Punjab and Haryana High CourtConstitutional LawProperty and Real Estate Law

Haryana must pay compensation for private land used for road without acquisition, says HC citing Article 300A

Malik Singh Kang And Othersv.State Of Haryana And Another

Haryana must pay compensation for private land used for road without acquisition, says HC citing Article 300A. Malik Singh Kang And Others vs State Of Haryana And Another. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the State's use of the petitioners' land for the Kurukshetra–Jhansa Road without acquisition or payment of compensation violates the right under Article 300A of the Constitution.

The court held

The State's use of the petitioners' land for the road without acquisition or compensation violated Article 300A.

It also directed

The delay and laches plea was rejected, and the petitioners are entitled to compensation.

The Court ordered (i) compensation for 2 kanal 19 marla in Khasra 204/4 and 2 kanal 5 marla in Khasra 204/5, limited to each petitioner's proportionate share; (ii) the State to determine each share within three months after hearing the petitioners; (iii) market value fixed at the Collector's rate on the judgment date, with 100% solatium and 12% interest from the judgment date until payment; (iv) assessment within five months and payment within six months; (v) petitioners to execute registered sale deeds in favour of the State on receipt of compensation; and (vi) no further claim regarding the existing road.

01Facts

Tej Partap owned land in Khasra Nos. 204/4 (19 kanal 16 marla) and 204/5 (7 kanal 2 marla) in Village Darra Kalan, Tehsil Thanesar, Kurukshetra.

¶ 5, 18

After his death, the land passed to his heirs, including the present petitioners.

¶ 5, 18

Petitioners sought demarcation through repeated applications to the Tehsildar between 2017 and 2022.

¶ 6, 30

A demarcation in CWP-1511-2023 dated 03.09.2021 found 2 kanal 5 marla of Khasra 204/5 under a PWD road and footpath.

¶ 19–20

In CWP-16690-2023, petitioner No. 2 filed CWP-10683-2022.

The Tehsildar's written statement (25.07.2022) disclosed that Khasra 204/4 contained 5 kanal recorded as "Gair Mumkin Sadak."

¶ 7

Petitioners then obtained RTI replies stating that acquisition and compensation records were unavailable.

¶ 8

A Coordinate Bench directed a demarcation on 03.08.2023.

The resulting report dated 22.08.2023 found 2 kanal 19 marla of Khasra 204/4 used for the road and drain.

¶ 11–12

The State did not place this report on record and later sought to challenge it, which the Court stayed on 07.08.2025.

¶ 13–15

The Court found this conduct contumacious but took no further action.

¶ 15

The State's written statement (20.11.2025) pleaded that the road was built in 1974–75 on the landowners' free will and oral consent, that the widening occurred in 1992, 2000 and 2016, and that the claim suffered from delay and laches.

¶ 16, 24

The State relied on sale deeds dated 15.06.1970 and 11.07.1974.

¶ 24, 28

02Issues

i.1. Whether the State's use of the petitioners' land for the Kurukshetra–Jhansa Road without acquisition or payment of compensation violates the right under Article 300A of the Constitution.

¶ 23, 36–38

ii.2. Whether the writ petitions are barred by delay, laches or acquiescence, particularly given the alleged oral consent of the predecessors and the sale deeds relied upon by the State.

¶ 24, 28–31, 39–40, 43–45

iii.3. Whether the plea of oral consent can justify deprivation of property in the absence of written consent or acquisition.

¶ 27, 39–40

iv.4. What relief the petitioners are entitled to: restoration of the land or compensation under the 2013 Act.

¶ 46

03Law Applied

Article 300A, inserted by the 44th Amendment, bars deprivation of property save by authority of law.

¶ 35–36

Under Vidya Devi v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2020), the right to property remains a constitutional and human right, and the State must pay compensation for property taken without legal sanction.

¶ 37, 38

Oral consent is not a valid defence, and adverse possession cannot be pleaded by a welfare State.

¶ 37, 38

Sukh Dutt Ratra v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2022) holds that the State cannot shield itself behind delay and laches in such cases, and that oral consent unsupported by written consent is insufficient.

¶ 39–40

Abdul Rashid Wani v. UT of J&K (2026) holds that once the State admits use of land for public purpose without acquisition, compensation must follow, even after long delay.

¶ 41

K.T. Plantation v. State of Karnataka (Constitution Bench, 2011) holds that public purpose is a precondition for deprivation under Article 300A and that the right to compensation is inbuilt.

¶ 42

State of Maharashtra v. Digambar (1995), which denied relief on grounds of delay in scarcity-relief road works, was distinguished.

¶ 43–44

Bhupal Sharma v. State of Haryana (CWP-17369-2001) supplied the basis for the relief formula.

¶ 46

Under Sections 26(1) and 30 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition Act, 2013, the market value is fixed as of the notification date (here, the judgment date) and solatium is payable.

¶ 47(iv)–(vi)

A jamabandi carries a presumption of truth.

¶ 25

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 Section 11Section 26Section 30

04Reasoning

The Court found ownership undisputed, supported by the State's own jamabandi, which recorded 5 kanal as "Gair Mumkin Sadak."

¶ 25

It held that the land was taken without acquisition or compensation, violating Article 300A.

¶ 25, 38

The demarcation dated 22.08.2023 limited the quantum to 2 kanal 19 marla. The petitioners fairly accepted this finding, which the Court accepted.

¶ 26

The Court rejected the oral consent plea as unsubstantiated and self-contradictory, since the State simultaneously relied on consent and denied taking the land.

¶ 27, 33, 40

The sale deeds did not refer to Khasra 204/4 and only described the road as adjoining the plots, so they did not show knowledge of encroachment.

¶ 28

The delay defence failed because the petitioners repeatedly sought demarcation, were unaware of the encroachment until the 2022 written statement, and acted promptly after RTI disclosures. The widening of the road in 2016 indicated the encroachment likely occurred then.

¶ 29–31, 45

The facts were held to be distinguishable from Digambar, which involved a documented scarcity-relief context and mass delayed litigation.

¶ 43–44

Since the petitioners remain co-sharers in other land and the entire holding was not taken, their claim was limited to the proportionate share in the affected area.

¶ 45, 47(iii)

Return of the land was not granted because the road already exists.

¶ 46

05Holding

The State's use of the petitioners' land for the road without acquisition or compensation violated Article 300A.

¶ 25–46

The delay and laches plea was rejected, and the petitioners are entitled to compensation.

¶ 25–46

The Court ordered (i) compensation for 2 kanal 19 marla in Khasra 204/4 and 2 kanal 5 marla in Khasra 204/5, limited to each petitioner's proportionate share; (ii) the State to determine each share within three months after hearing the petitioners; (iii) market value fixed at the Collector's rate on the judgment date, with 100% solatium and 12% interest from the judgment date until payment; (iv) assessment within five months and payment within six months; (v) petitioners to execute registered sale deeds in favour of the State on receipt of compensation; and (vi) no further claim regarding the existing road.

¶ 47(i)–(xii)
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Malik Singh Kang And OthersvsState Of Haryana And Another

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment