APTELAdministrative and Public LawContract Law

APTEL Holds Wind Generators Entitled To Full Tariff For Power Beyond Capacity Utilisation Factor, Sets Aside ₹0.50 Rate

M/s. Beta Wind Farm Private Limitedv.Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors

APTEL Holds Wind Generators Entitled To Full Tariff For Power Beyond Capacity Utilisation Factor, Sets Aside ₹0.50 Rate. M/s. Beta Wind Farm Private Limited vs Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. APTEL. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether APERC was right in prescribing a different commercial treatment for energy generated in excess of the energy corresponding to normative CUF.

The court held

APERC erred in prescribing differential commercial treatment for energy generated beyond normative CUF; the contracted tariff is payable for all Delivered Energy under the PPAs.

It also directed

Issue 2 was not decided on merits because it was rendered academic; the ₹0.50/unit rate and the cumulative annual CUF calculation are set aside.

Remand for fresh tariff determination is refused.

The Impugned Orders are set aside to the extent they prescribe differential treatment for excess generation. Energy generated by the wind power generators is to be paid at the applicable generic tariff, irrespective of whether annual generation exceeds the normative CUF energy. Amounts payable under the judgment carry interest per the relevant PPA provision. The captioned appeal and pending IAs are disposed of accordingly.

01Facts

Beta Wind Farm Pvt. Ltd. (BWFPL) operates a 50.4 MW wind project (50.148 MW export capacity) under a PPA with APSPDCL, executed 29.05.2013 at a firm tariff of ₹4.70/unit for 25 years, based on APERC's order dated 15.11.2012 that assumed a 23% normative CUF.

¶ 8, 9, 38

The project was commissioned on 27.07.2013.

¶ 9

For the period 27.07.2016 to 27.07.2017, APSPDCL paid only for energy up to 23% CUF and treated the excess as free of cost.

¶ 9

Against 2,33,77,000 units billed, 1,07,59,061 units were admitted, leaving 1,26,17,939 units unpaid, quantified by BWFPL at ₹5,93,04,313.

¶ 10

In O.P. No. 85 of 2021, APERC (order dated 26.09.2022) held that CUF must be applied over the PPA life with adjustments, and fixed ₹0.50/unit for energy beyond the prescribed CUF.

¶ 11

BWFPL appealed (No. 600 of 2023) and APSPDCL cross-appealed (No. 746 of 2023). The batch concerns similar orders for other wind generators, with differing capacities, tariffs and CUFs.

¶ 1, 6, 12

02Issues

i.1. Whether APERC was right in prescribing a different commercial treatment for energy generated in excess of the energy corresponding to normative CUF.

¶ 15

ii.2. Whether, if Issue 1 is answered in the affirmative, APERC was justified in fixing the tariff for such excess energy at ₹0.50/unit.

¶ 15, 68

03Law Applied

The Tribunal relied on the PPA's contractual terms, read as a whole: Article 1.5 (definition and Explanation 2 of "Delivered Energy"), Articles 2.1, 2.2 and 5.1, which provide for purchase of all Delivered Energy at the contracted tariff.

¶ 32–34

Normative CUF is a benchmark for computing generic tariff, not a ceiling on energy generated or billed, and the tariff orders do not create separate tranches of energy above and below CUF.

¶ 29–30

Explanation 2 imposes only a monthly ceiling based on export capacity and hours, with no CUF limit.

¶ 37

Courts and Tribunals must give effect to the contractual bargain and cannot rewrite it or import implied terms that contradict express provisions (Nabha Power Ltd. v. PSPCL, (2018) 11 SCC 508; Haryana Power Purchase Centre v. Sasan Power Ltd., (2024) 1 SCC 247; Satya Jain v. Anis Ahmed Rushdie, (2013) 8 SCC 131; TANGEDCO v. GMR Vemagiri, (2018) 3 SCC 716).

¶ 45

The maxim "If it is not necessary to change, it is necessary not to change" applies where no ambiguity exists.

¶ 53

Tariff determinations and regulations may be amended only through proper proceedings under Sections 62 and 64 of the Electricity Act, 2003 (GUVNL v. Solar Semiconductor, (2017) 16 SCC 498, as cited by the Discoms).

¶ 62, 69–70

NSEFI v. TNERC (APTEL, 28.11.2022, Appeal No. 119 of 2021) is persuasive but was distinguished on its facts and bidding framework.

¶ 21, 55

Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Electricity Act, 2003 Section 39Section 40Section 62Section 63Section 64

Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 Section 98

04Reasoning

The Tribunal first rejected the premise of "undue enrichment" that underpinned the Impugned Order.

¶ 28, 44

Because Article 1.5 and the other PPA provisions make no reference to CUF, and Explanation 2 prescribes only an export-capacity-based monthly ceiling, the Discoms' attempt to read a CUF limit into it was unsupported by its language.

¶ 33–37, 43

The Tribunal held that the "based on" wording does not permit introducing an additional parameter, and that "excess energy" in Explanation 2 plainly means energy above the monthly export-capacity limit.

¶ 50–51

The possible purposes of Explanation 2 did not suggest any intent to distinguish CUF energy, and the WPGs had dedicated their full installed capacity for sale.

¶ 41–42

Treating an annual normative benchmark as a monthly ceiling was conceptually inappropriate given wind variability.

¶ 40

The Tribunal also found that the PPA allocates generation risk to the WPG (no change-in-law or force-majeure clause, curtailment under Article 4.19, no compensation for low wind years), so high-generation revenue could not be isolated as unjust enrichment.

¶ 46–47

A CUF ceiling would also discourage generation when wind is available, an outcome not presumed to be intended.

¶ 54

The NSEFI judgment was distinguished because its relief rested on a different contractual and regulatory framework.

¶ 55

On Issue 2, the Tribunal held that, since Issue 1 was decided against APERC, the ₹0.50 rate was unnecessary to examine.

¶ 68

The Tribunal rejected the Discoms' request for remand because the judgment neither amends regulations nor tariff orders, and the pending Supreme Court appeals (Civil Appeal Nos. 10282–10295 of 2025) do not bar enforcement of existing PPAs.

¶ 69–70

05Holding

APERC erred in prescribing differential commercial treatment for energy generated beyond normative CUF; the contracted tariff is payable for all Delivered Energy under the PPAs.

¶ 57, 56

Issue 2 was not decided on merits because it was rendered academic; the ₹0.50/unit rate and the cumulative annual CUF calculation are set aside.

¶ 68 · Order

Remand for fresh tariff determination is refused.

¶ 69–70

The Impugned Orders are set aside to the extent they prescribe differential treatment for excess generation. Energy generated by the wind power generators is to be paid at the applicable generic tariff, irrespective of whether annual generation exceeds the normative CUF energy. Amounts payable under the judgment carry interest per the relevant PPA provision. The captioned appeal and pending IAs are disposed of accordingly.

Order · ¶ 71
APTEL

Original Court PDF

M/s. Beta Wind Farm Private LimitedvsAndhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors

APTEL · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment