01Facts
The applicants, five daughters of the deceased testator, sought recall of the order dated 26 April 2024 granting probate of Dhirendra Mohan Ojha’s Will ex parte.
pp. 1–3They said their absence resulted from illness in the family and, in particular, their advocates’ failure to take steps after a change of counsel; they also asserted that they had not received notice of the ex parte hearing.
pp. 1–3The propounders opposed recall, contending that the applicants had participated until the issues were framed, had been given opportunities to contest, and had then failed to appear.
pp. 1–3The Court noted that the probate order had relied on the evidence of two attesting witnesses, which had not been cross-examined.
pp. 5–602Issues
i.Whether the ex parte order granting probate should be recalled where the applicants’ absence was attributed to the inaction or non-cooperation of their counsel.
pp. 7–9ii.Whether the applicants should be permitted to contest the probate proceedings, including by cross-examining the propounders’ attesting witnesses and adducing further evidence.
pp. 8–903Law Applied
The Court applied the principle that litigants should not suffer because of their counsel’s non-cooperation, laches or inaction.
p. 8It also considered the principle that sworn testimony left unchallenged despite an opportunity to cross-examine may be treated as admitted, which had supported the original probate order.
pp. 5–6Although the probate proceeding concerned proof of a Will under the Indian Succession Act, 1925, the judgment does not identify a specific statutory provision as the basis for deciding the recall application.
pp. 4–704Reasoning
The Court accepted that the original order had considered the framed issues and the attesting witnesses’ evidence, and that the witnesses’ testimony supporting execution and the testator’s sound state of mind had gone unchallenged.
pp. 4–7Nevertheless, it found that the applicants had engaged replacement counsel before the probate order was passed, but that counsel failed to act in time and filed the vakalatnama only after the order; the applicants later re-engaged their former lawyers to seek recall.
p. 7In the Court’s view, these circumstances showed that the applicants’ absence was attributable to counsel-related non-cooperation and that barring the testator’s daughters from contesting the probate proceedings would cause a gross miscarriage of justice.
pp. 7–9The Court therefore allowed them an opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses and present further evidence, without determining the merits of the Will.
p. 905Holding
The recall application was allowed, subject to payment of costs of Rs. 50,000 to the propounders within two weeks.
pp. 8–9The order dated 26 April 2024 was recalled subject to that condition; the applicants’ caveat was restored, and the parties were permitted to adduce further oral and documentary evidence, with the applicants specifically granted leave to cross-examine PW 1 and PW 2.
pp. 8–9Original Court PDF
IN THE GOODS OF SRI DHIRENDRA MOHAN OJHA (DEC.) -AND- SMRITIREKHA OJHA AND BIVA NANDYvsMUKTI OJHA (KUMAR), MALA OJHA (KUNDU) DIPTI OJHA, TRIPTI OJHA (ROY) BANANI OJHA (INDU)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
