01Facts
On 3 September 2014, Assam taxation authorities searched the petitioner’s business premises under Section 74 of the Assam Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (AVAT Act), pursuant to a warrant issued by the Commissioner of Taxes, and seized books, documents, and goods
¶ 3–5The petitioner objected to the search and seizure, including on the grounds that statutory procedure had not been followed and that some seized property belonged to another concern
¶ 6Following assessment proceedings, an assessment order dated 31 December 2014 and demand notice dated 2 January 2015 were issued; a further demand for penalty was communicated in 2020
¶ 2, 7, 9The petitioner had earlier challenged the search in a writ petition, which was disposed of without finally determining its legality; subsequent interlocutory and appellate proceedings were also unsuccessful
¶ 8–11In the present petition, the petitioner challenged the assessment and demands, as well as the search and seizure, without having filed a statutory appeal against the assessment order
¶ 2, 2802Issues
i.1. Whether the powers of search and seizure under Section 74(3), (4), and (5) of the AVAT Act could be exercised only after following the procedure under Section 74(1)
¶ 21–24ii.2. Whether alleged non-compliance with the search-and-seizure procedure under Section 74(10) of the AVAT Act and the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, rendered the search and consequential proceedings invalid
¶ 26–27iii.3. Whether the Court should examine the assessment and demand under Article 226 despite the petitioner’s failure to pursue the statutory appellate remedy
¶ 28–3503Law Applied
Section 74(1) of the AVAT Act empowers the authority to require production of accounts and information, while Sections 74(3), (4), and (5) separately provide for seizure of accounts, entry and search, and seizure of unaccounted goods, subject to their respective statutory conditions; prior recourse to Section 74(1) is not invariably required
¶ 22–24Section 74(10) requires the search-and-seizure authority to follow, as far as may be, the procedure prescribed by the Code of Criminal Procedure, including relevant safeguards under Section 100
¶ 26–27The Court distinguished Saligram & Company v. Deputy Commissioner of Taxes, (1994) 94 STC 189 (Gauhati), because the earlier statute required a Magistrate-issued warrant, unlike Section 74(4) of the AVAT Act
¶ 25The Court also applied the principle in Assistant Commissioner (CT), LTU, Kakinada v. Glaxo Smith Kline Consumer Healthcare Ltd., (2020) 19 SCC 681, that extraordinary jurisdiction should not ordinarily be used to circumvent a statutory appellate remedy that has become time-barred
¶ 33The existence of an alternative remedy is not an absolute bar to Article 226 jurisdiction, particularly in cases of want of jurisdiction or breach of natural justice
¶ 34Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 47Section 100
04Reasoning
The Court held that Section 74(1) operates independently from the search-and-seizure powers in Section 74(3)–(5); therefore, issuing the Section 74(1) notice after the search did not, by itself, invalidate the search
¶ 23–24The record showed independent witnesses, an inventory of seized documents, and a zimmanama, and the petitioner did not establish a procedural violation sufficient to nullify the search and ensuing demand
¶ 27, 35Although the assessment and demand were appealable, the petitioner had not filed an appeal. The earlier writ proceedings neither dispensed with that remedy nor extended or suspended its limitation period; the interlocutory application and subsequent appeal were not substitutes for a statutory appeal
¶ 28, 30–33In these circumstances, and having found no basis to invalidate the search, the Court declined to review the assessment and demand under Article 226
¶ 3505Holding
The Court rejected the contention that Section 74(1) had to be followed before exercising the search-and-seizure powers under Section 74(3), (4), and (5), found no established procedural defect warranting invalidation of the search, and declined to examine the assessment and demand because the petitioner had not pursued the statutory appeal
¶ 35The writ petition was dismissed as devoid of merit, with parties bearing their own costs
¶ 36Original Court PDF
M/S Sri Krishna EnterprisevsThe State Of Assam And 6 Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
