendant's admissions establish the Plaintiff's ownership and estop the Defendant from disputing her title, and whether the Defendant's occupation was a licence or tenancy.
¶ 69–103iv.4. Whether the unregistered plain-paper agreement dated 23.02.2023 confers any right to continued possession or protection under s.53A TPA.
¶ 104–114v.5. Whether the licence was validly terminated and whether the Plaintiff's entitlement to possession is established.
¶ 116–11903Law Applied
The Court applied O.XII R.6 CPC, which permits judgment on admissions "or otherwise," provided the admissions are clear, categorical and unequivocal, and read with the pleadings as a whole; Rajiv Ghosh v. Satya Narayan Jaiswal, 2025 INSC 467, as cited at para. 84.
¶ 69, 84Pushpa v. Dayawati, 2026 INSC 603 holds that not every statement is an admission and that admissions must establish the relief claimed.
¶ 85Admissions in an earlier suit may be considered.
¶ 86Under s.122 BSA (erstwhile s.116 Evidence Act), a tenant or licensee who came into possession through a person is estopped from disputing that person's title.
¶ 89The licence/lease distinction turns on the parties' intention gathered from substance, not labels; Associated Hotels v. R.N. Kapoor, AIR 1959 SC 1262; Delta International v. Shyam Sundar Ganeriwalla, (1999) 4 SCC 545.
¶ 95, 98A licensee must surrender possession on termination; Sant Lal Jain v. Avtar Singh, (1985) 2 SCC 332.
¶ 102An agreement to sell does not itself confer title or interest; s.54 TPA; Nazim Shaikh Hasan v. Nasir Mushtaq Shaikh, 2026 INSC 853.
¶ 105–107Possession under s.53A TPA requires a registered agreement post-s.17(1A) Registration Act; Ameer Minhaj v. Dierdre Elizabeth Issar, (2018) 7 SCC 639.
¶ 113Filing a suit may itself serve as notice of termination; Nopany Investments v. Santokh Singh, (2008) 2 SCC 728.
¶ 117Delay under s.5 Limitation Act is condoned where sufficient cause is shown, and substantive rights should not be defeated on technical grounds.
¶ 66–67Provisions in the judgment · 16 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 448Section 34Section 147Section 149Section 186Section 353
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 Section 17Section 122
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 105Section 108Section 54Section 111
Indian Easements Act, 1882 Section 52
Registration Act, 1908 Section 17
04Reasoning
On Issue 1, the Court held that the District Judge erred by dismissing the condonation application without considering the explanation. The 17-day period between receiving the certified copy and filing the appeal was not inordinate, and June 2025 was a vacation period. The condonation dismissal was therefore set aside.
¶ 66–67On Issue 2, the Court held that the O.VII R.11 observation concerned only whether the plaint disclosed a cause of action. It did not adjudicate whether the written statement raised triable defences, so it did not preclude an O.XII R.6 decree.
¶ 61–62On Issue 3, the Court held that the Defendant's sworn statement that she paid rent to the Plaintiff's husband, and her agreement to buy the rooms from the Plaintiff, were clear acknowledgments of the Plaintiff's proprietary rights. Her earlier plaint in CS 1019/2022 described the Plaintiff as owner and the caretakers as acting for her. This made her estopped under s.122 BSA.
¶ 81, 87, 89–91On the nature of occupation, the Court found that a PG bed on a double-sharing basis, with management retained by the owner, is a licence, and the Plaintiff's written statement in the earlier suit described the Defendant as a licensee.
¶ 93–101The Court also noted that the Defendant's alleged claim against caretaker Umesh Kumar gave rise to a separate cause of action that could not justify continued occupation.
¶ 88On Issue 4, the Court held that even if the plain-paper agreement was treated as an agreement to sell, it conferred no title. The Defendant's possession was not relatable to that agreement, because she was already a licensee before its execution. The agreement was also unregistered and could not protect possession under s.53A.
¶ 104–106, 110, 113–114The distinction in S.M. Asif was held inapplicable because no specific performance suit was pending.
¶ 110On Issue 5, the Court held that the four requirements for possession were met: the Plaintiff's proprietary right, the Defendant's occupation as licensee, valid termination, and no bar under the Delhi Rent Control Act. Even if the notice was not served, the filing of the suit itself served as notice of termination. The admissions were treated as establishing each of these elements.
¶ 117–11905Holding
The refusal to condone the 51-day delay was improper and is set aside; the O.VII R.11 "triable issues" finding did not bar an O.XII R.6 decree; the Defendant's admissions established the Plaintiff's ownership and made the Defendant a licensee estopped from disputing title; the unregistered plain-paper agreement conferred no title and no s.53A protection; and termination of the licence was valid.
¶ 61–62, 67, 89–91, 101, 104–114, 116–117, 119The Court held that no substantial question of law arises and that the concurrent findings are based on the Defendant's own admissions and settled law. The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed, and the decree for possession under O.XII R.6 CPC is affirmed. The Defendant remains free to pursue any independent remedy regarding the agreement to sell or the claim against Umesh Kumar.
¶ 88, 111, 114, 120–122Original Court PDF
PayalvsPooja Gupta
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
