Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawHuman Rights Law

Civic body must pay Rs 30 lakh compensation to families of two men who died cleaning a sewage plant, recovering it from the firm later, rules Karnataka HC

SHASHI EXPORTS PRIVATE LIMITEDv.STATE OF KARNATAKA

Civic body must pay Rs 30 lakh compensation to families of two men who died cleaning a sewage plant, recovering it from the firm later, rules Karnataka HC. SHASHI EXPORTS PRIVATE LIMITED vs STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the establishment's challenge to the Commission's communication dated 26.12.2023, which recommended payment of compensation, is maintainable or premature in the absence of any enforcement action under the Rehabilitation Act or the Government Order dated 20.06.2024

The court held

The establishment's challenge to the Commission's communication dated 26.12.2023 is premature. W.P. No. 815/2024 was held premature, with no opinion expressed on the establishment's liability under the Rehabilitation Act. The establishment may approach the Court only if the GBA demands recovery under the Government Order dated 20.06.2024

It also directed

The dependents' petition is allowed. The Commissioner, Bengaluru South City Corporation, is directed to pay the balance ₹20,00,000 to each set of dependents as compensation under the Rehabilitation Act, acting under the Government Order dated 20.06.2024, within four weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order. The payment is without prejudice to the local authority's right to examine recovery from the establishment. The dependents may file a representation before the Commission for rehabilitation under Section 13, which the Commission is to consider expeditiously. All pending applications are disposed of

01Facts

Two workers died of asphyxia while cleaning a Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) within the petitioner's industrial establishment, an act of manual scavenging

¶ 1

The Karnataka State Commission for Safai Karamcharis ("Commission") by communication dated 26.12.2023 opined that the deaths resulted from the establishment's disregard of Pollution Control Board guidelines and recommended that the establishment pay ₹30,00,000 to each dependent

¶ 2

The establishment challenged this communication in W.P. No. 815/2024. The Court stayed the communication on 08.01.2024, subject to the establishment depositing ₹20,00,000, which was deposited and disbursed among the dependents

¶ 3

On 06.06.2025, the Court, relying on Balram Singh v. Union of India (2023 SCC OnLine SC 1386), held that pending writ proceedings would not prevent the State from paying compensation under the Government Order dated 20.06.2024

¶ 3

The dependents, who had received only ₹10,00,000 each, filed W.P. No. 16784/2025 seeking the balance and rehabilitation under Section 13 of the Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013 ("Rehabilitation Act")

¶ 4

The establishment did not oppose compensation but objected to being proceeded against under the Rehabilitation Act, citing penal consequences and a stayed criminal case (Crime No. 729 of 2023)

¶ 5

The Commission and the dependents' counsel contended that the communication was merely a recommendation under Section 31 of the Rehabilitation Act

¶ 6

02Issues

i.1. Whether the establishment's challenge to the Commission's communication dated 26.12.2023, which recommended payment of compensation, is maintainable or premature in the absence of any enforcement action under the Rehabilitation Act or the Government Order dated 20.06.2024

¶ 6, 15

ii.2. Whether the dependents are entitled to the balance compensation of ₹20,00,000 each under the Government Order dated 20.06.2024 and the Apex Court's directions, and which authority must pay it

¶ 7, 12–13

iii.3. Whether the State or the local body (GBA/BBMP) must pay the compensation when the private entity has not done so, and whether the entity can be compelled to pay

¶ 7, 11–12, 14

03Law Applied

The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013, under which the Commission functions and makes recommendations (Section 31) and under which rehabilitation is to be provided (Section 13)

¶ 6, 15

Safai Karamchari Andolan v. Union of India (2014), which held that manual scavenging must be addressed through rehabilitation, including compensation of ₹10,00,000 for sewer deaths

¶ 8

Balram Singh v. Union of India (2023 SCC OnLine SC 1386), which raised compensation for sewer deaths to ₹30,00,000 and directed that the State or Union Territory pay it

¶ 9–10

The Apex Court directed that the appropriate government devise accountability mechanisms, including contract cancellation and monetary liability on the responsible party

¶ 9–10

Government Order dated 20.06.2024 requires the local body to pay compensation promptly where the private entity defaults, with recovery to follow

¶ 11–12

A party cannot assert a cause before an adverse action is taken, and a recommendation does not itself create liability

¶ 15

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013 Section 13Section 31Section 32

04Reasoning

The Court first identified the focal question as who bears the liability to pay compensation, not whether dependents are entitled to it

¶ 7

Applying Balram Singh and the Government Order, the Court held that where a sewer death occurs within BBMP/GBA limits, the local body must ensure payment promptly and cannot defer payment because the private entity disputes liability. It may then seek recovery

¶ 12

The delay in acting under the Government Order was attributed to the establishment's stayed writ and interim order, and the Court held that the dependents could not be made to wait further

¶ 13

The establishment's objection was that the Rehabilitation Act's penal and adverse consequences would follow from the communication. The Court held this was not yet a cause of action. The communication was only a recommendation, and the establishment could only challenge a concrete action under the Government Order, such as a GBA demand for recovery

¶ 14–15

Because the establishment did not dispute compensation, the Court directed the local authority to pay the balance without awaiting the outcome of the liability dispute

¶ 14, 15

05Holding

The establishment's challenge to the Commission's communication dated 26.12.2023 is premature. W.P. No. 815/2024 was held premature, with no opinion expressed on the establishment's liability under the Rehabilitation Act. The establishment may approach the Court only if the GBA demands recovery under the Government Order dated 20.06.2024

¶ 15 · Order A

The dependents' petition is allowed. The Commissioner, Bengaluru South City Corporation, is directed to pay the balance ₹20,00,000 to each set of dependents as compensation under the Rehabilitation Act, acting under the Government Order dated 20.06.2024, within four weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order. The payment is without prejudice to the local authority's right to examine recovery from the establishment. The dependents may file a representation before the Commission for rehabilitation under Section 13, which the Commission is to consider expeditiously. All pending applications are disposed of

¶ 15 · Orders B, C, D, E, F
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SHASHI EXPORTS PRIVATE LIMITEDvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment