Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Fixed-tenure appointment on deputation under recruitment rules cannot be curtailed arbitrarily, only on justifiable grounds

DR C T PUTTASWAMYv.THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Fixed-tenure appointment on deputation under recruitment rules cannot be curtailed arbitrarily, only on justifiable grounds. DR C T PUTTASWAMY vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the order posting the petitioner for "one year or till further orders, whichever is earlier" entitles the State to curtail his tenure in the manner adopted by Annexure-A.

The court held

The court answered the issue in the negative: the "until further orders" language does not entitle the State to curtail the tenure arbitrarily.

It also directed

Annexure-A was set aside as arbitrary and unreasoned. The petition was allowed in part. The petitioner is to continue in service until 27.01.2027 on the same terms, and is to be reinstated forthwith and in any event within one week, with continuity of service and pay from the date of Annexure-A to the date of reinstatement.

The relief for extension beyond 27.01.2027 (to 26.01.2028) was refused. The petition is disposed of.

01Facts

The petitioner, a Professor at B.M.S. College of Engineering, was appointed Director (Technical Cell), Department of Forest, Ecology and Environment, on 27.01.2025 "till further orders" (Annexure-B).

¶ 3–4

The terms (Annexure-N, dated 10.06.2025) provided for a one-year contractual appointment "or until further orders whichever is earlier".

¶ 4, 10

By Annexure-P (23.01.2026), the appointment was extended for one year from 27.01.2026.

¶ 4, 12

By order dated 24.07.2026 (Annexure-A), the petitioner was relieved and Respondent No. 4 was posted in his place, with immediate effect.

¶ 1, 5, 31

The petitioner sought quashing of Annexure-A and a mandamus permitting him to serve a three-year tenure.

¶ 2

The State contended that the appointment was strictly "until further orders," that deputationists have no indefeasible right to continue, and that the petitioner's lien at B.M.S. College did not bind the State.

¶ 6

Respondent No. 4 adopted the State's contentions.

¶ 7

The Annexure-A order assigned no reason.

¶ 31

02Issues

i.1. Whether the order posting the petitioner for "one year or till further orders, whichever is earlier" entitles the State to curtail his tenure in the manner adopted by Annexure-A.

¶ 9

03Law Applied

The court relied on the Karnataka Government Secretariat Services (Recruitment) Rules, 2019, Schedule IX, which provides for filling the post of Director (Technical Cell) by deputation or posting under a recruitment mechanism.

¶ 13–14

The court applied the distinction in Union of India v. S.N. Maity (2015) 4 SCC 164, following Ashok Kumar Ratilal Patel (2012) 7 SCC 757, between "transfer on deputation" and "appointment on deputation," holding that an appointment made after due selection under recruitment rules is an appointment, not a transfer.

¶ 15, 25–26

Under Maity, a fixed tenure may be curtailed only on rational grounds and not arbitrarily or capriciously; "until further orders" does not confer unguided power to curtail.

¶ 29

The court applied Rule 8(47) of the Karnataka Civil Services Rules, 1958, defining a "tenure post".

¶ 18

Following P. Venugopal v. Union of India (2008) 5 SCC 1, tenure ends on completion unless curtailed on justifiable grounds.

¶ 20, 22

Under K. Anbazhagan v. Registrar General, Madras High Court (2018) 9 SCC 293, an appointment against a sanctioned post with a pay scale is not contractual.

¶ 23–24

Article 14 requires fair dealing with employees.

¶ 30

Under Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC (1978) 1 SCC 405, an order must speak for itself and cannot be supplemented by affidavits.

¶ 32

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

KARNATAKA STATE CIVIL SERVICES ACT, 1978 Section 3Section 8

04Reasoning

The court held that the petitioner's posting was an appointment on deputation under the Rules, not a simple transfer on deputation, because he was selected through the prescribed process for a sanctioned permanent post.

¶ 15–16, 19, 25–26

Although the Rules do not prescribe a tenure, the specific order fixed a one-year term, so the post operated as a tenure posting for the petitioner.

¶ 17

The contractual label in Annexure-N did not displace this character, since the post is sanctioned, carries a pay scale, and is filled under the Rules.

¶ 23–24

Relying on Venugopal and Maity, the court held that "until further orders" does not authorise unguided curtailment, and any curtailment within the one-year term requires justifiable grounds and cannot be arbitrary.

¶ 21–22, 27–29

Annexure-A was an immediate displacement that assigned no reason, and the court refused to read in reasons from the State's pleadings or affidavits.

¶ 31–32

The petitioner's claim to extension until 26.01.2028 was rejected, because the BMS College lien binds only the College and creates no right of continued Government employment beyond the Annexure-P tenure.

¶ 34

05Holding

The court answered the issue in the negative: the "until further orders" language does not entitle the State to curtail the tenure arbitrarily.

¶ 33

Annexure-A was set aside as arbitrary and unreasoned. The petition was allowed in part. The petitioner is to continue in service until 27.01.2027 on the same terms, and is to be reinstated forthwith and in any event within one week, with continuity of service and pay from the date of Annexure-A to the date of reinstatement.

¶ 31–33, 35

The relief for extension beyond 27.01.2027 (to 26.01.2028) was refused. The petition is disposed of.

¶ 34–35
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

DR C T PUTTASWAMYvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment