01Facts
KSRTC executed a registered concession agreement dated 27.06.2012 with KSMZ Properties Pvt. Ltd. (the concessionaire) for operating commercial-cum-retail space at Shivamogga Bus Terminal.
¶ 7The agreement was extended to 15.03.2025.
¶ 7KSMZ granted sub-leases to the other petitioners on back-to-back terms, under which the concession agreement applied mutatis mutandis.
¶ 7Force majeure is governed by Article 8 and termination following force majeure by Article 9.4.
¶ 7–8During COVID-19, a strike by KSRTC employees ran from 07.04.2021 to 21.04.2021, and a lockdown from 21.04.2021 to 20.06.2021 followed.
¶ 11.1, 21.2A communication dated 01.09.2021, addressed to Senior and Divisional Controllers, recorded a CCG decision (27.08.2021) granting a licence-fee concession for April–June 2021 to all licensees except ATM and mobile tower licensees. The concession was 70% for April and June and 100% for May. It expressly excluded GST and any concession from July 2021 onwards.
¶ 20.8Licensees paid on that basis.
¶ 20.10In 2022, KSRTC issued demands. On 21.03.2022 its Board, at the 447th meeting, rejected the CCG recommendation and resolved to recover the full licence fee.
¶ 15.7, 23.6Demand letters followed on 06.04.2022, 08.04.2022, 09.04.2022 and 11.05.2022.
¶ 11.4A further resolution dated 13.11.2024 is also challenged.
¶ 13.5Fresh notices dated 18.08.2025, 01.09.2025 and 16.10.2025 demanded ₹43,86,818 for April–June 2021 (licence fee ₹37,17,642 plus GST ₹6,69,176).
¶ 10.8–10.10The petitioner in W.P. 7641/2023 surrendered its premises, which KSRTC accepted on 31.01.2022. It paid a security deposit of ₹22,38,596 and faced a demand of ₹10,19,317.
¶ 13.3–13.4, 24.1Petitioners 9 and 10 in W.P. 20426/2022 vacated their premises and sought refund of deposits.
¶ 12.9, 24.2The petitioner in W.P. 27997/2023 deposited ₹6,68,668 and sought protection against its adjustment.
¶ 6, 24.3KSRTC contended that the 01.09.2021 letter was an internal recommendation, that the Board had rejected it, that the writs were barred by the arbitration clause, and that no Article 8 notice was given.
¶ 15.1–15.902Issues
i.1. Whether the writ petitions are maintainable despite the arbitration clause (Cl. 12.3.1) of the Concession Agreement.
¶ 17(i), 19.1–19.14ii.2. Whether the communication dated 01.09.2021 constituted a final and binding concession for April–June 2021, whether the issuing authority was competent, and whether the concession extended to GST and sub-lessees.
¶ 17(ii), 20.1–20.25iii.3. Whether the COVID-19 pandemic and restrictions attracted the force majeure clause (Art. 8), whether the petitioners complied with its procedure, and whether Art. 9.4 applies.
¶ 17(iii), 21.1–21.30iv.4. Whether continued possession disentitled the petitioners from suspension or waiver of licence fee under the Concession Agreement and Sections 108(B)(e) and 108(B)(l) of the TPA.
¶ 17(iv), 22.1–22.17v.5. Whether the Board resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 and the consequential demands are sustainable, having regard to withdrawal authority, natural justice, promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation.
¶ 17(v), 23.1–23.37vi.6. Whether the petitioners are entitled to refund of security deposits, protection against adjustment, and interest.
¶ 17(vi), 24.1–24.1403Law Applied
Clause 12.3.1 of the Concession Agreement refers disputes to the MD of BMTC as sole arbitrator. Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is discretionary but not excluded where a genuine public-law element exists.
¶ 19.3–19.8Article 8.1.1 (epidemic, state-wide strikes and analogous events), the notice, consultation and mitigation procedure in Article 8.3, and Article 9.4 on termination for prolonged force majeure.
¶ 8.1–8.3, 21.8–21.24Section 108(B)(e) and (l) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, relying on Ramanand v. Girish Soni (Del HC): a lessee must exercise the avoidance option under clause (e) to escape rent, and mere non-use does not suspend rent.
¶ 22.2–22.10Promissory estoppel principles in Kasinka Trading and Monnet Ispat, and the four-element Section 115 Evidence Act test in Pratima Chowdhury v. Kalpana Mukherjee (representation, acceptance, alteration of position, inequity), with Dattatraya v. Rangnath on admissions.
¶ 23.19–23.24Legitimate expectation principles in GNCT of Delhi v. Naresh Kumar.
¶ 23.14P.H. Avari, Rachapudi Subrahmanyam, P.C. Sethi and Central Coalfields v. SLL-SML, as limits on estoppel against government and on strict compliance with prescribed procedures.
¶ 23.25–23.29Article 14 and the need for a comparator.
¶ 23.30–23.32Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 108
04Reasoning
The arbitration clause does not bar review of the Board resolutions, which were a common administrative decision with a public-law element. Individual contractual monetary claims, however, remain subject to arbitration.
¶ 19.9–19.14The court rejected KSRTC's characterisation of the 01.09.2021 communication as an internal recommendation. The letter was addressed to field officers for implementation, specified the concession and its period, and was acted upon, with reduced payments accepted and demands raised only in 2022.
¶ 20.10–20.11, 20.17KSRTC produced no rules or delegation showing that CCG lacked authority.
¶ 20.12–20.13, 23.27The concession therefore extended to sub-lessees under back-to-back terms. It did not extend to GST, which the letter expressly excluded. The claimed 04.09.2021 waiver was unsupported by record.
¶ 20.19–20.23On force majeure, the court held that the pandemic and lockdown fell within Article 8.1.1(c), (e) and (g). However, petitioners did not issue Article 8.3 notices or participate in consultation. Under Central Coalfields, they could not claim independent Article 8 relief.
¶ 21.11–21.22The concession, though, was KSRTC's own decision and could not be defeated by the absence of individual notices. No termination notice was issued under Article 9.4, and the frustration plea failed because the parties had expressly provided for force majeure.
¶ 21.19–21.27On possession, continuing occupiers were not entitled to suspension of licence fee. Under Ramanand, they neither avoided the lease under s.108(B)(e) nor were dispossessed. The position differed for the 7641/2023 petitioner, who surrendered possession, accepted by KSRTC.
¶ 22.5–22.17The 01.09.2021 concession was an acted-upon representation. Its retrospective withdrawal in March 2022, for a period already ended, without notice or hearing, was unsustainable under legitimate expectation and estoppel. The 2024 resolution suffered the same defect.
¶ 23.12–23.18, 23.23–23.24, 23.33The Article 14 plea failed as an independent ground because the first- and second-wave concessions were separate decisions and no comparator was shown.
¶ 23.31–23.32The quashed licence-fee component could not be used to withhold or forfeit deposits, and surrendered or vacated premises entitled petitioners to refund after lawful adjustments.
¶ 24.5–24.8Interest was set at 6% p.a.
¶ 24.9–24.1305Holding
The writ petitions are maintainable insofar as they challenge the Board resolutions on public-law grounds. The individual contractual claims remain subject to arbitration.
¶ 19.14The 01.09.2021 communication was a binding administrative concession for April–June 2021 (70% reduction for April and June, 100% for May). It applied to sub-lessees but not to GST.
¶ 20.24–20.25The pandemic constituted force majeure, but the petitioners did not comply with Article 8.3 procedure, and Article 9.4 was not invoked.
¶ 21.29–21.30Continuing occupiers cannot claim suspension under s.108 TPA, but the concession is subject to the findings below.
¶ 22.16The resolutions of 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 and the consequential demands are quashed only insofar as they recover the licence-fee component of the April–June 2021 concession. GST and dues for other periods remain recoverable.
¶ 23.34–23.37W.P. 35467/2025 (KSMZ): Partly allowed. Notices dated 18.08.2025, 01.09.2025 and 16.10.2025 are quashed for the licence fee of ₹37,17,642. They are undisturbed as to GST (₹6,69,176) and other periods. W.P. 10460/2022 and 13395/2022: Partly allowed. The letter dated 06.04.2022 and consequential notices are quashed for the withdrawn licence-fee component. They are undisturbed as to GST and other periods. W.P. 20426/2022: Partly allowed. Annexure-F is quashed for the licence-fee component. Respondents are to refund petitioners 9 and 10's deposits after lawful adjustment, with 6% p.a. simple interest. W.P. 7641/2023: Partly allowed. The demand of 03.05.2022 and resolutions of 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 are quashed for the licence-fee component. Respondents must refund ₹22,38,596 after lawful adjustment, with 6% p.a. simple interest from 01.07.2022. W.P. 27997/2023: Partly allowed. Respondents may not adjust the ₹6,68,668 deposit against the quashed April–June 2021 licence-fee arrears, but may adjust other lawful dues. All other demands are not interfered with. Pending applications are disposed of.
¶ 25.1(vi)–(vii)Original Court PDF
G DAMODARvsKARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
