01Facts
The suit is an intra-family dispute among three brothers: the Plaintiff (Arun Kumar Singal), Defendant No. 1 (Ajay Kumar Singal), and Ashok Kumar Singal (Defendant No. 2, since deceased, represented by Defendants 2A and 2B). Family members, Defendants 4 and 5, and 13 family companies (Defendants 3 and 6–18) are also arrayed.
¶ 2(a) · p. 2A 2016 MoU allocated family companies among the brothers, including Defendant No. 3 (M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd.) to the Plaintiff, but it was never fully implemented.
¶ 2(c)–(d) · pp. 2–3The Plaintiff filed the suit on 26.09.2017 seeking specific performance of the 2016 MoU.
¶ 2(e) · p. 3During mediation, a Second MoU dated 08.07.2019 was executed by 41 signatories.
¶ 2(g) · p. 3The Plaintiff now seeks a decree under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC on the basis of the Second MoU.
¶ 1 · p. 1 · ¶ 2(h) · p. 3On 03.12.2019 the Court directed that the shareholding of Defendant No. 3 and Defendants 6–8 not be altered pending the application.
¶ 4 · p. 4Defendants contend that the settlement is executory, that 22 signatories are not parties to the suit, that FIRs were not quashed, and that consent was vitiated by duress and misrepresentation. These are contentions, not findings.
¶ 11–19 · pp. 6–902Issues
i.1. Whether the Second MoU dated 08.07.2019, by its very nature, is decreeable under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC, given that it binds signatories who are not parties to the suit.
¶ 21 · p. 10 · ¶ 26–27 · p. 23ii.2. Whether the non-party signatories whose rights and obligations are affected must be impleaded before the Court can decide whether a decree may be passed.
¶ 29 · p. 26 · ¶ 30–31 · p. 2703Law Applied
Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC requires that a suit be adjusted by a lawful agreement in writing signed by the parties, and directs a decree only "so far as it relates to the parties to the suit."
¶ 25 · pp. 21–22 · ¶ 26 · p. 23The Rule's proviso requires the Court to decide disputed claims of adjustment, and its Explanation excludes agreements void or voidable under the Indian Contract Act, 1872 from being "lawful."
¶ 25 · p. 22The nature of a party to an agreement must be assessed by reference to the obligations it undertakes; a signatory required to transfer shares, receive consideration, convey property, or perform another obligation affecting its legal rights cannot be treated as a pro forma party.
¶ 29 · p. 26The Plaintiff relied on Pushpa Devi Bhagat v. Rajinder Singh, K. Venkata Seshiah v. Kanduru Ramasubbamma, Bhaja Govinda Maikap v. Janaki Devi, and Kohli Housing & Development (P) Ltd. v. Convenience Enterprises (P) Ltd. for the proposition that a decree may pass despite one party's dispute.
¶ 6 · pp. 4–5The Court did not discuss or rely on the authorities cited by the Plaintiff in its reasoning.
Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 91Section 92
04Reasoning
The Court first noted that the Second MoU involves 41 signatories, including family members, HUFs, shareholders, and corporate entities, whereas the suit has 19 parties. Consequently, at least 22 signatories are not before the Court.
¶ 27–28 · pp. 23–26The Court found that a decree in terms of the MoU would directly affect these non-party signatories' rights and obligations.
¶ 27 · p. 23The Court observed that the MoU requires performance by various non-parties, including transfers of shares and consideration, and that some obligations remain unperformed while others, such as certain FIR quashings, have been acted upon.
¶ 22–24 · pp. 10–21The Plaintiff's argument that the additional signatories are merely pro forma parties was rejected because their reciprocal obligations required examination.
¶ 29 · p. 26The Court held that, before deciding whether a decree could be passed, it was necessary to implead these signatories so they could be heard on whether the application should be allowed and whether the reciprocal obligations can still be performed.
¶ 29–30 · pp. 26–27The Court expressly left open the questions of whether the MoU is a lawful adjustment, whether it is executory, and the other defences raised, to be decided after impleadment.
¶ 32 · p. 2705Holding
The Second MoU cannot be decreed under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC at this stage because it binds non-party signatories whose rights and obligations would be directly affected.
¶ 27–30 · pp. 23–27The Plaintiff must take appropriate steps to implead the signatories who are not parties and whose obligations are affected. The question of decreeability is left open. I.A. 13352/2019 is dismissed, with liberty to the Plaintiff to file a fresh application after taking the necessary steps in accordance with law. The matter is listed before the Roster Bench on 03.12.2026.
¶ 31 · p. 27 · ¶ 32 · p. 27 · ¶ 33 · p. 27 · ¶ 34 · p. 27Original Court PDF
Arun Kumar SingalvsAjay Kumar Singal And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
