Allahabad High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Candidate bound by application-declared category; post-deadline switch from EWS to Unreserved impermissible absent express advertisement provision

Mohit Kumarv.State Of U.P. And 4 Others

Candidate bound by application-declared category; post-deadline switch from EWS to Unreserved impermissible absent express advertisement provision. Mohit Kumar vs State Of U.P. And 4 Others. Allahabad High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Commission could cancel the petitioner's candidature for declaring EWS category in the online application, despite his prior affidavit, his undertaking, and his claimed merit-based selection in the UR category.

The court held

The Court held that the petitioner could not alter his declared category from EWS to UR after the prescribed deadline and the Commission's express bar, and that cancellation of his candidature under the advertisement's conditions was legally sustainable.

It also directed

The writ petition was dismissed, the notification dated 16.10.2026 was upheld, and the recommendation of Suraj Singh was sustained.

No order as to costs was passed.

01Facts

The petitioner applied for the post of Lecturer in Textile Technology under the UPPSC advertisement dated 15.09.2021 and, in the online form, mentioned his category as EWS, though he was UR and held no EWS certificate.

¶ 3–4

He appeared in the written examination (26.11.2025) and was called for interview (27.04.2026).

¶ 3, 30

On 02.05.2026 he filed an affidavit stating that the EWS entry was a clerical or technical error and seeking consideration under the UR category.

¶ 4, 31

On 05.05.2026, as a condition for being allowed to sit the interview, he furnished an undertaking to produce an EWS certificate by 20.05.2026.

¶ 7, 25, 30

The select list dated 25.06.2026 placed him at Serial No. 4 under "UR/EWS" with provisional status.

¶ 8, 28

His representations dated 29.06.2026 and 03.08.2026 were not decided and were consigned to records.

¶ 9, 35

The Commission recommended 34 of 35 listed candidates and omitted the petitioner.

¶ 10

By notification dated 16.10.2026, his candidature was cancelled and Suraj Singh (Roll No. 0900854) was recommended against the resultant vacancy.

¶ 11, 34

No separate cancellation order was served on him.

¶ 11

The petitioner challenged the notification under Article 226 of the Constitution.

¶ 2

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Commission could cancel the petitioner's candidature for declaring EWS category in the online application, despite his prior affidavit, his undertaking, and his claimed merit-based selection in the UR category.

¶ 43–46

ii.2. Whether the petitioner was entitled to consideration in the UR category on the authority of Pankaj Singh and Pankhudi Agarwal, given the absence of any corresponding advertisement provision.

¶ 17, 39, 47–48

iii.3. Whether the consequential recommendation of Suraj Singh is sustainable.

¶ 50

03Law Applied

The advertisement's "Important Instructions" provide that concealment or misrepresentation may lead to cancellation of candidature.

¶ 18

Clause 13.2 provides that category claims are valid only up to the last date of submission, that no correction is permitted, and that false or misleading information results in cancellation.

¶ 21

Clause 13.10 provides that ineligible candidates admitted provisionally may be rejected at any stage.

¶ 22

The Commission's decision of 02.08.2024 barred post-deadline alteration of category, and the EWS certificate validity rule under the OM dated 18.02.2019 applied.

¶ 33

The applicant's declaration form made the declaration binding.

¶ 23

Conditions of an advertisement are mandatory and cannot be relaxed by the Commission or the Court, per State of Tamil Nadu v. G. Hemalathaa, (2020) 19 SCC 430.

¶ 41

Conditions of an advertisement are mandatory and cannot be relaxed by the Commission or the Court, per Bedanga Talukdar v. Saifudaullah Khan, (2011) 12 SCC 85.

¶ 46

Poonam Dwivedi v. State of U.P. (2026 SCC OnLine SC 577) cautions against challenges that stall recruitment.

¶ 42

Pankaj Singh v. State of U.P. (Writ-A No. 36163 of 2013) permits UR consideration only where the advertisement expressly provides for it.

¶ 47–48

Pankhudi Agarwal (Writ-A No. 8882 of 2023) distinguishes unsubstantiated claims from deliberate misrepresentation and proportionality.

¶ 17, 39

Prabhakar Mani Tripathi (Writ-A No. 17824 of 2019) upheld the bar on category change after submission.

¶ 40

Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution require uniform criteria in recruitment.

¶ 49

Provisions in the judgment · 1

Right to Information Act, 2005 Section 1

04Reasoning

The court held that the petitioner's successive declarations (the online entry, the 02.05.2026 affidavit, and the 05.05.2026 undertaking) formed a consistent pattern that could not be treated as an isolated procedural step, and that the undertaking was a solemn obligation that could not be disowned after it had secured interview access.

¶ 44–45

Merit-based selection in the UR category did not override the advertisement's framework, because UR is "not a residual avenue" open to a candidate at his convenience after the Commission has acted on his declaration.

¶ 45

Pankaj Singh was distinguished because it rested on General Instruction No. 11, an express advertisement provision for UR consideration, which is absent here.

¶ 48

Pankhudi Agarwal was distinguished on facts, since that candidate disclosed her claims at the application stage.

¶ 39

The court held that an inconsistent affidavit or missing certificate is not, by itself, fraud, and that cancellation must rest on the advertisement's language and cogent material.

¶ 48

The petitioner's merit claim was unsupported by specific particulars or documents in the record.

¶ 28

Because the cancellation was found sustainable, the consequential recommendation of Suraj Singh was also upheld.

¶ 50

05Holding

The Court held that the petitioner could not alter his declared category from EWS to UR after the prescribed deadline and the Commission's express bar, and that cancellation of his candidature under the advertisement's conditions was legally sustainable.

¶ 46–48, 50

The writ petition was dismissed, the notification dated 16.10.2026 was upheld, and the recommendation of Suraj Singh was sustained.

¶ 50–51

No order as to costs was passed.

¶ 51
Allahabad High Court

Original Court PDF

Mohit KumarvsState Of U.P. And 4 Others

Allahabad High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment