01Facts
The plaintiffs sued for recovery of ₹8,68,000 with pendente lite and future interest on the basis of a pronote and receipt.
¶ 2The defendant denied execution, alleged that thumb impressions were obtained on blank papers, and claimed the pronote, receipt and account entries were forged.
¶ 2After pleadings were complete and issues framed, the court allowed the plaintiffs' application for specimen thumb impressions of the defendants on 12.08.2022.
¶ 2.1The plaintiffs' fingerprint expert, Sh. Shamsher Singh Malik, compared them and submitted a report dated 10.02.2023.
¶ 2.1During the plaintiffs' evidence, one defendant died and his legal representatives were brought on record on 20.12.2024.
¶ 2.2The plaintiffs closed their evidence on 15.09.2025 without examining the expert to prove his report.
¶ 2.2At the defence evidence stage, the plaintiffs sought leave to examine the expert, and the Trial Court dismissed the application by order dated 09.04.2026.
¶ 1, 2.2The plaintiffs challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court erred in refusing the plaintiffs leave to adduce additional evidence by examining the fingerprint expert to prove his report, after the plaintiffs had closed their evidence.
¶ 1, 2.2, 3, 4ii.2. Whether the plaintiffs' omission to examine the expert, attributable to inadvertence, justified permitting belated evidence, and if so, on what conditions.
¶ 5, 5.1, 5.203Law Applied
The Court exercised supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India to examine the legality and propriety of the impugned order.
¶ 1The Court applied general principles governing leave to lead additional evidence, namely whether the evidence introduces a new or undisclosed line of defence, whether it causes irreparable prejudice or necessitates a de novo trial, whether the lapse amounts to inadvertence or lack of diligence, and whether the ends of justice can be secured by costs and conditions.
¶ 5, 5.1, 5.2The Court relied on the principle that the opposing party must be given a full opportunity to cross-examine and rebut the evidence.
¶ 5.1, 6.104Reasoning
The proposed evidence raised no new line of defence, since the defendant had long known the plaintiffs intended to prove the thumb impressions through expert evidence and the specimen comparison had been ordered at the plaintiffs' instance.
¶ 5The omission was treated as inadvertence or lack of diligence, but excluding potentially material expert evidence on the central question of execution and genuineness would be disproportionate in these circumstances.
¶ 5.1Because the defendant had not yet closed its evidence, it could cross-examine the expert and lead rebuttal, so the permission would neither cause irreparable prejudice nor amount to a de novo trial.
¶ 5.1The defendant's inconvenience and delay were addressed through monetary costs and a restriction on pendente lite interest for the intervening period.
¶ 5.2The indulgence was limited to "one final opportunity," which indicates it was granted as an exception rather than a general relaxation.
¶ 5.2, 6(i)05Holding
The Court held that the belated examination of the expert to prove his report is permissible, as the omission was inadvertent and causes no irreversible prejudice, subject to conditions.
¶ 5, 5.1, 5.2The revision is allowed and the impugned order dated 09.04.2026 is set aside. The plaintiffs may lead additional evidence by examining Sh. Shamsher Singh Malik to prove his report dated 10.02.2023, subject to the plaintiffs paying ₹25,000 as costs to the defendant. If the suit is decreed, the plaintiffs are barred from claiming pendente lite interest from the date of the additional-evidence application until the expert's testimony is recorded. The Trial Court must give the defendant a full opportunity to cross-examine the expert and adduce rebuttal evidence, then decide the suit on merits in accordance with law. The observations are confined to the revision and express no opinion on the merits.
¶ 6, 6(i), 6(ii), 6(iii), 6.1, 7Original Court PDF
M/S Suresh Kumar Nitin Kumar & AnrvsKaran Singh (Since Deceased) Through Lrs
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
