APTELAdministrative and Public LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

APTEL Dismisses Adani Transmission's Review Plea, Holding Disagreement With a Judgment Is Not a Ground for Review

Adani Transmission (India) Limitedv.Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors

APTEL Dismisses Adani Transmission's Review Plea, Holding Disagreement With a Judgment Is Not a Ground for Review. Adani Transmission (India) Limited vs Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. APTEL. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the 2017 judgment suffers from an error apparent on the face of the record in upholding CERC's reduction of AC sub-station capital cost by benchmark norms, allegedly contrary to the "specified" requirement and the second proviso to Regulation 7(2) of the 2009 Tariff Regulations.

The court held

No error apparent on the face of the record was shown on Issue 1, namely the benchmark-based reduction of AC sub-station capital cost, and the grievance amounts to a challenge to the merits of the 2017 judgment.

It also directed

No error apparent on the face of the record was shown on Issue 2, namely the reduction of opening loan by cumulative depreciation and the resulting depreciation disallowance.

Any grievance with the merits of the 2017 judgment must be raised by statutory appeal to the Supreme Court under the Electricity Act, 2003.

The Review Petition is dismissed as devoid of merit. No further directions were issued.

01Facts

The present Review Petition seeks review of the Tribunal's judgment dated 8 November 2017 in Appeal No. 226 of 2016.

¶ 1

The Review Petitioner (Adani Transmission) built a dedicated 500 kV Mundra–Mohindergarh HVDC bi-pole line with associated 400 kV lines to evacuate power under PPAs with UHBVNL and DHBVNL.

¶ 2

The Review Petitioner also built the 400 kV Mundra–Dehgam D/C line and the Mohindergarh–Bhiwani line to connect to PGCIL's Dehgam sub-station.

¶ 2

CERC granted a transmission licence for these dedicated assets on 29 July 2013.

¶ 3

The Review Petitioner then sought tariff determination for Asset-1 (HVDC bi-pole and associated lines) and Asset-2 (Mundra–Dehgam line).

¶ 4

CERC's order dated 18 March 2016 reduced the claimed tariff by adjusting the commencement date, reducing the AC sub-station capital cost, and reducing the opening loan by cumulative depreciation up to the licence date.

¶ 5

In Appeal No. 226 of 2016, the Tribunal on 8 November 2017 fixed 29 July 2013 as the tariff commencement date and remanded for recomputation of capital cost, including the Bhiwani and Dehgam sub-stations.

¶ 6

The Tribunal in the 2017 judgment otherwise upheld CERC on (i) capital cost reduction for AC sub-stations other than Dehgam and Bhiwani, and (ii) reduction of loan by cumulative depreciation, with resulting disallowance of depreciation of Rs. 204.69 crore (Asset-1) and Rs. 101.92 crore (Asset-2).

¶ 6

The present review is confined to these two aspects.

¶ 7

Respondent No. 11 filed no reply, and Respondent No. 31 left the matter to the Tribunal; the Petitioner's Senior Counsel alone argued.

¶ 1, 8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the 2017 judgment suffers from an error apparent on the face of the record in upholding CERC's reduction of AC sub-station capital cost by benchmark norms, allegedly contrary to the "specified" requirement and the second proviso to Regulation 7(2) of the 2009 Tariff Regulations.

¶ 17–18, 23

ii.2. Whether the 2017 judgment suffers from an error apparent on the face of the record in upholding the reduction of opening loan by cumulative depreciation up to the licence date, and the consequent depreciation disallowance, when Regulation 7(2) makes a single admitted capital cost the basis for depreciation.

¶ 24–26, 28–30

03Law Applied

The Tribunal treated review as governed by Section 114 CPC and Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC, which permit review only for discovery of new and important matter or evidence, a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason.

¶ 9–10, 11

Relying on Malleeswari v. K. Suguna (2025 INSC 1080), the Tribunal held that review is not an appeal in disguise, cannot rehear the matter, and is confined to patent errors; an error requiring a long process of reasoning or a debatable view is not an error apparent on the face of the record.

¶ 12–14

The Tribunal applied Ghanshyam Mishra and Sons (P) Ltd. v. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Co. Ltd. (2021) 9 SCC 657, which holds that a review cannot be used to repair an erroneous verdict.

¶ 15

On the merits, the Tribunal relied on Regulation 7(2) of the 2009 Tariff Regulations and its provisos, which permit prudence checks against benchmark norms "specified" by the Commission, and require reasonableness checks where no norms are specified.

¶ 18, 21

The Tribunal noted that an erroneous judgment is challengeable only by statutory appeal to the Supreme Court under the Electricity Act, 2003.

¶ 23, 27–28

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 114

Electricity Act, 2003 Section 63Section 62

04Reasoning

On Issue 1, the Petitioner's contention that benchmark norms could be used only if "specified" by Regulations, and that the Commission should have conducted a prudence check under the second proviso, had already been raised, recorded, and rejected in the 2017 judgment.

¶ 19, 23

The earlier judgment had found that the Commission could rely on benchmark norms where the situation warranted, that the Petitioner's own submissions and models were used, and that the benchmark norms, issued in 2010, were not impermissibly retrospective because the 2013 tariff determination was not linked to their issuance.

¶ 19, 21, 22

Since the Petitioner's argument required re-evaluating that reasoning, it was not a patent error.

¶ 23

On Issue 2, the 2017 judgment had considered the Petitioner's arguments on cumulative depreciation, the pruned capital cost, the Section 63 competitive-bid context, and the NTPC precedent, and had found the reduction of opening loan consistent with the Tariff Regulations and sound financial principles.

¶ 26(iv)–(v)

The Tribunal observed that depreciation on pruned capital cost was deferred to the truing-up proceedings.

¶ 26(vii)

The Petitioner's reliance on Regulation 7(2) amounted to a fresh interpretation of the same provision, and therefore did not disclose an error apparent on the face of the record.

¶ 24, 27–29

The Tribunal concluded that the Petitioner was seeking a re-look and an appeal in disguise, which the review jurisdiction does not permit.

¶ 27–29

05Holding

No error apparent on the face of the record was shown on Issue 1, namely the benchmark-based reduction of AC sub-station capital cost, and the grievance amounts to a challenge to the merits of the 2017 judgment.

¶ 23

No error apparent on the face of the record was shown on Issue 2, namely the reduction of opening loan by cumulative depreciation and the resulting depreciation disallowance.

¶ 27–30

Any grievance with the merits of the 2017 judgment must be raised by statutory appeal to the Supreme Court under the Electricity Act, 2003.

¶ 23, 28

The Review Petition is dismissed as devoid of merit. No further directions were issued.

¶ 30
APTEL

Original Court PDF

Adani Transmission (India) LimitedvsCentral Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors

APTEL · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment