01Facts
The petitioner applied in response to a 2007 advertisement for an LPG distributorship at Barrackpore/Kalyani Highway More under the SC category and for a Rural-market location.
¶ 2–4After litigation concerning the selection process, the petitioner was empanelled and received Letters of Intent in 2013; a 2019 reasoned order subsequently confirmed his selection.
¶ 2–4In 2022, the petitioner disputed the Corporation’s treatment of the distributorship as Gramin Vitarak, contending that the location qualified as Rurban Vitarak.
¶ 5–10Following an RTI request and first appeal, the Corporation supplied a relevant extract of the Unified Guidelines on 19 February 2024 but declined to disclose the complete internal manual.
¶ 5–10The petitioner sought to quash that letter and obtain recognition of the distributorship as Rurban Vitarak.
¶ 1, 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner, having applied and been empanelled for a Rural-market location, could claim that the distributorship should be categorised as Rurban Vitarak.
¶ 20ii.2. Whether the Corporation’s 19 February 2024 RTI response was liable to be quashed for failing to provide the complete Unified Guidelines or adequately explain the classification.
¶ 20–2303Law Applied
The Court applied the Corporation’s distributorship-selection framework, including clause 6.2.1 of the Unified Guidelines 2022, which maps earlier market classifications to the current nomenclature: Urban to Sheheri Vitrak, Urban Rural to Rurban Vitrak, and Rural to Gramin Vitrak.
¶ 24–25, 28It treated the classification as a market type under the Corporation’s scheme, distinct from a statutory or census determination of whether an area is rural or urban.
¶ 22In the RTI context, the Court noted that a complaint about the adequacy of information supplied is to be pursued through the remedies provided under the RTI Act, rather than used to challenge a distributorship classification not made by the impugned communication.
¶ 2304Reasoning
The petitioner’s advertisement, application and Letters of Intent related to a Rural-market distributorship, and the petitioner had himself acknowledged applying under the Rural category; the record did not show that he had ever been categorised as Rurban Vitrak.
¶ 21Under clause 6.2.1, a Rural location corresponds to Gramin Vitrak, and the petitioner’s later reliance on the 2022 Guidelines did not change the category for which he had applied and been empanelled.
¶ 24–25, 28The Corporation’s 19 February 2024 letter merely responded to the RTI appeal by supplying the relevant extract; it neither made nor altered the distributorship classification.
¶ 21, 23, 29Any challenge to the sufficiency of that RTI response belonged under the RTI Act, and no prejudice arising from the withheld manual was established.
¶ 21, 23, 2905Holding
The Court held that the petitioner was not entitled to Rurban Vitrak classification for a distributorship sought and obtained under the Rural category, and that the 19 February 2024 letter was an RTI-compliance communication that did not affect his rights.
¶ 29–30The writ petition was dismissed without costs; connected applications were disposed of and any interim order was vacated.
¶ 31–32Original Court PDF
PRASUN KANTI MONDALvsINDIAN OIL CORPORATION AND ORS.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
